UK Politics - Political Parties Flashcards

1
Q

What are the functions of political parties?

A
  • Have several functions, but they mainly seek to win office and hold power, done by holding a set of beliefs that translate into specific policies - although the ideologies of the main parties have not changed much over time, policy has constantly been reinterpreted
  • Conservative Party was traditionally a patriotic party, which moved from strong support for the British Empire to Euroscepticism and wariness of EU sovereignty
  • The Labour party has traditionally been the party of the working classes and wealth redistribution, and this has become a message of social justice
  • Parties cannot stand still and fossilise, but they also cannot become mere opportunistic vote-gathering machines
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

The origins of the Conservative Party

A
  • The modern Conservative party dates from 1834
  • It is the most successful modern British political party being in government for approximately two-thirds of the period since 1900.
  • It initially drew it’s core support from the landed aristocracy
  • Core principles included defence of the privileges of the Church of England and opposition to political reform.
  • The development of the party can be broken down into four main strands, all of which have left an imprint on the Conservative party of the 21st century.
    1) One-nation conservatism
    2) Butskellite pragmatism and consensus
    3) Traditional values
    4) Thatcherism
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Conservative strand 1 - One-nation Conservatism

A
  • This is commonly associated with Victorian Prime Minister Benjamin Disraeli.
  • It focuses on the duty of those with power and privilege to use this wisely and unite the nation by way of moderate social reforms and patriotism. It represented a form of pragmatic self-interested paternalism, which Disraeli summed up with the words ‘the palace is not safe when the cottage is not happy’.
  • Echoes of one-nation conservatism were seen in David Cameron’s ‘Big Society’ and in
    Boris Johnson’s: ‘members of our new one-nation government, a people’s government’ - embraced the state protecting the vulnerable through public services, without penalising the rich with high income tax rates or seeking to dismantle free market capitalism and significantly redistribute wealth.
  • Privilege and wealth inequality are fine and natural but with them comes duty and responsibility
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Conservative party strand 2 - Butskellite Pragmatism and Consensus

A

Butskellite -
- Term used to describe the postwar consensus between Labour and the Conservatives that endured until the 1970s. It was named after Rab Butler, a leading Conservative politician in the 1950s and Hugh Gaitskell, Labour leader between 1955-1963.

What impact did Labour’s 1945 election victory and the establishment of the Welfare State have on the Conservative party?
- They shifted further from the centre and accepted the bulk of Labour’s social reforms.

What happened to politics throughout the 1950s and 60s?
- There were large areas of consensus in many key policy areas between Labour and Conservatives.

How did Butskellite conservatism impact views regarding Europe?
- It was a pro-European outlook, and this lead to Conservatives being keen to join the European Economic Community or Common Market - Heath, a Conservative Prime Minister, led the UK into the EEC in 1973, whilst Eurosceptics were more generally located in the Labour benches, despite Labour PM Wilson attempting to negotiate the UK’s entry in 1967.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Conservative strand 3 - Traditional Values

A

What are the traditional values which the Conservative party supports?
- Supporting the traditional nuclear family and the institution of marriage, as well as maintaining a firm line on immigration policy.

Where can echoes of these traditional values be seen?
- John Major: Back to Basics speech; self-discipline, respect for the law, consideration to others, accepting responsibility for yourself and your family an not shuffling it off on other people and the state
- Section 28: Banned the promotion of homosexuality in schools (1988).
- Theresa May: Promise as Home Secretary to create a ‘hostile environment’ for illegal immigrants.
- Sunday Trading: Opposition to this and its extension - a Tory backbench revolt in 2016 derailed attempts to relax the Sunday Trading hours.
- Enoch Powell and the ‘Rivers of Blood’ speech: Critics have implicated this type of conservatism as embracing elements of racism.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Conservative strand 4 - Thatcherism

A
  • Based on Pragmatism and ‘good sense’ alongside a suspicion of revolutionary and radical ideas.

When did Thatcherism come to dominate the Conservative party and with whom is it most closely associated?
- Came to dominate throughout the 1980s and 1990s associated mostly with Thatcher and it was a far more ideological outlook than previous forms of conservatism and represented conviction over compromise.

What did Thatcher see herself on a crusade to achieve? (for individuals and government)
- Individual freedom, especially economic, to slay the ‘dragons’ of overly powerful trade unions and to emphasise self-help and personal responsibility. The aim was to roll back the frontiers of the state, denationalise most government-owned industries and encourage council tenants to buy their own houses. This was to be accompanied by lower taxes, particularly on income.

What did Thatcher achieve in 1984-5:
- After the prolonged and bitter miner’s strike Thatcher’s government broke the power of the one of the country’s most powerful trade unions, the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM), a feat which had eluded previous Prime Minister’s, including her predecessor Heath.

In what ways was Thatcher’s foreign policy more assertive:
- The Falklands War: oversaw victory in 1982
- Cold War: Worked closely with Ronald Reagan and the US
- European Union: Won a hard-fought financial rebate from the EU, while also sowing the seeds for more recent Tory Euroscepticism. Her famous 1988 Bruges speech stated that ‘We have not successfully rolled back the frontiers of state in Britain to see them reimposed at a European level’. She was a strong advocate of the European single market.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What is the modern conservative party like?

A

Led by Cameron, May and Johnson, contains elements of all 4 strands of conservatism, which can be seen through the 2019 manifesto (Get Brexit Done - Unleash Britain’s Potential)

Manifesto pledges:
- Extra funding for the NHS, with 50,000 more nurses and 50 million more GP surgery appointments per year; associated with the Butskellite consensus - acceptance and expansion of a key plank of the Welfare State
- 20,000 additional police officers and tougher sentencing - traditional values conservatism
- An Australian style points-based system to control immigration - traditional values
- A promise not to raise the rate of income tax, VAT or National Insurance - Thatcherism
- Get Brexit done and remove the power of institutions such as the European Court of Justice - One Nation conservatism / Thatcherism - strong emphasis on the sovereignty of the nation state
- Maintain the triple lock on pensions - One Nation
- Make Britain a world leader in tackling plastics pollution and creating an independent Office for Environmental Protection - arguably, tackling climate change and environmental issues is a mixture of Butskellite consensus and one nation
- Keep the minimum voting age at 18 - traditional values
- Everyone who can work, should work, continue the rollout of Universal Credit and crack down on benefit fraud - Thatcherism; belief in self-help, reducing the welfare dependency culture

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Divisions in the Conservative Party

A
  • Before the 2019 election, Europe and the European Union was the main fracture line of the party, with successive Tory leaders by the division between Leavers, Remainers, Eurosceptics and Europhiles - through the 2016 referendum, Cameron looked to settle the issue
  • However, the narrow Leave victory only led to deeper division as opposing factions of the party fought over the terms of any negotiated deal, and May attempted to placate both sides but saw rejection of her deals on several occasions in the Commons and she had a record number of ministerial resignations
  • The emphatic victory of Johnson in 2019 began the end of this division
  • Conservatives have also been divided over social issues - a majority of his own MPs rejected Cameron’s bill to legalise same-sex marriage in 2013, and it only passed because of support from opposition parties
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

The development of the Labour party

A
  • The Labour party can trace its origins back to the Farringdon Street Conference of 1900
  • The early Labour party was an alliance between the trade union movement and socialist groups
  • Its initial aim was the independent representation in parliament of the working man
  • The party formally assumed a socialist position in 1918 with the adoption of Clause IV
  • Clause IV was a commitment to nationalisation of industry, the abolition of capitalism and a key redistribution of wealth
  • Although this was the language of communism and revolution, the Labour Party has always been a parliamentary and constitutional political movement
  • It did not advocate violent revolution but change from within
  • The modern Labour party is the sum of several principles and values with the inevitable internal tensions and factionalism
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

