Revision Session + Sample Questions Flashcards
What are the three main types of knowledge production and the assumptions underlying each?
Positivism - natural history, range & biographical aspects
Critical realism - the real World exists ‘out there’ independent of our experience
Interpretivism - capture & understand meaning of a social action for agent performing it
What does ontology mean?
Ontology concerns our assumptions about the nature of reality.
What does epistemology mean?
Epistemology means theory of knowledge, or how it is we can know anything about the world.
What are the advantages of the scientific method? (4)
- Tightly controlled independent variable allow comparison of effect on dependent variable
- Randomised controlled trial gold standard of medical interventions
- Replicable, reliable, objective
- Evidence based medicine (anecdotal evidence can be proved wrong and turn out to be harmful)
What is the main disadvantage of the scientific method?
- Does not and cannot accommodate inconsistencies, confounding and outliers
Describe the two main ontological positions with their assumptions.
Objectivism/Realism - the social world is objective, out there, independent of us who perceive it
Subjectivism/Idealism/Constructionism - the social world is constructed by us - constructions are built up from the perceptions and actions of social actors.
Describe positivism and interpretivism (positions of epistemology) and the difference between the two.
Relate these two approaches to two different applications in the health field.
Positivism - the application of empiricist natural science to the study of society. Reality is unitary and can only be understood through the scientific approach. Research is conducted in a value-free way: the researcher is independent of the data and detached (doesn’t influenced or is not influenced by the research).
Interpretivism - people and institutions are different from material objects and the natural world and therefore require a different approach. People are ‘social actors’ who interpret their everyday social roles in accordance with the meanings they give to these roles. The goal of research is to understand the subjective meanings and reality of social actors in order to make sense of their motives, actions and intentions in a meaningful way.
Why is adherence important and what is it?
Adherence is the extent to which a patient’s behaviour, with respect to taking medication, corresponds with agreed recommendations from a healthcare provider. It has three components - persistence, initiation adherence and execution adherence.
Poor adherence to treatment of chronic diseases is a worldwide problem. The consequences of poor adherence to long-term therapies are poor health outcomes and increased health care costs. It compromises the effectiveness of treatment.
What is the average rate of adherence according to the WHO?
Adherence to long-term therapy for chronic illnesses in developed countries averages 50%. In developing countries, the rates are even lower.
Describe three practical/moral steps that should be taken to improve adherence.
Three from:
- Doctor embark on an iterative reasoning process with the patient (patient centred medicine)
- Acknowledge and engage patient as a moral agent
- Acknowledge patients are embedded in social relationships and that they are accountable to and responsible for others (context of family, community and livelihood)
- Acknowledge intersubjectivity and relational aspects of autonomy and choice
Understand the different points of view in relation to patients paying for their own healthcare or being denied treatment due to their lifestyle behaviours.
CCG’s rationing services due to funding deficit, which has led to the question of should obese patients be refused routine operations across the NHS?
Yes - it will help the NHS save money
No - the NHS is meant to be for everyone. Denying these patients means not adhering to clinical guidelines.
What is meant by sociological perspectives?
This links the individual and the social and explore the relationship between two levels of attribution of responsibility. It applies frameworks to explain varied responses of individuals.
Name two different types of sociological perspectives and the assumptions underlying them.
Two from:
Social constructionist - shared understanding or construct of death & dying formed through values, norms, social practices & contingencies. Social determinants of mortality To what extent are our beliefs about health largely social constructions? To what extent are our lives driven by our need to deny the uncertainty inherent in life?
Phenomenological existentialist - meaning & significance of individual embodied experiences
Anthropological cultural - cultural thoughts systems integrate their ideas about mortality into their language, religions, values, rituals – cultural death systems.
Biomedical - biological reality, dying trajectories, palliative care, advanced directives, death certification. Population statistics on mortality & morbidity.
Define ‘habitus’.
This means the social norms, tendencies, habits, resources that are taken for granted and so guide behaviour, i.e. structured determining ways to think/feel/act that become internalised and are seen as part of character.
Explain the term ‘biopower’ in relation to health.
The technologies, knowledges, discourses, politics and practices used to bring about the production and management of a state’s human resources.
Biopower analyses, regulates, controls, explains and defines the human subject, its body and behaviour.
Describe what is meant by ‘medicine as a social ideology’.
Not a body of scientific and neutral truths about the nature of existence. It presents an image of health that fits with the culture of industrial capitalist societies. A new morality/ethics of individualism.
Describe what is meant by the term ‘cultural norms’.
The term ‘culture’ refers to attitudes and patterns of behaviour in a given group. ‘Norm’ refers to attitudes and behaviours that are considered normal, typical or average within that group.
Describe three different binaries and how these relate to medical practice.
Patient and doctor
Objectivism and subjectivism
Positivism and interpretivism
Suicide rates are highest in which of the groups below…?
Men aged 35-49