Social Class Flashcards
What is the labelling/interactionist theory?
•WC disadvantages within education
•“Interactions” between teachers and pupils
•Process and organisations within schools
What is the labelling interactionist theory?
Internal
• The WC are disadvantaged within education due to the processes within and organisation of the education system
• The interactions between Teachers and Pupils determine their success
Labelling theory
KEDDIE
- unequal access classroom knowledge
(Status and knowledge)
High and low status knowledge - Ts do not evenly distribute
-common sense - descriptive
- basic
- dumb down
OR - abstract
- theoretical
- detailed
- full curriculum
Labelling theory
RIST
Labelling in primary schools
American Kindergarten
- tigers, cardinals, clowns
Placed ‘tigers’ near here for more encouragement - MC
Labelling theory
CICOUREL & KITSUSE
Counsellors and labelling
Assessed students on race and social class
Judged students sustainability for courses
MC referred to higher ability and academic subjects
Labelling theory
HARGREAVES
‘The halo effect’
- act upon perceptions
- students have imaginary halos and future interactions with teachers and pupils are based on the halos
Labelling theory
BECKER
Interviewed 60 high school teachers
- teacher stereotypes
- work, conduct, appearance
- MC closest to ‘ideal pupil’
- WX furthest away from
Labelling theory
RUTTER
Secondary schools and their effects on children
- specific factors in schools good or bad and the role that teachers play
- e.g teachers show genuine interest, well prepared for lesson
What is the self-fulfilling prophecy?
prediction that comes true purely on the basis of it being created in th first place
3 stages
1) teachers label pupils and make prediction
2) interacts with pupils based on label/prediction
3) pupil internalises label and Ts expectations
Self-fulfilling prophecy
ROSENTHAL & JACOBSON
Studied teacher expectations
- 47% showed significant progress because they were treated better by their teacher
- given fake results
- the Pygmalion and Gollum effect
Setting and streaming
HARGREAVES
‘resistant anti-school subcultures’
WC that value the system is contradictory in terms of their own progress, opinions, status, progression
- form RASS to achieve status and reward through an alternative set of values- directly oppose values ES promotes
Setting and streaming
BALL
Argues the dangers of setting and streaming
- supports Hargreaves
- beachside comprehensive
- Teachers interactions with pupils affect their exam results, usually the MC are more co-operative
- polarisation of pupils gradually lessened into subcultures
Setting and streaming
LACEY
Hightown grammar- why subcultures form
Differentiation- Ts categorise through stereotypes of ability and appearance, setting n streaming
Polarisation- pupils response to D and move towards 2 extremes
What are macro-schooling processes and selection policies?
formula funding, league tables, free market- parentocracy
Gives the MC an advantage
What do GILLBORN and YOUDELL say about marketisation and selection policies?
Educational triage
- focus all their time on ‘middle group’
- top will pass anyway
- bottom will fail anyway
WC are neglected
Teachers ration their time and resources
What does BARTLETT say about marketisation and selection policies?
Cream-skimming
-successful students
Silt-shifting
- off-load and turn away difficult and expensive to teach students
What are the criticisms of Internal approaches to social class inequality in education?
X ignores intersectionality
X assumes all teachers stereotype
X reductive/too deterministic
X assume that all labels given ‘stick’7
X ignore structural problems