The origins of the Labour Party

A
  • 1900 conference between trade union representatives and socialists, and looked to represent the working class
  • Driven by ethical appeal of socialism
  • New movement in politics, inspired by unions and idealism - leaflets and slips were given out, with sub slogans such as workers of the world unite, and socialism - the way of the world
  • Young trade union representatives were avid supporters of the Independent Labour Party, and gave up weekends to support socialist messaging - this was viewed as a threat to the power of the upper classes and the union of the large section of the working class population was frightening
    ILP - political union of socialists and trade unions
  • View of securing better representation of the interests of labour in the House of Commons, and asked the committee to invite working class organisations for the securing of an increased amount of Labour representatives in the Commons - small majority gave a push for representation; 1900 conference was the point of formation for the Labour party, and the trade unions joined with the 3 socialist societies of the ILP, Social Democrat Federation and the Fabians
  • The delegates of the different parties and unions decided that class prejudice should not make them prisoners - working men are not the only people who can represent the working class; new party recognises the class war with socialism as they aim
  • Policy looked to embrace cooperation and promoting legislation that benefited the working class - Labour Representation Committee that represented the different factions of socialism including the unions, Fabians, SDF and ILP
  • McDonald - appointment as secretary of the Committee and saw possibilities of the new movement, and organised a Labour party to grow from this and gain affiliation with the trade unions
  • Aimed to have annual conferences to get representation of Labour - the party struggled initially to be unified due to the range of unions and groups, and the argument over the background of their MPs
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Labour from 1945 onwards

A
  • 1945 Labour Party Conference - a young military man, Healey, stated the new campaign for socialism
  • An election held after V-Day; forced by his Labour coalition to allow the socialist say
    Clement Attlee was the Labour leader at the time; Churchill struggled over and over again to appeal to his voters on his campaign trail and had no connection to the modern world
  • The Labour Party won the election with a majority of 200 seats, with the aim to create a new Britain; established council housing, NHS, welfare state, free education - aim of socialism is to give greater freedom to the individual
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Branches of the Labour Party - Economic Socialism

A

What did Clement Atlee’s post war Labour government establish?
First majority Labour government - established the welfare state.

What industries were taken into state ownership?
Coal mining, iron and steel and even the former travel agent Thomas Cook.

What industries were nationalised in 1977?
Major parts of shipbuilding and aerospace industries.

What happened to these industries during the Thatcher years? (bonus point - what is this policy known as?)
The advent of the Thatcher years saw all of these industries be sold and privatised, with Blair and Brown choosing to renationalise them.

What did Jeremy Corbyn’s 2017 & 2019 Labour manifestos promise?
Partial renationalisation of these services.

What does Labour’s commitment to nationalisation reflect?
Historic pledge to redistribute wealth for the many not the few, and to put people before profit

What have the elections of Corbyn and Starmer shown about Labour’s position?
Marked a clear shift towards a more left-wing position under Corbyn and a return to the centre with Starmer.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Branches of the Labour Party - Trade Unionism

A

What key workers rights is the Labour party expected to protect and advance?
The right to strike and trade union recognition in the workplace.

How did Trade Unions support the Labour party?
Supplied the bulk of Labour’s funding, sponsored some MPs and had seats in the national ruling executive.

How did the influence of Trade Unions shift in the 1980s and 90s?
It waned due to deindustrialisation and a shift in the economy away from manufacturing to a far less unionised service sector.

What reforms did the Conservatives introduce in the 1980s to weaken the power of Trade Unions?
Designed to make unions more democratic and so this made industrial action harder to take, therefore weakening their powers of protest.

How has Trade Union influence been affected by the following Labour leaders?

Blair/Brown: Did not reverse the Conservative reforms - weakened unions
Corbyn: Unions enjoyed increased influence and access to the leadership. Unite’s general secretary, McCluskey, was particularly close to Corbyn.
Starmer: Union influence has again been reduced under Starmer.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Branches of the Labour Party -Global Internationalism

A

What has Labour’s long term position on global conflict been?
Commitment to peace and disarmament alongside resisting fascism and racism worldwide. Ramsey McDonald, Labour’s first Prime Minister, remained a pacifist during the First World War.

Give examples of how this commitment has been shown throughout the 20th century.
- First World War: McDonald remained a pacifist.
- Nuclear Weapons: Grassroots movement opposed to nuclear weapons and advocating nuclear disarmament, briefly embracing this policy officially
- Right-wing dictatorships: Fighting alongside Republicans during the Spanish Civil War (1936-39) or campaigning against apartheid in South Africa

How do Labour’s policies on internationalism link to their views on socialism and destroying nationalism?
- They promote a need for workers to show solidarity across national boundaries, with socialists viewing nationalism as a pretext for preserving the capitalist status quo and distracting the masses from revolutionary consciousness.

How do many in the modern Labour movement feel about Europe?
- This attitude is however revised in support of European integration with a strong emphasis on protecting worker’s rights across the EU.

How did Tony Blair weaken this strand of the Labour party? Give a detailed answer.
- His close relationship with George Bush, the Republican president and his support for the ‘War on terror’ with the accompanying military campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan produced deep divisions in the party and large scale backbench rebellions. Blair was pronounced a warmonger by many on the left.

What did Jeremy Corbyn’s election as party leader show and what results did this have?
- Disenchantment with Blair’s ‘Third-Way socialism’ was reflected in Corbyn’s election, as he was a more left wing leader and this led to a swing into more left wing politics for Labour in 2015. This aided Labour in the 2017 election where there was a gain of votes and seats, but the party’s defeat in 2019 led to a resignation of Corbyn as leader and the election of Starmer in 2020, a more mainstream Labour figure and a more centrist stance

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Branches of the Labour Party - Third Way Socialism / New Labour

A

When was the era of ‘New Labour’?
1997 to 2010; it reflected the same help and hindrance that Thatcher’s revolutionary creed had on the Conservatives.

What did Tony Blair intend with his ‘New Labour’ movement? Give a detailed answer.
He intended to modernise and update Labour and move it to the centre ground of electability following its shift to the left under Michael Foot in the 1980s. The emphasis was on triangulation; repositioning Labour in the centre ground, accepting many of the Thatcherite economic policies but retaining Labour’s social values such as justice and fairness for all.

How did Labour shift their position on how social justice would be achieved?
There was less concern about who owned industry and far more emphasis on how profits could be put to good use and achieve an end goal of social justice. More money was pumped into the NHS and education (‘Education, education, education’).

What changes did Blair make to education?
Oversaw the demise of what his key adviser Alastair Campbell called the ‘bog-standard comprehensive’ and instead they focused on specialist schools and colleges outside the direct control of local authorities.

What other key areas did New Labour focus on?
Elimination of child poverty.

How was the Labor party split over Blair’s ‘New Labour’ policies?
This amounted to pragmatic common sense and electoral success for some in the party, with Blair winning 3 consecutive general elections due to his New Labour policies, unprecedented for a Labour leader, but to others his Third Way was a sell-out and a betrayal, with one of his most critical and rebellious backbencher being Jeremy Corbyn.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

How far did New Labour ideologically drift from the roots of Labour? - The divisions during Thatcher

A

Why did the Labour Party split in the early 80s and what were the consequences?
- The social democrats were largely the party of Labour before this time, but the result of Thatcher’s election signified a move to the left with the Democratic Socialists, and the ‘Gang of Four’ left to create the Social Democratic Party, and Foot created a more radical left wing manifesto including increasing income taxes and nuclear disarmament- the divide split the left wing vote, and gave the conservatives a key majority.

