Ethnicity Flashcards
CD
1) Intellectual and linguistic skills
BOWKER
- lack of SE creates a huge barrier to UK education
EAL- English as an additional language
link to BERNSTEIN
‘sociolinguistics’ and restricted code
Criticism of intellectual and linguistic skills
THE SWANN REPORT
- lang differences had little impact on achievement
X does not explain why Indian pupils do so well
CD
2) Attitudes and Values
ARNOT
Black Machismo
- the media created negative role models for black pupils
- ultra tough ghetto superstar
- reinforced through rap lyrics and MTV videos
- boys who lack father figure
- anti authority
Why is attitudes and values a factor of cultural deprivation?
Different ethnic groups are socialised into or inherit different attitudes and values
Criticisms of CD 2) Attitudes and Values
X Reductionist- not all will be influenced negatively
- not all rap lyrics are negative
CD
3) Family structures and Parental support
MOYNIHAN AND MURRAY
- African Caribbean lone-parenthood to blame
- lack of male role model
- mother struggle to socialise children adequately
CD
3) Family structures and Parental support
SCRUTON
Low achievement is the result of ethnic minorities failing to embrace and conform to British culture
- lack of cultural assimilation
CD
3) Family structures and Parental support
PRYCE N HALL
- Asian culture ignores racism more effectively
- impact of slavery means B less likely to assimilate and integrate with white MC led to their loss of lang, religion, ancestry
HALL calls this ‘culture of resistance’
CD
3) Family structure and Parental support
DRIVER & BALLARD
Asian families have a more pro school than black families
- extended family unit
- rarely lone parents
- offer a bigger support network for their children
CD
3) Family structure and Parental support
LUPTON
Suggests Adult Authoritarian Asian families match that of the school
- Tiger parenting
- embraces multiculturalism
Criticism of CD Family structure and Parental support
DRIVER- ethnicity can be an advantage- AF CRB girls do well
KEDDIE- to blame culture is to blame victims of educational failure
X relies of generalisations
X ignores compensatory education
MD
FLAHERTY
15% of minority groups live in overcrowded homes
LINK TO DOUGLAS SC
Pakistanis are 2X more likely to be in semi-skilled jobs compared to whites
MD
THE SWANN REPORT
Social class differences account for a high proportion of differences in achievement between ethnic groups
RACISM IN SOCIETY
MASON
Discrimination is a continuing and persistent feature of the experience of Britain’s citizens of minority ethnic origin
RACISM IN SOCIETY
REX
- Racism leads to social exclusion and accordingly poverty
- shown in housing employment and education
- discrimination inside and outside the classroom