Theories Flashcards
Durkheim
-society is consensual and people have shared values making a collective conscience
-Crime helps society to change but too much leads to social disruption
Durkheim positives of crime
-reaffirming boundaries
-changing values
-social cohesion
Kingsley Davis
-safety valve allowed minor crimes to avoid bigger problems e.g. drugs
Cohen
-crime boosts the economy for jobs and its an early warning sign showing where society is going wrong
Negatives of crime
Anomie- collective conscience is unclear during times of great stress
Egoism- becomes weak to restrain selfish desires of others
negatives of Durkheim
-exaggerates collective conscience
-vague when starting what crime is beneficial for
Merton
Strain theory
-society became dysfunctional
-crime is a poor fit between socially acceptable goals and the way to obtain those goals
-Unequal class based society
Merton - 5 forms of behaviour
conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism, rebellion
Evaluate merton
+official statistics show crime is most property, material wealth
+explains 2011 riots
-Valier states there are no clear common goals
-Not all crime produces material rewards
Cloward and Ohlin
Illegitimate opportunity structure
some subcultures illegal career is available with illegal means to goals:
-criminal
-conflict
-retreatist
Evaluate Cloward and Ohlin
+evidence of organised crime
-not just a neat 3 clear category, they do overlap
-ignore crime of wider power structure
Cohen
Status Frustration
-crime was not money based
-w/c boys wanted to have m/c values but lacked
-School is where they reject the values of behaviour and gain status from peer groups
Evaluate Cohen
-Box states he ignores the fact w/c boys may never share the same goals to begin with
-doesnt look at female crime
-underplays the role of the relationship out of school
Becker
Labelling theory
-Examples from incest of people being tolerant and intolerant
-Just because someone breaks as rule doesn’t mean defined as deviant
-it is when rules are enforced which draws attention to them
Example of tolerance
Kitsuse
-75 heterosexuals interviewed and no one had the exact same response therefore no defined definition
Lemert
Primary deviance: rule breaking
Secondary deviance: consequences of the responses of others
Master Status
e.g. Canada and the chronic stuttering
Cohen
Moral Panic
-labels are amplified by authorities to groups which results in them being more deviant
e.g. Mods and Rockers, deviance amplification and folk devils
Deviance Amplification Spiral
-The drug takers
-media led to police targeting them
-Hippies became more secretive
Moral entrepreneurs
newspaper editors, MPs, religious leaders and campaigners
Evaluation of labelling theory
+raised important issues on police discretion/stop and search
+voice for powerless and outsiders
-labelling could be based on the actual serious offence
-deterministic, it may deter crime
Phenomenological explanation
-connection between human awareness and social action
-Society is created by humans, certain acts defined deviant and some not