Unit 2 - Criminological theories - 2.2 Describe individualistic theories of criminality Flashcards
Psychodynamic theories - Psychoanalysis
According to Sigmund Freud, what determines our personality and future behaviour?
Our childhood
What three elements make up the human personality?
The Id, The ego and The super ego
What is the Id?
Located in the unconscious, instinctive, ‘animal’ part of the mind. It contains powerful, selfish, pleasure-seeking needs and drives such as food, sex and sleep. The Id is governed by the ‘pleasure principle’ - the blind desire to satisfy urges at any cost. If we acted on these urges whenever we felt them it would lead to anti-social or criminal behaviour
What is the Ego?
Freud saw our behaviour as the result of the struggle between the Id and the Superego. The ego’s role is to strike a balance between their conflicting demands. The ego is driven by the ‘reality principle’ - it learns from our experiences in the real world, actions have consequences. The ego seeks to control the Ids urges while still finding ways to satisfy them
What is the Superego?
Contains our conscience or moral rules, which we learn through interactions with our parents. Through socialisation, the child learns its parents idea of right and wrong and the superego develops as a sort of ‘nagging parent’. If we act in contrary to the superego it punishes us with feelings of guilt and anxiety
According to psychoanalytic theories, what causes anti-social behaviour?
Abnormal relationship with parents eg neglect or excessively strict parenting
What can these abnormal relationships cause for children’s superegos?
They can get a weak, over-harsh or deviant superego
What is a weakly developed superego?
The individual will feel less guilt about an anti-social action and less inhibition about acting on Id’s urges
What is a too harsh and unforgiving superego?
Creates deep-seated guilt in the individuals, who then craves punishment as a release for these feelings. The person may engage in repeat offending in order to be punished
What is a deviant superego?
A child is successfully socialised but into a deviant moral code. A son may have a perfectly good relationship with his criminal father and so he internalises his father’s criminal values. As a result, his superego would not inflict guilt feelings on him for contemplating criminal acts
Psychodynamic theories - Bowlby’s maternal deprivation theory
According to Bowlby, what causes deviant or anti-social behaviour?
Maternal deprivation. In his eyes a child needs a close relationship with its primary carer from birth to the age of 5 in order to develop normally
What can happen to a child if they do not form the correct attachment at an early age?
The child will not be able to form meaningful emotional relationships with others. This is known as ‘affectionless psychopathy’. In some cases this can lead to criminal behaviour.
Briefly outline the evidence that supports Bowlby’s theory
Study of 44 juvenile thieves who had been referred to a child guidance clinic. 39% of the thieves had suffered from maternal deprivation before the age of 5, compared to 5% of control group of non-delinquents
Psychological theories - Eysenck’s personality theory
According to Eysenck, what is criminality the result of?
For Eysenck criminality is a result of a particular personality type
What two dimensions is our personality made up of?
Extraversion versus introversion (E)
Neuroticism versus emotional stability (N)
What are the 3 dimensions of personality identified by Eysenck?
Extraverted, Introverted and Neurotic
Outline Extraverted
Outgoing, sociable, impulsive, carefree, optimistic, aggressive, short tempered and unreliable
Outline Introverted
Reserved, inward looking, thoughtful, serious, quiet, self-controlled, reliable and permissive
Outline Neurotic
Anxious, moody, depressed, prone to overreacting
Describe the Eysenck personality questionnaire
Eysenck devised a questionnaire to measure people’s personality traits, ranking them on a E scale and N scale. For example, people with a high E score are very extroverted and people with a low E score are very introverted. Eysenck found that most people have personalities around the middle on both scales. However, criminals score high on both E scale and N scale. In other words, criminals tend to be strongly extraverted and neurotic
What is meant by conditioning?
Some psychologists argue that through experience we learn to seek pleasure and aim to avoid pain. For example, if we misbehave we are punished and so we learn to stop doing it as to avoid further punishment. This process is called ‘conditioning’. Eysenck argues that we learn through conditioning, but some individuals inherit a nervous system that causes them to develop a criminal personality
Briefly explain Eysenck’s argument that genetic inheritance can cause a criminal personality in the case of Extraverts
Have a nervous system that needs high levels of stimulation from their environment so they are constantly seeking excitement. This leads to impulsive, rule-breaking behaviour. In turn, this is likely to lead to punishment.
Briefly explain Eysenck’s argument that genetic inheritance can cause a criminal personality in the case of Neurotics
Harder to condition into following society’s rules because their high anxiety levels prevent them from learning from punishment for their mistakes
Briefly describe the additional personality dimension of psychoticism
In his later research, Eysenck added psychoticism (P) as a further personality dimension. People with a high P score are more likely to engage in criminality. They tend to be solitary misfits who are cruel, insensitive, aggressive and lacking in empathy. High P can overlap with serious psychiatric illnesses like schizophrenia
Learning theories
Describe 3 key features of learning theories
- Criminal behaviour is learned behaviour
- We learn this behaviour from family and peer groups (social environment)
- The key role of reinforcement and punishment in the learning process
Learning theories - Sutherland’s differential association theory
According to Sutherland, where do individuals learn criminal behaviour?
Family and peer groups (including working groups)
What are the two factors that can result in criminal behaviour according to Sutherland?
Imitation and Learned attitudes
Briefly describe Imitation
Individuals can acquire criminal skills and techniques through observing those around them