Politics Investigation Flashcards
Identify and explain the voting system used in AUS HOR
Preferential voting sytem, it is a majoritarian system and is based on single member electorates
What does a preferential system tend to do
amplify a small number of votes into a large number of seats thus creating a strong majority rule
Why is the preferential system good
Allows for a strong representation of the majority and the creation of a stable government
eg of exaggerated majority in 2013 aus election
Liberal national coalition achieved 46% of the vote but had 60% of the seat in the HOR
Bad of preferential voting
Results in minor parties receiving minimal political representation
Eg of minimised minority 2013 fed aus election
Greens achieved 9% of vote but only 1 seat in the HOR
What system does AUS senate use and describe it
Proportional voting system which looks to achieve an accurate translation of votes into seats
Good of senate system
Accurate translation of votes means their is a fair rep of minorities which creates a diverse senate who can veto executive bills
Bad of senate and how
Flawed by malapportionment due to section 7 of the constitution mandating equal state representation
What does senate malapportionment mean
NSW Pop of 7.5 mil has same rep as TAS pop of 515 000 means a vote in tas is worth 14.5x more that in NSW
What system does USA HOR use
uses a majoritarian system but instead of Preferential it uses a ftptp system
What does the FPTP system create
a strong link between constituents and reps as it surrounds the notion of single member electorates
What does AUS + US sytems have and common and what does it result in
The use of a majoritarian electoral sytem which means there is sweeping representation of the majority and a stable gov
eg of exaggeration of majority in 2016 congressional elections
Not particulary large
Republicans won 49% of vote but achieved 55% of seats
what same problems occur in USA HOR as Aus
Minimal minority representation
What system does US senate use and what does it mean
FTPT, means it gains the same disadvs and advs as the HOR gets
What other problem does the US senate concerned about + explain
Malapportionment, Each state is required 2 have 2 reps
Vote in wyoming with a pop of 580,000 is worth 69x more than a vote in cali with a pop of 40 million
What other problem does US HOR + Senate have to deal with, explain it
Gerrymandering, the USA allows the state governor to draw electoral boundries in order to gain a pol adv
Explain the process of gerrymandering
Concentrating opponents votes into fewer seats and conceding them, then by distributing its own voters into a greater number of seats it has a greater chance of winning
eg of gerrymandering
2002 Pennsylvania election, saw the republican party redraw a democratic reps seat so much that it saw him contest the seat with another democrat
Main instrument that Aus upholds popular participation, EXPLAIN IT
CMWTH Electoral Act 1924 which mandates compulsary voting for all citizens over 18
when was the electoral act extended to ATSY
1984
Benefits of electoral act eg
High participation rates of 91% and 93% in 2013 and 16 fed elections
2nd instrument to uphold participation in AUS
In 1984, decided to give political parties who obtain more than 4% of the primary vote funding
Result of pol funding in AUS
Helps parties meet the cost of policy development and campaigning. Means more parties are compelled to participate because they know they can support themselves
What do some people see compulsary voting as
a coercive and immoral way to get people to vote
What does the fines system in AUS undermine
Basic principles of democracy as rather than encouraging people to vote it coerces them through a notion of a large fine
Negative result of compulsary voting eg
Large increase in number of informal voting with 5% of 2016 federal election ballots being informal
Main instrument for pol participation in USA
Through a number of very influential sectional groups that represent the pol interest of a large portion of citizens
what do pressure groups act as
Another avenue for political participation to counteract the notion of voluntary voting
eg of section group
NRA is a powerful sectionalist pressure group that allows citizens to participate from the ideology of the right to bear arms
2 flaws of us participation
Voluntary voting
Voting machines