Prevention, Consultation, and Psychotherapy Research Flashcards
Who developed the most frequently cited models of prevention?
Gerald Caplan and Robert Gordon
What are the 3 types of prevention in Caplan’s Model?
- primary
- secondary
- tertiary
According to Caplan’s Model, what is the goal of primary prevention?
to reduce the occurrence of new cases of a mental or physical disorder
According to Caplan’s Model, who are primary preventions aimed at?
an entire population or group of individuals rwho may or may not be at elevated risk for the disorder
According to Caplan’s Model, what is the goal of secondary prevention?
to reduce the prevalence of a mental or physical disorder in the population through early detection and intervention
According to Caplan’s Model, who are secondary preventions aimed at?
specific individuals who have been identified as being at elevated risk for the disorder
According to Caplan’s Model, what is the goal of tertiary prevention?
to reduce the severity and duration of a mental or physical disorder
According to Caplan’s Model, who are tertiary preventions aimed at?
people who have already received a diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder and include relapse prevention and rehabilitation programs
What are the 3 types of prevention according to Gordon’s Model?
- universal
- selective
- indicated
According to Gordon’s Model, what are universal preventions?
aimed at entire populations or groups that are not restricted to individuals who are at risk for a disorder
According to Gordon’s Model, what are selective preventions?
aimed at individuals who have been identified as being at increased risk for a disorder due to their biological, psychological, or social characteristics
According to Gordon’s Model, what are indicated preventions?
for individuals who are known to be at high-risk because they have early or minimal signs of a disorder
What is the Institute of Medicine’s expended version of Gordon’s Model?
- prevention (universal, selective, indicated)
- treatment
- maintenance
According the Institute of Medicine’s expended version of Gordon’s Model, who is targeted by prevention?
people who have not received a diagnosis of a mental or physical disorder
According the Institute of Medicine’s expended version of Gordon’s Model, who is targeted by treatment?
people who have received a diagnosis
According the Institute of Medicine’s expended version of Gordon’s Model, who is targeted by maintenance?
people who have received treatment for a disorder and the focus is on preventing chronicity or relapse and/or providing rehabilitation
According to Caplan’s mental health consultation, who is in the triad?
- consultant
- consultee (therapist/program administrator)
- client or program
According to Caplan, what are the four types of mental health consultation?
- Client-centered case consultation
- Consultee-centered case consultation
- Program-centered administrative consultation
- Consultee-centered administrative consultation
What is client-centered case consultation?
- focuses on a particular client of the consultee who is having trouble identifying the appropriate treatment
- the consultant provides the consultee with a plan what will benefit the client
What is consultee-centered case consultation?
- focuses on the consultee and improving their ability to work effectively with a specific group/type of clients
- the goal is to improve the consultee’s knowledge, skills, confidence, and/or objectivity
What is program-centered administrative consultation?
- working with program administrators to help them clarify and resolve problems they’re having with an existing mental health program
- provide administrators with recommendations for dealing with the problems they’ve encountered in developing, administering, and/or evaluating the program
What is consultee-centered administrative consultation?
focuses on improving the professional functioning of program administrators so they’re better able to develop, administer, and evaluate mental health programs in the future
How does mental health consultation differ from collaboration?
- consultant has little or no direct contact with a consultee’s client
- consultant is not responsible for the client’s outcomes
What are efficacy research studies?
maximize internal validity (the ability to draw conclusions about the cause-effect relationship between therapy and outcomes) by maximizing experimental control (aka clinical trials)
What are effectiveness research studies?
maximize external validity (the ability to generalize the conclusions drawn from the study to other people and conditions) by providing therapy in naturalistic clinical settings
Describe Eysenck’s (1952) psychotherapy outcomes research.
- reviewed 24 empirical studies reporting treatment outcomes for neurotic patients receiving anychoanalytic or eclectic psychotherapy
- no control groups, so used other research to estimate spontaneous remission rates
- concluded that psychotherapy is ineffective and may be detrimental based on the following improvement rates: spontaneous remission = 72%, psychoanalytic psychotherapy = 44%, eclectic psychotherapy = 64%
What were the 2 main methodological flaws of Eysenck’s (1952) psychotherapy outcomes research?
- no random assignment to intervention and control groups so initial differences between groups could explain results
- criteria used to determine recovery were questionable and using different criteria significantly changes results (83% recovery for therapy; 30% recovery for control)
Describe Smith, Glass & Miller’s (1980) psychotherapy outcomes research.
- first meta-analysis to compare outcomes of therapy versus control
- included 475 studies that produced a mean effect size of .85
- means the average patient who got therapy was better off than 80% of people who did not get therapy
Describe Howard et al.’s (1986, 1996) psychotherapy outcomes research.
- investigated the relationship between the duration of psychotherapy and its outcomes
- developed two models based on this research: the dosage model and the phase model
According to Howard et al., what is the dosage model?
- there’s a predictable relationship between number of therapy sessions and probability of clinically significant symptom improvement
- 50% of clients see improvement by 6-8 sessions, 75% by 26 sessions, and 85% by 52 sessions
According to Howard et al., what is the phase model?
- psychotherapy outcomes can be described in terms of three phases: initial remoralization, remediation, and rehabilitation
- initial remoralization: occurs during the first few sessions and is characterized by an increase in hopefulness
- remediation: occurs during the next 16 sessions and involves a reduction in symptoms
- rehabilitation: unlearning troublesome, maladaptive, habitual behaviors and establishing new ways of dealing with various aspects of life
- says different outcome measures should be used in different phases