Theory of Mind Flashcards
Theory of mind is also known as mentalizing (Morton & Johnson) or __________ (Whiten)
Mindreading
Theory of mind is a form of _____ cognition
social
The term was first used by Premack and Woodruff (1978) in their paper “Does the _______ have a theory of mind?”
chimpanzee
Henry et al. (2013) distinguished between 2 types of theory of mind. What are they?
Hot / Affective
Cold / Cognitive
Henry’s ‘Hot’ / affective ToM relates to what?
Emotions, feelings, affective states
Henry’s ‘Cold’ / cognitive ToM relates to what?
Cognitive states, thoughts, beliefs, intentions
Baron-Cohen et al. (2001) identify how many different stages of Theory of Mind attribution?
2
What are Baron-Cohen’s different stages of Theory of Mind attribution?
The first stage is INDENTIFYING the mental state of the stimulus
e.g., “compassion”
The second stage is INFERRING the content of that mental state
e.g., “compassion for the loss of her mother”
Theory of mind tasks differ in their complexity, with every additional step of attribution raising the order of theory of mind processing by one (Perner & Winner, 1985).
When do children develop first order ToM?
4 - 5 years
Theory of mind tasks differ in their complexity, with every additional step of attribution raising the order of theory of mind processing by one (Perner & Winner, 1985).
When do children develop second order ToM?
6 - 8 years
What is first order ToM? (Perner & Winner, 1985)
Reflecting on the thoughts or feelings of another person
e.g., “I think that you think”
What is second order ToM? (Perner & Winner, 1985)
Predicting what another person thinks or feels about what another person is feeling
e.g., “I think that you think that she thinks”
“I think that you think that she thinks that I think” is an example of which order of ToM?
third order
False belief tasks - Conclusive demonstration of theory of mind can only be gained from predicting another’s behaviour based on a false belief because …..
The ToM test can be passed without the need to predict another’s mental state if the belief either reflects the true state of affairs or the individual’s own beliefs.
The punch and Judy show is an example of what?
What age does Dennett say ‘obviously’ follow the plot?
False belief ToM.
4 yr old
Successful task performance on false belief tasks require the attribution of a belief to another person that is _____ from the individual’s own belief
different
What is the Sally and Anne task (Baron-Cohen et al., 1985)?
False belief test.
In which an object (marble) is moved (box) without the knowledge of the character and the participant must predict where the character will look for the object on his or her return
What is the Smarties task (Wimmer & Perner, 1983)?
False belief task - A false contents task
The child participant discovers that a tube of smarties in fact contains pencils or crayons
And is then asked what another child who has not seen inside the tube will think is inside
The correct answer is “Smarties”
Which is the change in location task: smarties task or sally-anne?
Sally anne
What age do children start to pass false belief tests?
3-year-olds nearly always fail such tests
4- and 5-year-olds typically pass, Showing that they can distinguish between their own knowledge and the knowledge of other people
3 explanations of theory of mind?
Theory Theory (Perner) Theory of Mind Mechanism (Leslie) Simulation Theory (Gordon)
All 3 explanations of theory of mind propose what?
That people use propositional attitudes when thinking about beliefs and desires
Define propositional attitude.
the relation that a person has with a proposition, such as having an opinion concerning it or responding emotionally to it
Are propositions always true?
No
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts. What are they?
The agent
The proposition
The attitude
The anchor
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
Of the following sentence, which is the AGENT?
“Laura really wanted to do well in her exam”
Laura
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
Of the following sentence, which is the PROPOSITION?
“Laura really wanted to do well in her exam”
Laura really wanted to do well in her exam
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
Of the following sentence, which is the ATTITDUDE?
“Laura really wanted to do well in her exam”
Wanted
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
Of the following sentence, which is the ANCHOR?
“Laura really wanted to do well in her exam”
Exam
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
What is an anchor?
The part of the real world that the proposition is about, for evaluating the proposition against
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
What is the agent?
The individual holding the belief or desire
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
What is the proposition?
The content of that belief or desire
A propositional attitude can be split up into four parts:
The agent, The proposition, The attitude, The anchor
What is the attitude?
The mental state that is being talked about
e.g., thought, belief, knowing, hope, doubt, fear, desire
The Theory Theory account (Perner)
Before 4 yrs old, children might not have ToM, but they might have what?
A theory of behaviour
According to the Theory Theory account and Fletcher-Wilson, why do children act like “little-scientists”?
Formulating hypotheses about the actions of people around them and then testing these hypotheses against reality