TASK 6 - CONSTITUTIONS Flashcards
- constitutions. what is the problem?
aim to lay down certain frameworks in which gov and pol activity are conducted but none have been successful
(inaccuracies, distortions, omssions)
- constitutions. what do they do (3)
- lay down meta-rules for pol system
- rules that govern the government
- bring stability, predictability and order to gov’s actions
as a means of change:
means of establishing a new political order following the rejection or collapse of an old order
- constitutions. what are the first?
- us constitution (1787)
- french declaration of the rights of man and citizen (1789)
- classfications. according to 4 factors
- form of the constitution and status of rules
- written/unwritten
- codified/uncodified - ease with which the constitution can be changed
- rigid or flexible - degree to which the const. is observed in practice
- effective
- nominal
-façade - content of const. and institutional structure that it establishes
- monarchical/ republican
- federal/unitary
- presidential/parliamentary
2.1 written/unwritten constitution
-> written const.: constitutions enshrined in laws
ex: no fully written one
->unwritten const.: embodied in customs and traditions
ex: new z, israel, uk (liberal d), saudi a, oman… (non-liberal d)
ALL CONST ARE A BLEND OF BOTH
ex: france, usa (loose framework for gov, priority on written rules)
2.2 codfied/uncodified constitution
-> codified: based on existence of a single authoritative document
- ‘higher law’
- binds all pol institutions (binded to courts)
- entrenched provisions
- hierarcy of laws
unitary system: 2 tier (const above statute law)
federal system: 3 tier (+ lower state laws)
-> uncodified: very diff characteristics
ex: uk
- statute law
- common law
- legislature enjoys sovereign unchallenged authority (arbitrers)2
2.3 rigid/flexible constitution
-> rigid: codified constitution tend to be more inflexible
- enrtenched provisions
-> flexible: uncodified constitution tend to be
- laws of const. significance can be changed
-> various degrees possible: not directly proportional to the formality of its procedures and rules
- referendums, amendments used
- meanings under constant revision of judicial interpretation
2.4 effective/nominal or façade constitution
-> effective: one fulfilling 3 criteria
1. practical affairs to gov correspond to provisions of constitution
2. const has ability to limit gov behavior
-> nominal: text/principles may accurately describe gov but fail to limit it
ex: chinese const
-> façade: differ from pol practice (propaganda role)
ex: dictatorial/authoritarian states
2.5 based on content and pol structure that it establishes.
- Monarchical/republican
- Unitary/federal
- parliamentary/presidential
- pluralistic/monopolistic
2.5.1 monarchical/republican
-> monarchical: invest const supremacy in a dynastic ruler
-> republican: pol authority derived from people
2.5.2 unitary/federal
-> unitary: based on centralized decision-making power in one institution
ex: france (assembly in paris)
-> federal: based on decentralized power distribution
ex: germany (federation)
- bundesland has own sovereignty (own asseblies, police forces, judiciaries…)
2.5.3 parliamentary/presidential
-> parliamentary: executive derived from and accountable to the assembly
- chooses exec
-> presidential: 2 branches of gov function independently (separation of powers)
2.5.4 pluralist/monopolistic
-> pluralist: liberal democracies
- pol power is dispersed
- guarantees of participatory rights and party comp
-> monopolistic: communist/authoritarian
- unquestionable authority of the ruling party or supreme leader
- PURPOSE OF A CONST (5)
- empower states
- establish unifying values/goals
- provide gov stability
- protect freedom
- legitimize regimes
- 1 empower states
mark out existence of states and make claims on their sphere of independent authority