The existence of God and revelation Flashcards
what are the three arguments for the existence of God?
- the Design Argument
- the First Cause/Cosmological Argument
- the Argument from Miracles
what is the Design Argument?
the argument that because everything is so intricately made it must have been created by God
what is the Muslim design argument?
- God created humans to serve him - they are in charge of creation
- the world is so well ordered and balanced to sustain life - beautiful + has so many complex, independent parts that make up a whole
- must have been designed - only God can do this
what is William Paley’s Design argument?
- the workings of a watch are so intricate that the must have been designed and made by a watchmaker - not by accident
- similarly the universe is so complex and intricate that it must have been designed and made
- it must have been a work of God
what is Isaac Newton’s Design argument?
- the opposable thumb is only on humans and some primates
- it allows precise and delicate movement and allows us to do things like tying a shoelace or writing with a pen
- this is sufficient evidence of design which could have only been achieved by God
what is Thomas Aquinas’s Design argument?
- only an intelligent being could keep everything in the universe in regular order
- the fact planets rotate in the solar system without colliding is because of God
what is F. R. Tennant’s Design argument?
- since everything was just right for humans to develop, the world must have been designed by God
- strength of gravity was just right - if force and speed of Big Bang explosion was slightly different, life wouldn’t have developed on earth
what are the objects to the Design argument?
- natural selection happens by chance - species design themselves through evolution not designer God
- suffering - a good God would not have designed and allowed bad things like evil and natural disasters
- order of the universe makes it look like it is designed but actually order and structure in nature is imposed by humans
what is the First Cause argument?
it states that there has to be an uncaused cause that made everything else happen
what is the chain of reasoning for the First Cause argument?
- everything that exists has a cause to explain it’s existence
- as the universe exists and had a beginning, it too must have a cause
- there must be something eternal existing with no cause to cause everything else to exist
- eternal first cause must be God
- this means God must exist
what is Thomas Aquinas’s First Cause argument?
- everything in the universe is caused to exist - nothing an become something by itself
- as everything we see is caused to exist, including the universe, it must have a creator
- the uncaused cause of creation can only be God, who is eternal
what is the Kalam cosmological argument?
- set out by 11th century Muslim philosophers
- the difference between the universe and God is that the universe has a starting point, God doesn’t
- everything that has a starting point has a cause for existence
- the cause of the universe is God who is eternal and doesn’t need a cause to exist
what are some objections to the First Cause argument?
- if everything that exists has a cause, what caused God?
- if God is eternal the universe can be eternal too
- the idea that everything has a cause doesn’t necessarily mean the universe has to have a cause too
- the Big Bang was a random event - nothing to do with God
- religious creation stories are myths - they tell spiritual truths, not actual truths
what are miracles?
seemingly impossible events that cannot be explained by the laws of science or nature
example: someone recovering from an illness when doctors had given up all hope
why are miracles important?
God shows his love through them and a believer’s faith is strengthened
what do theists argue about miracles?
- no scientific reason for event happening so must be caused by something outside nature
- God is the only thing outside nature
- these events must be the result of God’s intervention in the world
- therefore God must exist
what do atheists and agnostic argue about miracles?
- miracles are no more than happy coincidence
- they may be explained by scientific explanations we don’t realise yet
- healing- mind over matter or wrong diagnosis
- some miracles might be made up for money and fame
- therefore miracles might not have anything to do with God so can’t prove God exists
what is David Hume’s argument against miracles?
- there can never be enough evidence to prove that miracles can happen
- witnesses to miracles are unreliable - primitive + uneducated
- religions depend on miracles to prove they are right but all religions can’t be right
why do some theists object against miracles?
They make God seem unfair - why would God choose to benefit one person over millions who aren’t so fortunate - an all-just and all-loving God wouldn’t do that
how do Christians respond to miracles?
- evidence of God’s existence and work in the world - many converting to Christianity after a miracle is proof
- Jesus did many miracles - healings, bringing dead back to life, etc.
- most important miracles in Christian teaching = Jesus’s incarnation + resurrection
- Lourdes is recognised by the church as a place where miracles have happened - 69 confirmed by Catholic church
how do Muslims respond to miracles?
- it isn’t a strong argument for God - few modern examples
- supreme miracle = revelation of Qur’an to Muhammad - no human could write such a book without God’s intervention
- most miracles aren’t important - religious experiences are individual cases
- Muhammad’s ascent into heaven (Al-Mi’raj) can be seen as a miraculous religious experience
what are the 2 types of revelation?
- general revelation
- special revelation
what is general revelation?
- God making himself known through ordinary experiences
- available to everyone
- we use reason to make logical assertions based on the information available
what are some forms of general revelation?
- God’s presence in nature
- Worship and reading scriptures
- the lives of religious leaders close to God
- a person’s reason, conscience or morality
how is nature a way of understanding the divine? (general revelation)
- Christians + Muslims believe God is revealed through the beauty of the world he created
- the power of storms and the sea, the wonder of a newborn baby, the order of nature
- may lead to awe and wonder at his power to create and destroy
key Bible quote on general revelation through nature?
“The heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the work of his hands… night after night they reveal knowledge” - Psalm 19:1-2
key Qur’an quote on general revelation through nature?
“It is He who spread out the earth, placed firm mountains and rivers on it and made two of every kind of fruit… There are truly signs in this for people who reflect” - Qur’an 13:3