Quiz 4 Flashcards
Ancient Question of Judaism
Q: Why is Israel subordinated to the gentiles?
A: Israel’s sanctification and God’s judgement of Israel’s failures
New question of Judaism
How is it possible to be both an Israelite and something else (ex. European or American)?
Reform Judaism’s answer to the new question
Israel is a religious community with a universal mission
Israelites could integrate AND be loyal to France, Britain, etc.
Practices separating Israelites from humanity were to be dropped
Orthodox Judaism’s answer to the new question
Rejected Reform
Integrationists held that Israelites should combine Torah study and secular sciences
Integrationists held that one could practice Judaism AND integrate into national culture
Conservative Judaism’s answer to the new question
Mediated between the two positions
Traditions could change, but only in accord with the historical processes of Judaism
Zionism’s answer to the new question
Political system, not a religious system
Did not trust emancipation
Proposed the creation of a Jewish state in Palestine
What competition did Rabbinic Judaism meet?
Orthodox, Reform, Conservative
In NA, 50% Reform, 30% Conservative, and the rest Orthodox
What was Zionism aimed at?
Restoring Jewish people to the Land of Israel
Founding the Jewish state
Realizing the nationalism of the Jewish people
Why did the Rabbinic system meet competition?
Jews used to have a distinct culture and identity, but were now expected to integrate into the law
The Rabbinic system did not answer the new question, but rather promoted the segregation
Major beliefs of Reform Judaism
Looked towards a messianic age when social order would be perfected in justice and humanity
Denied that any version of the Torah enjoyed eternal validity
Changes in Synagogue worship
People were defecting from the synagogue
Zionism emerged
Affirmed integration and made important changes to the law in the Pittsburgh Platform of 1885
Who is Israel?
No longer a nation and is now a religious community
Once had a set of laws regulating diet, clothing, etc, but no longer apply
How does Israel account for its existence as a distinct group?
The group had a mission to serve as a light to the nations
Realize messianic hope for the establishment of a kingdom of truth, justice, and peace
Reform worldview
Lays emphasis on a perfect age that is yet to come
The Pittsburgh Platform
Central Conference of American Rabbis
Worldview issues divided Judaism, but most Reform Jews could accept it
The way of life: sanctification
Worldview: Reference to the Torah for rules and explanation of conduct
Defined the norm for all communities of Judaism outside the Orthodox