How did the UK’s post-industrial society and the pressures of globalisation influence New Labour?
- Living standards have improved and greatly helped post-war reforms and the welfare service, and so the working class could not be relied upon alone - increased globalisation and international competition created greater pressure to make the Uk economy more competitive. Centre left figures argued that high taxes and strict labour laws would not be effective as they would simply move it to another company, and a skilled workforce was more of a priority - Neil Kinnock expelled the wing of Militant Tendency and focused on ideological policy and centrists Labour, as did Blair and Smith rebranding the party

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

How far did New Labour ideologically drift from the roots of Labour? - Blair

A

What was Tony Blair’s ‘Third Way’?
- The combination of thatcherism and socialism with a focus on social justice and economic efficient 0 the aims of socialism were retained but the methods were different, declining class divide, greater quality but instead of nationalisation get privatisation, low taxes not high and retain the free market - economy left to business; created a new political consensus. This was a consensus known as the post-thatcherite consensus, and their approach was to use the profits of the free market to enforce the economy - people could get rich

How did Blair change Clause IV of the Labour Party constitution?
- The need for the enterprise of the market and competition to provide the wealth the nation needs. The New Labour looked to find a Third Way

What did New Labour promise ahead of the ‘97 General Election?
- Promised to keep to the taxation of the previous government and increase public spending by allocating resources better - ran a surplus budget by bringing in more money than was being spent - 418 seat majority showed the popularity of this policy. They cut corporation tax, expanded privatisation and outsourced private companies who competed for contracts. Also used public finance initiatives and then rent these back to the taxpayers - argued as the best way to expand infrastructure without excessive borrowing, and creating a more successful private sector which was more efficient as a buy now pay later promise

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

The policies of New Labour - Economy (similar to Tories), Welfare (similar to Tories), Public Services (similar to Tories)

A

Economy -
- Foundation hospitals - gave managers more independent and power to set contracts and borrow money
- Academies - business can sponsor failing schools
- Universities - tuition fees
- Bank of England - monetary policy

Welfare -
- Similar to the welfare state - no rights without responsibilities - equality of outcome became equality of opportunity and reap the rewards of the free market and workfare programmes tried to reduce unemployment by providing work experience, further education and training, and made work more attractive by offering a minimum wage (minimum Wage Act 1998) and tax credits to help make work more attractive.
- Argued to have used stealth taxes, such as raising taxes on national insurance rates and on the payments made to companies that paid investors. 1997 Windfall tax was a £5 billion tax on the privatised utilities.

Public Services -
- Initially tried to stick to Conservative plans, but this was dumped with healthcare spending doubling between 1999 and 2010 with 85,000 more nurses, 32,000 doctors, 14,000 more police, 36,000 more teachers and 274,000 support staff, with funding doubled.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

New Labour policies - difference to Conservatives

A

Human Rights -
- Passed a number of laws, such as lifting the ban on gay people serving, Civil Partnership Act (2004), Local Government Act (2006) repealed section 28, Sexual Offences Act (2000) equalised age of consent for gay couples, Gender Recognition Act, Equality Employment Act

Authoritarian approach to civil liberties -
- Human Rights Act and Freedom of Information Act
- Introduced anti-terror laws - Anti-terrorism Crime and Security Act (2001) and this allowed indefinite detention without trial for non-British nationals suspected of committing terrorist offenders, prevention of Terrorist Act in 2005, allowing the Home Secretary to control orders on anyone suspected of terrorist related activities, and the Identity Cards Act 2006, introduced new identity cards, linked to a national database allowed to hold 50 categories of information.

Foreign policies -
- Left wing members had long been critical of the EU, but they instead favoured European integration under Blair and followed the Lisbon treaty but did not adopt the Euro. Doubled funding for overseas aid and focused on humanitarian intervention and should uphold human rights internationally using the military, worked with Bush and supported controversial laws that greatly divided the party. More internationalist.

Constitutional reform -
- Human Rights, Devolution, Modernisation of political institutions, Greater democracy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

2019 Labour Manifesto Policies

A

Green Industrial Revolution -
- Create 1 million jobs in the UK to transform the industry, energy, transport, agriculture and our buildings while restoring nature.
- Prioritise sustainability.
- Integrated Transport Systems.
- National Transformation Fund of £400 billion
- Prohibit foxhunting and the end of the cull of badgers.

Rebuilding public services -
- Universal public services provided through general taxation and free at the point of use for all, increasing the tax payment for those earning more than 80,000 a year
- NHS and Social care - Repair the health services by refilling the vacancies (100,000) but ending privatisation and funding cuts - increased investment
- National Education Service - provide free education, prioritise all types of learning, skill and knowledge including technical, vocational academic and creative - abolish tuition fees and bring back maintenance grants
- Police and communities - invest in police and address causes of crime
- Justice - break cycles of recidivism of poverty inequality and crime
- Community and local authority - reverse austerity for local government and aim to restore council spending powers to 2010 levels
- Fire - reopen fire stations and restore jobs to help improve response times
- Digital - free full fibre broadband by 2030
- Culture - expand careers in this industry
- Media - preserve the future of broadcasting companies and free TV licences for over 75s
- Sport - changes to football management, curb gambling advertisement in sports, preserve civic societies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

2019 Labour Manifesto cont.

A

Tackling poverty and inequality -
- Work - work should provide a decent life for all, guaranteeing not just dignity and respect in the workplace but also income and leisure time to allow for a fulfilling life outside of it
- Tackle structural causes of in-work-poverty - Living Wage of £10 per hour and cap the amount that can be paid in overdraft fees or interest; flexible working, statutory maternity pay from 9-12 months, 4 week paternity leave
- 32 weeks of working hours, enforcement of worker’s rights through a Worker’s Protection Agency and Labour Courts
- Women and equalities - Labour is the party of equality, committed to achieving a world free from all forms of bigotry and discrimination, whether campaigning on the streets or passing legislation in government, Labour is the only party to stand for social justice - new Women and - Equalities department, full-time secretary of state, ratify Istanbul Convention on preventing domestic abuse, protect HRA and ECHR and the ILO Convention on Violence and Harassment at work
- Close the gender pay gap, end politics of hate, address systematic racism, ensures independence and equality for disabled people and update the Equality Act, national LGBT+ Action Plan, tackle the rough sleeping crisis in the UK, mandatory LGBT+ inclusive lessons and sex education
- Migration - Humane immigration system, end the hostile environment of the Windrush Scandal, stop deportation, follow human rights, meet the skills and labour shortages that exist in public services
- Social Security - same esteem as health and education systems - National Strategy for Childhood focusing on health, security, well-being and poverty and give effect to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
- Universal credit; will be scrapped and guarantee a minimum standard of living, stop benefit cap and two child limit and remove 300,000 people from poverty
- Pensions; correct injustices of women’s pension ages
- Housing; renewment of the 1945 commitment to a housing programme with maximum practical speed until every family in Britain has a good standard of accommodation, increased council housing and a new social house building programme, cap rent in line with inflation, solve homelessness
- Constitutional issues - repeal the Fixed Term Parliaments Act (2011), investment in devolved regions

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

2019 Labour Manifesto pt 3

A

The final say on Brexit -
- Give the people a final say with another public vote
- Ruled out a no deal brexit and remove Johnson’s deal
- A new deal to protect jobs, rights, and the environment. Avds and hard border in NI and to ensure no change in the status or sovereignty of Gibraltar
- A permanent and comprehensive UK-wide customs union, which is vital to protect our manufacturing industry and allows the UK to benefit from joint UK-EU trade deals, and is backed by businesses and trade unions.
- Close alignment with the Single Market – ensuring we have a strong future economic relationship with the EU that can support UK businesses.
- Dynamic alignment on workers’ rights, consumer rights and environmental protections so that UK standards keep pace across Europe as a minimum, allowing the UK to lead the way, not fall behind.
- Continued participation in EU agencies and funding programmes, including in such vital areas of co-operation as the environment, scientific research and culture.
- Clear commitments on future security arrangements, including access to the European Arrest Warrant and shared databases, making people safer at home and abroad.

