US Supreme Court Flashcards
How many cases are SCOTUS requested to review every year?
Over 7,000
How many cases do SCOTUS review a year?
100-150
What is judicial review?
The process by which the Supreme Court decides whether a law or government action is constitutional
How many justices are on the Supreme Court?
9
Why does the Supreme Court have enormous power in the US?
Constitutional sovereignty
How long are justices’ tenures?
For life
Who nominates Supreme Court justices?
The president
What factors will the president consider when choosing a Supreme Court nominee?
- Judicial experience and legal knowledge
- Professional reputation
- Share a similar political belief
What conservative legal group helped Trump choose his Supreme Court nominees?
The Federalist Society
Why do presidents have to ensure their pick for the judiciary will have widespread support?
Nominations must be confirmed by the Senate
Example of the White House failing to uncover a SCOTUS nominee’s controversial background
In 1987, Reagan announced his nominee, Douglas Ginsburg, however it was later uncovered that he had used marijuana while a law professor
What is the Senate Judiciary Committee?
A standing committee in the Senate which has the job of considering Supreme Court nominations. It conducts hearings and then votes whether to recommend the nominee or not.
What court have 8/9 Supreme Court Justices previously come from?
the Court of Appeals
Example of a Supreme Court judge who had never been a judge before?
Elena Kagan - had previously worked in the Justice Department
Does the Senate Judiciary Committee’s vote have any significance?
While it is only a recommendation, it normally signifies how the Senate will end up voting
How did Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s Judiciary Committee vote compare to her Senate vote?
Received unanimous support in her recommendary vote
Passed 96-3 in the Senate
How did Clarence Thomas’s Judiciary Committee vote compare to his Senate vote?
Received 7-7 in his recommendary vote
Passed 52-48 in the Senate
Why, until 2013, did Supreme Court nominees need over 60 votes to secure nomination?
Opposition could filibuster the proceedings, and 60 votes are needed for a cloture
What is the filibuster?
A tactic used in the Senate to prevent a vote - there is limited time allowed for voting so senators will aim to use up all this time through debating
What is a cloture?
The process for ending a filibuster - A simple majority is needed to stop a senator talking and allow the vote
When was the filibuster removed for Senate judiciary appointment confirmations?
2013 by the Democrats
What is the significance of removing the filibuster for Senate judiciary appointments?
A nominee can pass with the support of only one party
Who was the first Supreme Court nominee (in recent history) to not receive a single vote from the minority party in their confirmation?
Amy Coney Barrett, 2020
When was the last time the Senate voted to reject a nominee?
1987
When was the last time a SCOTUS nomination was withdrawn by the president?
2005
Why did the Republican Senate refuse to hold hearings for Merrick Garland in 2016?
As there was to be an election later that year, they suggested the new president should have the right to choose their nominee
Why was the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett controversial?
They nominated Amy Coney Barrett weeks before the 2020 election, going back on the precedent they set of not allowing new appointments in election years
Which president nominated Clarence Thomas?
George H W Bush
Why was Clarence Thomas’ nomination controversial?
He had serious accusations of sexual harassment, which he denied, suggesting it was a racially motivated attack
How many Democrats supported Thomas in the Senate vote?
11
How many Democrats supported Thomas in the Senate vote?
11