Questions IDK Flashcards
Outline dispositional explanation of obedience.
- Adorno- proposed dispositional explanation as an explanation of obedience.
An internal explanation for obedience- focus is on idea that certain personality characteristics are associated with higher levels of obedience. - Authoritarian personality= collection of personality traits said to develop from strict parenting during an individual’s childhood
(e.g. extremely strict discipline, an expectation of loyalty, impossibly high standards, and severe criticisms of failings.) - Personality traits inc. showing extreme respect for perceived authority AND submission to people in perceived authority as they see them as superior.
Also disapprove of individuals perceived as low status AND direct anger towards them as they view them as inferior. They have black and white thinking and fascist views. - Assessed using the F-Scale= questionnaire by Adorno on over 2000 American participants. High scores on the questionnaire= authoritarian personality and the characteristics described above displayed.
Group size factor affecting conformity
Conformity increase as the size of majority group increases.
Size of the group stops having an effect once the group reaches a certain size.
* 1 real participant and 1 confed conformity= 3%
* 2 confed and 1 real participant conformity= 13%
* 3 confed and 1 real participant conformity=32%
* However, conformity plateaued after this.
* Suggests size of the majority does have an effect on conformity but only to a point (3).
Unanimity factor affecting conformity
Unanimity= complete agreement from group about answer/viewpoint.
* Original Asch study= confeds all gave the same wrong answer and conformity= 37%
* Asch varied his study, one confed give the correct answers throughout, conformity= 5.5%
* ‘Lone’ confederate answer both different from majority and correct answer. Conformity= 9%
* Asch concluded- When dissenter breaks the group’s unanimous position conformity decreases.
Task difficulty factors affecting conformity
Conformity increases when difficulty of a task increases.
* One variation- Asch made stimulus and comparison lines more similar in length- correct answer less obvious and task was harder. Difficulty of the task increased conformity rates increased.
* Suggests that ISI plays a greater role when task becomes harder. When situations are unclear, we are more likely to look to others for guidance.
* As right answer becomes less obvious, lose confidence in own ability, more likely to conform.
Leading question definition
Question that wrongly implies something, and can therefore affect the accuracy of EWT.
E.G. ‘what colour was the youth’s jacket?’ implies the perpetrator was a youth.
Leading questions AO1
Aim: To investigate whether the phrasing of a question can affect participants’ memory of an event.
Method: Lab experiment
Sample: 45 American students (split into 5 groups of 9)
Procedure: Participants were shown a video of a car crash and each group was asked same question with different verb: (IV)
“About how fast were the cars travelling when they **** each other?”
Smashed, hit, collided, bumped or contacted.
Loftus and Palmer measured participants’ speed estimates (DV)
Findings: They found participants guessed a higher mean speed when they had ‘smashed’ (40.8mph) compared to contacted (31.8mph).
Conclusion: The phrasing of a question can influence a participant’s memory of an event.
AO3 STRENGTH Leading qu.
Has practical applications
Notion that leading questions can affect the accuracy of EWT has led to improvements in the legal system.
For example, police officers need to be very careful about how they phrase their questions when interviewing witnesses, and not use leading questions which has led to the development of COGNITIVE INTERVIEW.
Therefore, the research in to how leading questions affect the accuracy of EWT is an important part of applied psychology BECAUSE it could lead to more accurate testimonies and improve the lives of people affected by crime.
THINK FURTHER: Positive impact on the economy- witness statements more accurate could lead to quicker conviction of correct perpetrator, less tax payers’ money spent on multiple police interviews/ re-trials= money could be used elsewhere to benefit society.
Post event discussion
Witnesses of event discuss accounts w eachother
Affects accuracy: memory conformity and contamination
Memory contamination
Cowitnesses to crime discuss w each other and EWT becomes distorted/altered.
Combine misinformation from others w own memory of event= MEMORIES OF EVENT CHANGE
Memory conformity
Witnesses go along w each other either to win approval (NSI) or they believe the other is right and they r wrong (ISI).
Memory remains UNCHANGED, RECALL is AFFECTED
AO3 PED
Skakerberg and Wright- vid of mugging, muggers hair colour dark or light brown
Prone to demand characteristics- controlled environ.
Anxiety definition
Has strong emotional and physical effects.
According to research by J and S- negatively affects EWT accuracy as witnesses only recall certain aspects- recall limited
Anxiety AO1
Johnson and Scott
Aim: To investigate the effects of anxiety on the accuracy of eyewitness testimony
Method: Laboratory experiment
Procedure:
* Participants were placed in one of two conditions either a high anxiety, ‘weapon focus’ condition or low anxiety condition. (IV)
* Participants were told to wait outside a room before the experiment began.
* In the high anxiety, ‘weapon focus’ condition participants heard an argument and the sound of breaking glass from within the room, and a man walked out of the room carrying a knife covered with blood.
* The low anxiety condition heard the argument from within the room before a man walked out with grease on their hands and a pen.
* Participants then had to identify the person who left the room from 50 photographs. (DV)
Findings:
Found 49% accuracy for the low anxiety condition compared to 33% in the high anxiety ‘weapon focus’ condition.
Conclusion: Anxiety caused ‘weapon focus’ as the witness concentrates on the weapon not the person because of the fear of the situation, reducing accuracy of recall.
AO3 Anxiety
Christianson and Hubinette- criticise as real life situation of bank robbery found recall more accurate with bank teller compared to bystander
Valentine and Mesout- London Dungeon Labryinth- recall of actor characteristics better w low anxiety
Maternal deprivation definition
Emotional and intellectual consequences of extended separation between a child and his/her mother or mother substitute, where a child loses an aspect of care, within the critical period.