A new internationalism -
- International peace and security as a primary objective of foreign policy
- Recognise and correct injectices of the past
- Reform international rules based order to secure justice and accountability for breaches of human right s
- Rebuild climate expertise and negotiate and deliver more ambitious targets
- Comprehensive peace in the Middle East based on a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine with no military solution
- Lawful action to counter and confront all forms of terrorism
- Prevent conflict by investing in local capacities for peacebuilding in areas of conflict
- Increase funding for peacekeeping operations to £100 million
- Ensure all medicines developed with the support of uk taxpayer money are accessible to those in the global south
- Reject trade agreements that undermine labour standards or environmental protections

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

The 2019 Conservative manifesto

A

https://www.conservatives.com/our-plan
- Brexit - Get Brexit done
- NHS & Social Care - extra funding, 50,000 more nurses and 50 million more GP appointments a year (NHS failing, industrial action)
- Education - millions more invested every week into science, schools, apprenticeships and infrastructure while controlling debt (industrial action), strengthen academic freedom and strengthen global influence of higher education
- Support for working families
- Policing & Crime - 20,000 more police and tougher sentencing for criminals
- Immigration - an Australian style points-based system to control immigration
- Local communities & Housing - Levelling Up the North, fixed mortgage rates, more homes to local families and extend Right to Buy and Help to Buy schemes
- Transport & Infrastructure - industrial action, Northern Powerhouse Rail to connect Leeds, invest in the Midlands Rail Hub and upgrade bus, tram and train services to the level of London
- Business & Enterprise - Will not raise the rate of income tax, VAT or National Insurance (broken), expand start-up loans, encourage investment in physical building and equipment
- The strength of the Union - invest across the union, stand up or Northern Ireland to re-establish the Assembly (success), respect the independence referendum result for Scotland and protect democracy
- Defence - support our veterans and investing in the men and women of today’s armed forces, put national security first and promote the values of freedom and human rights
- The environment - Reaching net zero by 2050 with investment in clean energy solutions and green infrastructure to reduce carbon emissions and pollution

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

The Liberal Democrats - Key Facts

A
  • Formed in 1988 after a merger of the Liberal Party and the
    Social Democratic Party.
  • The Lib-Dems have third party status in the UK.
  • They have never held power on their own and the closest they came was the coalition government of 2010-15 when Nick Clegg served as deputy prime minister under David Cameron.
  • Whilst they they do have strong and consistent support from some they are often seen as a ‘protest vote’ party.
  • Today the Lib-Dems are fundamentally a progressive centrist party with a strong commitment to Europe and the EU, a concern for constitutional reform, especially that of the voting system and an emphasis on human rights and freedoms. Many members also pursue green environmental policies.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Q

The Liberals as part of the LD party

A
  • A dominant force in 19th century politics and until the 1920s had been the main rival to the Conservative party.
  • William Gladstone served 4 terms as Liberal Prime Minister in the 19th century.
  • Stood for free trade, religious tolerance, self-help and a more ethical foreign policy.
  • Traditional supporters included Christian nonconformists & the skilled working classes.
  • The Liberals suffered a serious split over the issue of Irish Home rule in 1885/6 and further divisions were created in the World War I coalition government.
  • The rise of the Labour party in the 1920s & 30s took the working class vote away from the Liberals.
    The Conservatives drew away it’s middle class supporters over fears of socialism and revolution.
    By the 1930s the Liberals were relegated to third party status.
26
Q

Social Democrat Party - LD

A
  • Founded in 1981 by a number of centrist Labour politicians and one Conservative MP who were concerned by how far to the left the Labour party had drifted.
  • The SDP disliked Labours commitment to unilateral nuclear disarmament and withdrawal from the EEC.
  • The Liberal party and the SDP made a pact in the 1983 & 1987 elections agreeing to fight elections on a common platform with joint candidates.
  • The two parties finally merged to form the Liberal Democrats in 1988.
27
Q

The 2019 Liberal Democrat Manifesto - Stop Brexit, The economy and education and skills

A

Stop Brexit:
- Every vote for the Liberal Democrats is a vote to stop Brexit and stay in the European Union.
- For over 3 years Lib Dems tried to stop Brexit. They campaigned to stay in the EU in 2016 and they believed that the UK is stronger as part of the EU.
- They wanted to do another referendum.
They said they would use the £50 billion to use on:
- Improving services like healthcare and education
- Help everyone to be treated fairly and have the same chances in life.

The economy:
- They stated that they would give every adult £10,000 to spend on education and training.
- They had a plan to invest in climate friendly infrastructure and technology and create new green businesses and jobs,
- Investing £130 billion in infrastructure - upgrading our transport and energy systems, building schools, hospitals and homes, empowering all regions and nations of the UK and developing the climate friendly infrastructure of the future.
- Enabling an adaptable, future focused workforce.

Education & Skills:
- Will give free childcare to all children over 9 months old if their parents work.
- Pay for 20,000 more teachers
- Fix the school and college buildings that need repairs.
- End SATs.
- Better information to show how well schools are achieving.

28
Q

The 2019 Liberal Democrat Manifesto - Green policy, health and fairness

A

Green society and green economy:
- Reduction on the use of petrol, coal, and gas that damage the environment.
- Start a 10 year plan to stop damage to the environment.
- Make sure all homes in Britain have insulation by 2030
- Ensure most electricity in the UK is made by the wind, sun and sea by 2030
- Stop all fracking
- Keep the countryside, sea, plants, animals and other things on earth safe.
- Plant 60 million trees a year
- Make sure all trains and new cars in Britain run on electricity.

Health and social care:
- Raising £7bn a year in additional revenue through 1p on income tax for the NHS and social care
- Treating mental health with the same urgency as physical health
- Reforming the Health and Social Care Act as recommended by the NHS to make it more effective
- Use £10bn of their capital fund to invest in equipment, hospitals, mental health services buildings
- Establish a cross party health and social care convention
- Make prescriptions for those with chronic neonatal health condition available for free on the NHS
- Ensure that LGBTQ+ inclusive mental health services receive funding and support
- Train more GPs and make more appropriate use of other healthcare professionals
- Introduce a legal, regulated market for cannabis

A fair society:
- Reduce the wait for first benefits from 5 weeks to 5 days
- Build 100,000 social homes every year
- Give people the right to have food by law
- Ensure local services are in place to support young people in helping them stay away from violence
- Police to work in local areas to stop violence
- Creating a £50bn Regional Rebalancing Programme to address the historic investment disparities between our nations and regions
- Retain the Triple Lock on the basic state pension
- Set up a £2 billion Rural Services Fund to enable the co-location of services in local hubs around existing local infrastructure.

29
Q

The 2019 Liberal Democrat Manifesto - equality, better politics and better world

A

Freedom, Rights & Equality:
- Human rights are rights that we all have, and the LibDems will stand up for human rights, working to keep important human rights laws that the UK and Europe have made
- Stop people being treated unfairly when they try to come to Britain to work, study or live
- Giving those escaping war, violence and other issues the right to work 3 months after they request to stay
- Over the next 10 years, the aim is to help 10,000 of these children to stay in Britain

Better politics:
- Proportional representation system - argue it is fairer and no votes are wasted
- Give votes to those who are 16 or over, British people who live in other countries and people from other European Union countries who want to live in the UK for a long time
- More power to other parts of Britain, this will give people in local areas more say in important decisions on how services run and how to spend tax money

Better world:
- Stand up for human rights, help people who are very poor, save the environment and keep us all safe
- We will help countries work together to solve problems, instead of them working on their own
- We will support organisations in the world that work together on human rights, like the United Nations (UN)
- We will keep spending some of Britain’s money to help poorer countries - financial aid
- We will stop selling weapons to Saudi Arabia and other countries that don’t look after people’s rights
Work with the Alliance Party

30
Q

The current state of the Liberal Democrat party

A
  • Although the coalition government was stable and the imprint of Liberal Democrat influence could be seen in some of its policies, the party was heavily punished in the polls in 2015 - in 2010, they won 57 seats whereas in 2015 it crashed to just 8 and they only recovered slightly by gaining 12 seats in 2017 and dropping back to 11 in 2019 when party leader Jo Swinson lost her East Dunbartonshire seat
  • This was despite the defections to the party of several MPs following the creation and subsequent demise of the Change UK party - the overall vote share the party achieved did however increase
  • In part, electoral woes have come down to opposition to the 2010-2015 coalition government which saw the abandonment of several key policies such as abolishing student tuition fees
  • Some critics also blame the campaign shortcomings of leader Jo Swinson (‘it feels like she is running a presidential campaign but no one really knows her’)
  • Unlike in the early 1980s, the Liberal Democrats proved unable to benefit from Labour’s lunge to the left or the Tories adoption of a more emphatically pro-Brexit position by the time of the 2019 election
  • Also - the creation of a coalition with the Conservatives was seen as a betrayal of the left wing, with core voters defecting to Labour
31
Q

