Professional Independence of a Lawyer Flashcards
A lawyer ____ not share legal fee with a nonlawyer.
Must
Lawyer L wants to practice law part-time, doing work for law firms that need extra temporary help. L gives copies of her resume to LawTemp, Inc., a placement agency that is owned
by nonlawyers. When law firms need extra help, they call LawTemp, which sends them
resumes of several available lawyers. By this route, L obtains temporary work at a firm that
agrees to pay her $100 per hour for her work and to pay LawTemp a “placement fee” equal
to 5% of the total amount it pays to L. The law firm’s bill to its client includes the amount
the firm pays to L and the “placement fee” paid to LawTemp.
Is this proper?
Yes - it is not fee splitting.
Can a firm pay a death benefit to the dead lawyers estate or family?
Yes - over a reasonable period of time.
The R, S & T firm set up a death benefit program. After a partner or associate dies, the
firm will make monthly payments to her estate for three years after the death, each payment to equal 40% of her average monthly income during the year before death.
Is this proper?
Yes
True or False: nonlawyer employees of a firm may be included in a compensation or retirement
plan even though the plan is based on a profit-sharing arrangement
True
True or False: One who buys the practice of a dead, disabled, or disappeared lawyer may
pay the purchase price to the estate or representatives of the lawyer.
True
When a court awards attorneys’ fees to the winning lawyer in a case, the lawyer ______
share the fee with a nonprofit organization that hired or recommended him as counsel.
May
A lawyer must not form a partnership with a nonlawyer if…
any part of the partnership activities will constitute the practice of law.
Family lawyer F formed a partnership with marital psychologist P; their purpose was to
offer a full range of counseling and legal services to family clients. All of the legal work
was done by F, and all of the other counseling was done by P—neither transgressed into the
domain of the other.
If F subject to discipline?
Yes, F is subject to discipline because part of the partnership
activity constitutes the practice of law.
Under what circumstances can a lawyer not practice in a firm or association for profit if:
(i) A nonlawyer owns any interest in the firm or association (but, when a lawyer dies, her
estate may hold an interest during the administration of the estate);
(ii) A nonlawyer is a corporate director or officer or the equivalent thereof; or
(iii) A nonlawyer has the right to direct or control the professional judgment of a lawyer.
M is a nonlawyer. She is the business manager of W, Y & U Ltd., an incorporated law firm.
As business manager, she keeps the firm’s calendar, does the firm’s accounting, hires, fires,
and supervises all of the firm’s nonlawyer employees, procures all of the firm’s supplies and
equipment, and runs the firm’s library.
Can M become a shareholder in the firm?
No violates the rules.
A lawyer must not allow a person who recommends, employs, or pays her for serving a client
to direct or regulate …
the lawyer’s professional judgment
A lawyer ______ make nor offer a partnership or employment or similar agreement that
restricts a lawyer’s right to practice after termination of the relationship.
Must neither
When can a restriction be imposed on the right to practice law?
When the agreement concerns benefits upon retirement.
Oakville practitioner A employed young lawyer L by an agreement that purported to prohibit L from practicing in Oakville after leaving A’s employment.
Who is subject to discipline?
Both parties.