Subcultural Functionalism Flashcards
When + why did subcultural functionalist develop?
1950/60s
Response to criticisms of traditional functionalism approach
Who’s work do subcultural theories build upon?
Merton’s (strain)
BUT focus in positions of groups in social structure rather than just on individuals
Why subcultural theories believe people generally commit crime?
Share different values from the mass of law-abiding S
BUT they don’t live in complete opposition to mainstream values
Amended certain values to justify criminal beh
= SUBCULTURE
What do subcultural theories aim to explain?
How certain social groups adapt to the strain they face
Focus most on wc juvenile delinquents
(; represent largest group in deviants + criminals)
What do subcultural theorist assume about OCS?
That they = correct
Take them at FACE VALUE
What 3 other theories have subcultural elements to them?
- Labelling theory
- Left realism
- New Right
When did A.K Cohen write?
1955
What were AK Cohen’s major criticisms of Merton’s work?
- c+d = collective response NOT just individual
2. Didn’t explain non-utilitarian crimes e.g. vandalism
Why do wc boys commit c+d ahcoirng to AK Cohen?
Lower wc boys want success but can’t achieve; cultural deprivation
Lead to Ed. failure
What do wc boys suffer from
AK Cohen
Status frustration
Turn to delinquency, get status from peers
IOT deal with S.frustration, adopt alternative set n+v
DEVIANT SUBCULTURE - reverse mainstram culture
e.g. values truancy, vandalism, stealing
What are 4 criticisms of AK Cohen’s work?
- Are wc aware they = ‘inverting’ mc values? or is it just for fun (Lygn, edgework)
- Box: wrong to assume wc boys originally accepted mainstream values
- Only looked at men, ANDROCENTRIC
- Cloward + Ohlin (build upon…)
How does Box criticise AK Cohen’s work?
MARXIST
Wrong to assume wc boys originally accepted mainstream values
Box argues delinquency = more result of feeling shame/guilt/resentment at being called failure by teachers
Leads them to retaliate
What are 2 strengths of AK Cohen’s work?
- Explains crime with no monetary reward - about gaining status not £
- Sutherland offers a supportive theory
- differentail association, majority of teenagers act same was as peers
What supportive theory does Sutherland offer to AK Cohen’s work/
Differentail association
If majority of teenagers act in same way = difficult for rest of group not to be influenced
When did Cloward + Ohlin write?
1960