Topic 2- Trends, Ethnicity differences and differences in offending Flashcards
What is crime usually measured in
Official statistics
Where are crime statistics compiled from
Police recorded crime
Victim surveys
Self-report studies
Court and prison records
Victim surveys
Include reported and unreported crime
A face to face survey where residents are asked about their experience of crime in the last 12 months
Self report studies
Anonymous questionnaires in which people are asked to own up to crimes they have committed
Court and prison records
These reveal some of the characteristics of those who are caught
Official crime statistics
Drawn from records kept by the police and other official agencies
Reasons for unreported crime
Embarrassment
Fear
Don’t know they are a victim of crime
Deal with it themselves
Distrust the police
Reasons for unrecorded crime
Not all crimes are entered into official figures
Police priorities
Changes in reporting, counting and recording crime
-The media
-Police attitudes
-People reporting less serious offences
-Changing social norms
-Community policing
-Changes in the law
Limits of victim surveys
-People may exaggerate or lie
-People may forget they have been victimised
-May not realise they are a victim
-Victims may be embarrassed
Limits of self-reported studies
-People may exaggerate or lie
-People may forget the crimes they have committed
-May ignore respondents own definition of crime
-Lack of representativeness
What percentage of Black people make up the prison population
13.1%
What percentage of Asians make up the prison population
7.7%
How many times more likely are Black communities than white communities to be stopped and searched
7 times
How many times more likely are black communities than white communities to be in prison
5 times
Graham and Bowling
43% blacks and 44% whites had very similar rates of offending while Indians 30%, Pakistanis 28% and Bangladeshis 13% had much lower rates
Philips and Bowling
Since the 1970’s there have been many accusations of oppressive policing of minority ethnic groups
Macpherson report 1999
Investigating Stephen Lawrence murder concluded there was institutional racism
Racial victimisation
Is when an individual is selected as a target due to their race, ethnicity or religion
Scarman report
-Brixton riots highlighted the role of resentment felt by the African Caribbean community against the police whom they felt they were being harassed by
Lea and Young
Ethnic differences reflect different levels of offending by different groups
Neo Marxism
That statistics don’t reflect reality
Gilroy
The myth of black criminality=
He believes that it is a myth and that in reality these groups are no more criminal than any other
Hall et al
Policing the crisis
-Saw a moral panic over black ‘muggers’ that served the interests of capitalism