The structure and function of political parties

A
  • Need structure in order to perform key roles, including manifesto creation and formulating policy, selecting candidates and choosing a leader - how this is done in each party reflects their historical and political outlook
  • The most open and democratic party in the UK is generally the Liberal Democrat party and the party with the least scope for direct membership participation is the Conservatives and Labour drifts in the middle of the two
  • All three parties have however showed a tendency recently towards centralising power in the hands of the leadership, while the Conservatives have moved towards slightly more internal party democracy in recent years e.g. party members, not Tory MPs, now decide the leader of the party in the final round
32
Q

The structure and policy making of the Conservative party

A

Local-level structure
- Local Conservative Associations, sometimes with ward branches below them

Local-level policy making:
- Local Conservative Associations play a key role in organising the grassroots of the party and in planning local campaigning and selecting candidates, although less autonomy in the latter than previously

National Level Structure:
- The National HQ is Conservative Campaign Headquarters at Millbank, Westminster. It was previously based in Smith Square London, as the Conservative Central Office. Day-to-day running of the party machine is undertaken by the Board of the Conservative Party, made up of representatives from each section of the party, including MPs and local associations
- Only 3 of the approximate 18 members are from the grassroots party overseen by the Annual Convention

National Level Policy Making Systems:
- The Conservative Policy Forum was set up in 1998 to enable more grassroots participation in policy making, although its role is advisory as opposed to binding - in general, the Tories have left the writing of their manifesto to their leader and trusted advisors. Major could boast that the winning of the 1992 election manifesto was all him but much of the 2019 manifesto was co-written by Rachel Wolf, education and innovation adviser for Number 10 during Cameron’s premiership

33
Q

The structure and policy making of the Labour party

A

Local-level structure:
Each constituency has a Constituency Labour Party and many also have a council ward level Branch Labour Parties

Local policy making:
- CLP takes the lead in local and national election campaigns

National structure:
- Labour’s national base is in Victoria St, London, and day-to-day activity is conducted by the National Executive Committee (NEC) who enforce party discipline and can, on occasion, expel members for breaking party rules. It has the final say over the selection of parliamentary candidates and comprises around 40 members.
- Automatically includes representatives from the parliamentary party, trade unions, CLPs, local councillors and Young Labour.
- Elections to the NEC are often highly functionalized with by-elections for two CLP reps held in April 2020 regarded as a victory for Starmer, as candidates backed by the moderate groups of Progress and Labour First triumphing over Corbynite candidates

National-level policy making:
Until the 1990s, the annual conference was the sovereign policy-making body, but its role has since diminished

34
Q

The structure and policy making of the Liberal Democrats

A

Local-level structure:
The Liberal Democrats have local branches but are also organised along federal lines with separate national parties or England, Wales and Scotland

Local-level policy making:
Local branches take the main role in running constituency level campaigns and can also submit motions to the conference for debate

National-level structure:
- The party has national headquarters in Great George Street, London, and the Federal Board is its National governing body. It comprises 35 voting members, including the party president (who chairs it), the leader and three other MPs/peers, the chairs of the three national parties, a councillor, a Young Liberals representative and 15 members directly elected by party members.

National-level policy making:
- The process largely replicates the party’s federal structures, with motions debated and passed at conference becoming official national party policy. Policies that affect the whole of the UK or just England are voted on by the Liberal Democrat Federal Conference, while Scottish, Welsh and regional conferences set policy that only affects their own area.

35
Q

Candidate selection in political parties

A

All three main parties have a similar three-stage process -
1) Hopefuls must get onto the party’s central list of approved candidates after undergoing a selection / vetting procedure and training e.g. all aspiring Conservative candidates must first pass the Parliamentary Assessment Board which tests skills of communication and motivational leadership
2) They must then apply to be shortlisted as the prospective party candidate (PPC) by local branches
3) They then get adopted following a vote by local party members

  • All main parties in recent years have sought to increase the diversity of candidate pools in areas of gender and ethnicity
    Labour pioneered the use of all-women shortlists, with the Conservatives occasionally using open primaries (Gosport) and priority lists (A-lists)
  • On occasion, the central party may impose a candidate shortlist on the local party, as the Conservatives were accused of fast-tracking longlists of favoured candidates in several constituencies such as Ealing North, in order to be ready for a snap election
  • Party activists claim that these lists lacked sufficient local candidates and undermined local parties having a proper and democratic influence on the process
36
Q

Leadership elections - the Conservative party

A

There is also a degree of similarity on how the main parties choose their party leaders - all use a two stage system, with candidates initially being nominated by a certain number of MPs / local parties with the final choice lying with party members - in Labour’s case, registered supporters

Conservative party:
1) Selection by MPs - vote in a series of ballots to narrow the choice of candidates to two names; in 2019, nine MPs secured enough support to stand, but after a succession of of votes by Conservative MPs, seven were eliminated leaving Hunt and Johnson on the ballot for party members
2) Party members - Make the final vote by picking on a one member, one vote basis (OMOV) - Johnson and Truss both had clear victories with around ⅔ of the vote, with Johnson having 16 regional hustings and several televised debates between the two stages

37
Q

Leadership elections - Labour and Liberal Democrats

A

Labour Party -
1) Selection by MPs - Candidates must first secure the backing of 10% of Labour MPs / MEPs and also either 5% of the constituency parties or at least 3 affiliates (2 must be trade unions) - in 2020, during the push to replace Corbyn, Emily Thornberry failed to get sufficient support from the affiliates section so was unable to proceed in the first round of the vote
- Keir Starmer, Rebecca Long-Bailey and Lisa Nandy all qualified to stand in the first round of the vote of party members
2) Party members - Party members and registered supporters vote on an OMOV basis using the alternative vote system to make the final choice - in 2020, as Keir Starmer won over 50% of the vote in the first round, there was no need for a second round of voting

Liberal Democrats -
1) Selection by MPs - Candidates must gain support from at least 10% of other Liberal Democrats MPs, and be supported by at least 200 members from more than 20 local parties
2) Election by party members - Party members vote on an OMOV basis using the alternative vote to make the final choice; Ed Davey won the leadership race in 2020, securing 63.5% of the vote by party members in the first and only round

38
Q

Analysing the leadership election process in political parties

A
  • Labour uses the same process to elect its deputy leader, with Angela Rayner winning that contest in April 2020 - on occasion, a new leader can be elected unopposed, which happened with Theresa May in 2016 in which Andrea Leadsom withdrew from the race, while Gordon Brown won the Labour leadership unopposed in 2007
    Vince Cable in 2017 was similarly unopposed for the Liberal Democrats and in these situations a leader is not elected, but rather crowned
  • With both policy-making and leadership selection, there is a balance between the participation and involvement of grassroots members and the input of the party’s MPs and institutional stakeholders, such as Labour’s affiliated unions
  • If ordinary members are not involved in the selection process, there is a risk they will become disillusioned and less willing to volunteer and campaign for the party at election time - however, without some peer review by those who probably best know the candidates, there is a danger that the chosen leader may lack sufficient support from their parliamentary group, a problem which affected Corbyn during his leadership of the Labour party
  • However, grassroots activists are often more extreme in their political views than ordinary voters - excessive devolution of policy-making to the wider party membership could prove electorally damaging
  • As a result, parties aim to strike a balance between membership participation and central direction/filtering with a growing bias towards centralised control
  • Each of the main parties have sought to increase their membership figures in recent years - contrary to the impression of consistent decline, each has had some success in improving supporter numbers
  • Labour’s membership had grown to just over 550,000 by the time of the 2020 leadership election, making it the largest political party in Europe with around an additional 230,000 affiliated supporters
  • The Conservative party also enjoyed a membership boost with around 160,000 eligible to vote in the 2019 leadership contest, and in 2020 Liberal Democrat numbers were just over 100,000
39
Q

