Sentencing Flashcards
Bill C-75 2019 brought in sweeping changes to
the Criminal Code regarding the available sentences for summary conviction offences, making longer sentences possible.
What are the objectives of sentencing adults, as outlined in CC Section 718, .1 and .2?
- DENOUNCE unlawful conduct and the harm done to victims
- DETER the offender and other persons from committing offences
- SEPARATE offenders from society
- ASSIST in rehabilitating offenders
- PROVIDE REPARATIONS for harm done to victims or the community
- PROMOTE a sense of RESPONSIBILITY in offenders
Deterrence may be
general or specific
General deterrence is aimed at
deterring the community at large by demonstrating the negative consequences of engaging in criminal behaviour
Specific deterrence is an effort to
ensure the offender is discouraged from reoffending
Section 718.1 codifies the importance of
the proportionality of a sentence
Section 718.2 sets out other principles of sentencing, including:
- parity
- totality
- restraint
How must judges consider the principles outlined by the SCC in R v Gladue?
the unique background and systemic racism faced by Indigenous offenders, the use of appropriate procedures and the imposition of appropriate sanctions must all be considered if the systemic factors facing INdigenous peoples in Canada have impacted to offenders life in a way that bears on the offenders moral blameworthiness
What is a Gladue Report?
Can be ordered when the offender is Indigenous, details the life circumstances of an offender and provide sentencing recommendations, given the circumstances and resources available
What is the significance of R v Morris?
While Gladue principles do not apply to black offenders, through the ONCA decision in Morris, the court may consider the impact of anti-black racism on sentencing
What factors pertain to the gravity of an offence?
- the range of the offence
- an offence involving abuse of trust
- domestic offences
- planning and deliberation
- duration
- magnitude or profitability
- prevalence
- violence and use of weapons
- vulnerability of the victim
What is the credit limit for time served while in pre-trial custody?
one day for each day spent in custody, with a max credit of 1.5 days for each day spent, of circumstances justify it
Organizations may be subject to a maximum fine of
$100,000 for a summary conviction offence
What kind of report may be produced as proof of an offender’s criminal record?
A CPIC report, generally the Crown will produce a copy of the record as kept by the RCMP
What is a pre-sentence report?
Can be ordered by the judge, a sentencing court may order that a probation officer prepare a pre-sentence report, which consists of interviews with the offenders family, friends, employer, and others, and prepare a report that outlines the offender’s family background, upbringing, education, employment history, significant issues and future plans
In some cases, a paralegal may wish to have what prepared instead of a pre-sentence report?
A psychological report
The court is not bound to accept a
joint position, in the situation where the Crown and defence have agreed to a guilty plea and appropriate sentence. Offender should be made aware of this prior to choosing to take a negotiated guilty plea
What is diversion?
Where an alternative method to a sentence is taken, where the accused agrees to participate in an appropriate program, and where the program is successfully completed, the charges are stayed or withdrawn