The funding of political parties - candidate spending

A
  • 25 pieces of primary legislation
    Regulation period for campaign spending begins when parliament dissolves and goes on for five weeks until election day on December 12th (as it was in 2019) - unlike in the US, there are strict campaign laws that regulate funding
  • They are allowed to spend £8,700 in their constituency, plus 6p per voter in Borough constituencies and 9p per voter in county constituencies giving the candidate between £10,000 and £16,000 to spend with a £600 limit on personal expenses and a £700 limit on help from non-party campaigners (not affiliated with the party but somewhat involved in campaigning
  • Anything spent above the £700 limit counts towards the candidate’s spending limit, with all expenses having to be reported to the Electoral Commission
  • Electoral Commission was created in 2000 as a result of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act and they are responsible for monitoring and regulating all the campaign finance rules
  • All personal donations over £50 have to be reported to the EC and must come from permissible sources - this includes any individual on the electoral register or any company registered in the UK
40
Q

The funding of political parties - third party spending

A
  • Most of these laws originate from the Transparency of Lobbying, Non-party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act of 2014, also known as the Lobbying Act
  • Third parties are defined as companies and charities that are not directly affiliated with any party but are essentially political campaigners - in 2015, there were 68 third party supporters, mostly charities
  • The campaign spending regulation period for third parties is backdated a year from the election date, and so any politically motivated spending from this date, such as local elections or European Parliament elections counts towards their spending limit
  • Any third party that spends more than £20,000 in England or £10,000 in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland has to register with the EC
  • However, the actual spending limit for any UK wide third party is £584,817; in England alone, it is £479,550, in Scotland it is £73,400, in Wales it is £55,259 and in Northern Ireland it is £37,550 with a £9,750 limit on any spending in an individual constituency
  • There are stricter limits on ‘targeted campaigning’ - the Lobbying Act has been unpopular amongst third parties because it is unclear what exactly counts to be political campaigning, but it was introduced as a response to concerns about unregulated third party campaigning
41
Q

The funding of political parties - Party spending

A
  • Regulation period is also backdated a year, and so any money spent on campaigns in this one year time period from the election day counts towards the spending limit - this is complicated by the amount of by-elections, local elections and European Parliament elections that may have occurred in that year which all have their own individual spending limits
  • General election spending limits - the limit depends on how many constituencies your party is planning to run in; it is calculated at £30,000 per constituency, or £810,000 in England, £120,000 in Scotland, £60,000 in Wales - it also depends on which number is higher (you could spend £810k in England, even if you only run in two constituencies) and the £810k does not have to be limited to £30,000 per constituency
  • If you field candidates in all 650 constituencies, you get a spending limit of £19,500,000 (30,000 x 650)
  • In European elections, candidates have a spending limit of £45,000 per person, which is £270,000 per constituency if all 6 positions feature your party - if you fielded candidates in all 78 positions, you would have a total of £3,510,000
  • However, these European election spending limits carry over into the general election spending limits; so, if no money was spent on campaigning in the European elections, the party would acquire an additional £3,510,000 on top of the £19.5 million, giving a total of £23 million
  • Donations - anything above £500 has to come from a permissible source, and anything in excess of £1,500 has to be immediately reported to the EC
42
Q

The issues with the funding of political parties

A
  • However, a major issue with these laws is the blurred distinction between candidate and party, because of how FPTP operates; UK-wide campaigning is a very inefficient way to win votes, and so much of the spending would go to marginal seats, as other seats do not require the spending to get votes as they are guaranteed, and there is no point campaigning in safe seats for other parties
  • Political parties want to be able to declare specific constituencies expenditure as national campaigning so it does not impact on the candidate spending limit; if it can be passed off as national spending, more than the £16,000 can be used on that constituency
    Conservatives were fined £70,000 over this in 2017, as during the 2015 campaign they used battle buses full of volunteers in specific constituencies and declared the cost as national spending and included accommodation costs for volunteers - EC stated it should’ve been counted as candidate spending
  • The Crown Prosecution Service was given the evidence who charged Craig McKinley, the Conservative candidate for the constituency on the bus (South Fanick) with knowingly overspending and misattributing funds but this problem has become more complicated with the growth of social media
  • The Conservatives were only caught as the buses physically went into individual constituencies - targeted online campaigning cannot be tracked as easily and parties can spend millions on targeting very specific voter groups
  • This problem is exacerbated by online advertising proving to be more effective than traditional advertising, and gives wealthier parties even more of an advantage - in 2015, the Conservatives spent more than 10x the amount on online campaigning as the other parties combined, spending £1.2 million on Facebook alone - Labour spent £1 million
  • The Lib Dems equally had 3 times the amount of unique personalised adverts as the Conservatives in 2017
  • Problem - massive budgets on specific marginalised seats and targeted online advertising, where limits are much higher
  • To remedy this, the EC issued a report including the Honesty Principle, which stated that in all cases an honest assessment, based on facts, should be made on the proportion of spending that can be fairly attributed to a campaign - ask politicians to be honest about their spending
43
Q

Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 - funding political parties

A
  • All political parties must register with the Election Commission and provide regular returns of their income and expenditure - in addition, there are strict limits placed on the amount each party can spend in the run-up to the election of £30,000 per constituency
  • All parties also have to declare all large donations defined in 2020 to be anything over £7,500
  • The Act also regulates campaign expenditure for national referendums and can issue fines to parties and groups that break the rules - in 2018 for example, Leave EU was fined £70,000 for breaches of electoral law
44
Q

Political Parties and Elections Act (2009) - funding political parties

A
  • This strengthened the provisions of the PPERA by increasing the powers of the Electoral Commission and placing further requirements on parties and donors to clarify the sources of their donations
  • Major donations or loans can only come from UK residents
    Whilst this regulates some o the funding that occurs, it does not resolve the issue of how parties should be funded

The suggested proposals to help with this:
1) Membership subscription - these are agreed to be the fairest and most transparent funding method; large numbers pay small amounts to ensure that no donor gets undue influence
-> The problem is that party memberships are not enough by themselves large enough to sustain the level of finance required to fund professionally run national campaigns, ads on billboards and increase the use of ads on social media, or organise effective policy research

2) Individual donors - all main parties have often relied on generous individual or institutional donors; in the Blair years, Labour benefitted from wealthy individuals such as Bernie Eccelstone and Lord Sainsbury, but more recently during the Corbyn years the party has been bankrolled by affiliated trade unions including the GMB and Unite (gave £3 million over 2019)
Conservatives also benefited from generous donors, with the party raising more than £5.67 million in large donations in the first week of the 2019 election campaign, including £200,000 from Chernukhin, the wife of a Russian business owner
-> Smaller parties also sometimes receive large donations such as Christopher Harborne Donating £2 million towards the Brexit Party’s 2019 campaign
-> The main problem with reliance on a few of wealthy givers opens up potential for corruption and undue political influence and access - 1997, Eccelstone’s £1 million donation to Labour led some to suggest that this was repaid by a delay in introduction of a ban on tobacco advertising in F1 motor racing
-> Research by an independent media platform openDemocracy found that almost 20% of an elite group of Tory funders, known as the Leader’s group (open to those who donate an excess of £50,000) later received honours after donating to the party
-> One example was hedge fund manager Michael Farmer who had given more than £6.4 million to the party since 2010 and received a peerage - ‘cash for honours’ accusations have been levelled at the party for years

3) State funding - pence per member or pence per vote; parties can receive public funding through Policy Department Grants (£2 million in total annually) which are available to parties with at least two sitting members of the House of Commons who have taken an oath of allegiance - they can also receive Short (Commons) or Cranborne (Lords) money, which is paid to opposition parties to help with their administrative work in providing effective scrutiny of the government in parliament
-> Parties also receive indirect help through free television airtime for party election broadcasts and free postage for one piece of campaign literature during elections, however, some have argued that there should be greater state funding of political parties

45
Q

Should parties be state funded? - Yes

A

1) State money would be clean, without the dependence on wealthy donors and interest groups who may expect something in return, whether in the form of honours or policies
2) It would enable politicians to focus on representing constituents and developing policies that benefit the entire nation, not just cosying up to potential donors
3) Provide a greater sense of equality for each party, Tories considerably outraised their rivals in 2019
4) Other attempts to regulate funding and eradicate corruption have failed. The independent 2007 Phillips report ‘Strengthening Democracy’ and 2011 Committee on Standards in Public Life suggested greater state funding of political parties
5) State funding that matches their vote would encourage them to campaign in all seats to increase the vote and not just the key marginals, which would increase democracy
6) State finding would make it easier to limit overall spending on elections, much of which goes on advertising as could be reined in
7) If funding was matched to small donations, it would encourage parties to seek more money from all their supporters, not just the wealthier

46
Q

Should parties be state funded? - NO

A

1) Voters should not fund parties they disagree with and there are many better areas on which to spend taxpayers money, such as health and education
2) Parties could become isolated from the ‘real world’ if links and competitions with interest groups were cut
3) There will always be inequality in party funding. Some parties are larger and more popular than others what matters is that everyone is equally able to join and give as they wish
4) Politics should be treated as an extension of the free market and the right to donate is a basic democratic right, provided it is made openly and major donors are identified
5) Finding based on the existing share of the vote merely strengthens the larger parties and makes it more difficult for smaller parties to get off the ground. Smaller parties, already disadvantages by FPTP, would be hit again
6) State funding would make parties too dependent on the state and less incentivised to actively recruit embers. Funding could also be manipulated by the governing party for its own benefit

47
Q

The relationship between politics and the media - newspapers

A
  • UK political parties have an interesting relationship with the media - all terrestrial television is governed by strict rules on impartiality, so parties and candidates cannot buy any airtime for political adverts in the same way they can in the USA
  • All broadcast news reporting has to be balanced and fair, and this political neutrality is a central principle of the BBC charter - this does not prevent politicians on both sides calling the BBC biassed however
  • The main partisan political campaigning therefore takes place in the national newspapers nearly all of which have a strong political slant
  • As the tabloid front pages on the eve of the December 2019 election made clear, newspapers are rarely shy of expressing political viewpoints e.g. ‘Banish the Blues by voting Red this Thursday’ - Daily Mirror
  • Papers often claim credit for poll success; following Major’s unexpected victory in 1992, The Sun famously stated that ‘It’s the Sun Wot Won It’ and the paper subsequently denied wielding such influence
  • When questioned about the article in the 2012 Leveson Inquiry, dealing with phone hacking in certain newspapers, Murdoch stated that they do not have the sort of power to make this influence and although he backed Blair in 1997, he stated that no favours had been exchanged throughout Labour’s 10 years in power
  • However, the evidence shows their influence - The Sun’s decision to switch to Labour in 1997 generated around 525,000 more votes for Labour, and about 550,000 additional votes for the Conservative in 2010, when it switched back to supporting the Tories
48
Q

The relationship between the media and political parties

A
  • Regardless of how newspapers do influence voters, it is argued they imply reinforce existing opinion, or just back likely winners, it cannot be denied their influence is decreasing
  • National newspaper circulation in the UK has fallen sharply in recent years, with much of the media war in politics now conducted online via social media - parties are in much more control and are able to purchase ads without needed to ingratiate themselves with newspaper tycoons
  • In both 2017 and 2019, each of the main parties spent heavily on Facebook ads, which were often carefully targeted by both location and voter profile - the BBC reported that the Conservative NHS ads were targeted in key marginal seats including Stroud and Abingdon
  • Gender can also be directly targeted, with the text of one Conservative ad seen over 250,000 times only by female users read ‘We’re recruiting 20,000 more police and giving them the powers needed to keep you safe’ and this is just one example of how media spending y parties has become increasingly targeted and developed in response to how voters access news and political opinion
  • Effectiveness - significant sums listed in Facebook’s Ad Library Report from October 2018 to May 2020 would suggest the parties believe this is effective - the Conservatives spent £999,730 on over 20,000 ads, Labour spent £1.2 million on around 8,000 ads and the Liberal Democrats spent £1.3 million on around 20,000 ads
  • How effectively money is spent is debatable, since the actual result bore little relation to the amounts each party set aside for online ads
49
Q

Politicisation of news papers

A

Right leaning newspapers -
- Daily Express
- Daily Mail
- The Sun
- The Daily Telegraph
- The Times

Left-leaning newspapers -
- The Guardian
- The Independent
- The Observer
- The Daily Mirror

Neutral -
- The Financial Times
- The BBC

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nhafm1ba3TmxLcIcB6ai2EngIcbGwdXbzx4OnmyGUJA/edit

50
Q

The factors that affect parties and their electoral outcomes

A

1) Relevance and attractiveness of main policies:
- The Conservative offer to ‘get Brexit done’ resonated in a way that Labour’s more convoluted Brexit policy did
not
- The Conservative promise of 20,000 more police officers and funding for the NHS

2) Leadership
- A strong personality and good communication skills in a leader can make or break a party’s campaign - May came across as somewhat robotic in 2017 with a repeated emphasis on ‘Strong and stable government’. By contrast, Labour’s Corbyn, initially an underdog, performed better than expected in this area and went down especially well with younger voters such as his applause at Glastonbury in 2017 and 2019.
- Blair’s ability to have his personality marketed well in the 1997 election helped him win compared to a ‘Grey’ Major
- Johnson’s enigmatic personality helped his campaign massively following a mellow May and a disgraced Corbyn

3) A committed and energised group of activists on the ground
- Parties need local campaigners to hand out leaflets, canvas door to door and coordinate the campaign in the constituencies
- Constituency Labour Party leads campaigns in the local level, and Local Conservative Associations and Young Conservatives

51
Q

The factors affecting parties and their electoral outcomes (pt2)

A

4) The strength and situation of the opposition
- In 2019, Johnson was a formidable and experiences campaigner, but in contrast Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson was a less assured candidate and arguably made a huge and untimely unsuccessful gamble in campaigning for a stop to Brexit without a second referendum or renegotiation
Conservatives were also helped by the decision of the newly formed Brexit party not to contest Tory-held seats and avoid splitting the Leave vote in each constituency
- Also, while the party’s intervention in other areas robbed the Conservatives of some additional gains, overall its vote largely went nowhere
- During May’s government, her supply and demand agreement with the DUP left her exposed to opposition from a sizeable Labour opposition, who were also joined by the Liberal Democrats
- Johnson’s large majority was noticeable in his ability to push through Brexit deals with virtually no cross party support
- Blair was a very effective leader with virtually no opposition holding 415 seats

5) Party Unity
- Although the Tories had been in deep disarray under May, Johnson largely resolved this by removing the whip from 21 rebel MPs, several of whom, including key figures such as former chancellor Philip Hammond, decided not to contest their seats again
Labour meanwhile remained factionalised and heavily dogged by accusations of anti-semitism
- A number of its own MPs, including Ian Austin, resigned over the scandal
- Party was very united under Johnson until his no confidence vote and the following governments of Truss and Sunak have been plagued by divide between their two factions and wings of the party
- Equally, Major’s divides in 1997 opened up the opportunity for a united New Labour

6) Electoral systems
- The impact and distortions of the electoral system should not be ignored - the Liberal Democrats are particularly disadvantaged; in 2019, despite winning over 11% of the total vote, they were awarded just 1.7% of the seats
- In contrast, the Conservatives won 43% of the vote but around 56% of seats
- In 2017, May won only 42% of the popular vote but secured 48% of seats, showing disproportion in the winning of seats

52
Q

Minor political parties in the UK - fringe parties

A
  • Minor third parties can take votes from the Labour and Conservatives; regional influence parties are also important for devolved regions
  • The fringe list - fewer than 50,000 votes in 2019, but more than 5,000 - the Yorkshire Party, UKIP, Monster Raving Loony Party, the Liberal Party, AONTU
  • The Yorkshire Party - 0.1% of the vote share, founded in 2014 aimed to give Yorkshire devolved powers through a Yorkshire Assembly for transport, education, housing and environmental control
    – Other policies which are socially democratic and economically centrists - some success in winning council seats, and they only field candidates in Yorkshire
  • UKIP - UK Independence Party who used to split Conservative votes, and secured 0.05% of the vote, and this largely due to Farage changing party
    – UKIP stands against the EU and rapid mass uncontrolled immigration - national democracy, patriotism, economic democracy and political democracy, liberalism and traditionalism - policies include House of Lords reform and electoral reform
    – In 2014, they were the first party to win a national poll, winning in the European Election and had some MPs in the House of Commons through defections from the Conservative party
    – Successfully elected fringe candidates
  • The Liberal Party - 0.02% of the vote, and they were one of the two major parties before the 1900s, and after the merger with the Social Democratic Party to make the Liberal Democrat party, they have established the Liberal party
    – They were libertarian, and they have little success due to the Liberal Democrats
  • AONTU - a conservative Irish party who advocate for conservatism socially, but they have policies that back increased public spending and reduction of zero hours contracts
  • Monster Raving Loony Party - not a serious political force, and was founded to offer protest votes - vote insanity
  • Christian People’s Alliance - growth out of a cross party advocate group following devolution and growing secularity, and they felt they could gain power due to devolution
    – Policies such as religious policy, such as opposing same-sex marriage and abortion
53
Q

Minor political parties - what are their purpose?

A
  • Aim to influence the behaviour of established parties and expand the ideological bands of existing political culture
  • They also exist to offer voters choice; those who feel they are disenfranchised, and voting for a joke party shows that there is discontent with the mainstream party - they are also an alternative to the Liberal Democrats, such as the Liberal Party offering a place for those who disliked the LibDem merger - allows for protest votes
  • They have a democratic function in their influence and choice
54
Q

Scottish and Welsh Nationalist Parties

A

SNP:
https://www.snp.org/
- Leader - Unconfirmed (Sturgeon gone)
- Formed - 1934
- Left wing but with right wing parties
- Policies - Second Independence referendum - Scottish Independence; Increase health spending / staff / double the Scottish Child Payment; Close the educational attainment gap; Freeze income tax rates and Greener transport policies
- Strong concentrated regional following - SNP is the largest Scottish political party in both Westminster and the Scottish parliament
- Won 48 seats in 2019, and 45% of the total vote in Scotland
- Without pressure from the SNP, it was unlikely Cameron would have entertained Scottish independence

Alba (Scotland):
https://www.albaparty.org/
- Alex Salmond - formed 2021
- Left wing
- Scottish independence
- Progressive tax policies
- Limiting nuclear power
- Only won 0.7% of the vote, with most MPs being defects from the SNP

Plaid Cymru:
https://www.partyof.wales/
- Adam Price
- Left wing
- Second EU referendum
- FSM for all primary school children and pay £35 a week to low income families and £300m a year for education
- Green job revolution
- Free social care at the point of need
- Increased ability under devolution to be heard
- Most popular Welsh party - won 4 of 40 Welsh seats and secured over 10% of the vote

55
Q

Northern Ireland parties (Unionist)

A

Democratic Unionist Party:
https://mydup.com/
- Jeffrey Donaldson
- Left wing
- Fix the NHS
- Grow the economy
- Help working families
- Remove the NI protocol - unionist
- Keep education levels high
- Dominant force in Irish politics, and was involved in a power sharing agreement with the Conservatives in 2017-2019. Won 27 seats.

Ulster Unionist Party:
https://www.uup.org/
- Founded in 1905 - Doug Beattie
- Left wing
- Unionist party
- Favour devolution
- No new border
- Skills based immigration system
- Access to healthcare
- Tend to align with the DUP, won 10 seats in last election.

Alliance Party:
https://www.allianceparty.org/
- Naomi Long
- Centre
- Restore stormont
- Deliver better public services
- A fairer, greener economy - more sustainable planning
- Better support for local businesses
- Non-sectarian
- 17 seats won in most recent election

56
Q

Northern Ireland Parties - Nationalists

A

Sinn Fein:
https://www.sinnfein.ie/
- Mary Lou McDonald / Michelle O’Neill
- Right wing
- Additional support under the cost of living crisis
- Tackle health waiting lists
Improve housing
- Help prevent climate change
Retain high educational standards
Ban conversion therapy
- The second most prominent ideology in Ireland, making up the other half of the power sharing in the Northern Irish Assembly; won 25 seats

Social Democratic & Labour Party:
https://www.sdlp.ie/
- Colum Eastwood
- Centre
- Giving £1,200 to those suffering in the cost of living crisis
- Slash hospital waiting lists
- Make childcare more affordable
- A unique party in the Irish political system, being socially liberal and supporting same-sex marriage; won 12 seats in previous election.

57
Q

‘Single Issue’ parties - minor political parties

A

UKIP (Brexit):
https://www.ukip.org/
- Neil Hamilton
- Right wing
- Abolish the House of Lords
- End mass immigration
- Support voting reform
- Support free speech
- Scrap foreign aid
- Fared well in European elections winning the 2014 and 2019 ones

Green Party (environment):
https://vote.greenparty.org.uk/
- Carla Deyner and Adrian Ramsay
- Left wing
- Prevent climate change
- Greener economy
- Mass investment into NHS
- Nationalise water to stop waste dumping
- Social care is free at point of use
- Green party fares well in elections; often seen as single issue party but they have many socialist policies - 1 seat in Commons but historically do well with vote share

Reform UK:
https://www.reformparty.uk/
- Nigel Farage (formed it)
- Richard Tice (current leader)
- Right wing
- Previously Brexit party
- Reform the economy
- Reform our Public sector
- Reform the energy strategy
- Reform our institutions
- Fares well in European elections - 3 seats in the recent elections but these no longer exist

Reclaim Party:
https://www.reclaimparty.co.uk/
- Laurence Fox
- Right wing
- Change freedom of speech laws
- Depoliticise the police and other institutions
- Patriotism - protect the borders
- Supporting the working class
- Equality for all
- They were not formed before the 2019 election but they intend to stand in 2024

58
Q

The impact of minor parties on the politics of major parties

A
  • The success of Eurosceptic parties pushed the Conservative party into a more resolute position on Brexit, so that it would avoid losing votes and potentially seats, but they have only ever one won Westminster seat, Clacton, where Tory MP Douglas Carswell defected to UKIP and won a by election after resigning and held the seat in the 2015 election.
  • The ongoing attraction of Eurosceptic parties and especially the high public profile of Nigel Farage meant that the Conservative’s were never able to avoid a debate over the EU.
  • The Green party should also not be ignored, despite posing a less direct threat, as it has ensured environmental issues remain on the political radar.
59
Q

The extent of the multiparty system in the UK - Evidence /arguments to suggest that the UK IS a multiparty system

A
  • Looking at the Commons benches - two party duopoly, with the 2019 election having 87% of seats being held by the Conservatives and Labour on a combined vote share of around 76% - it is largely two party within the Commons - it is in the political culture
  • In general elections, Britain is two-party, as FPTP means that they are the only parties large enough to have a chance at winning; small parties act as quasi-pressure groups to influence the policies of larger parties (voters see an issue, campaign, it is adopted by large ideological parties) or act as a protest vote - structure
  • Due to their small presence in Commons, this part of government is two party
  • Dominance of two parties returned in 2017 following the coalition
60
Q

The extent of a multiparty system in the UK - Evidence/arguments to suggest that the UK IS NOT a multiparty system

A
  • Coalition in 2010-15 - in 2010, the combined Tory/Labour vote share was only 65% despite seat share being around 87% - this was a major third party achievement and showed a shift in UK politics
  • In devolved regions and the UK contingent to the European Parliament prior to Brexit, the UK had very much a multiparty system - no fewer than 10 parties won seats in the latest European elections in 2019
  • Politics in Northern Ireland often involve contests between several parties, with some local electoral pacts existing to prevent splitting unionist or nationalist votes - their assembly is intrinsically multi-party, as are most of the devolved parliaments / assemblies
    Scotland is a country of ¾ party politics
  • Many local authorities have hung/balanced councils with no party in overall control, and independents have significant presence in many local councils in rural areas - in the 2019 council elections, 1,100 independents won seats, almost equal to the Liberal Democrats
  • Even at Westminster, an unelected Lords sees a multiparty system, with no party having a majority and the existence of many crossbench peers (more crossbench than Labour or Liberal Democrat)
  • The electoral system creates two-party politics - where there is no FPTP in UK elections, there is multi-party politics