philosophy 3

Question 1

what was elizabeth scarborough’s goal

Answer 1

is to help us reflect on how / weather to preserve artifacts and places

Question 2

what are the ideas we need to think of when deciding on how to preserve an artifact / place

Answer 2

-Original material
- Use value

Question 3

what is original material

Answer 3

-preserving these might limit the objects function -Helps preserve aura of original owner / user

Question 4

what is use value

Answer 4

preserving these might mean we lose original material but we are still able to engage with the object / space

Question 5

how was the cases of Kim Kardashian and Lizzo different

Answer 5

there was damage to the dress and none for the flute and the flute was preserved to be played again

Question 6

what was negative about kim kardashian’s case

Answer 6

-Primarily the institution who lent it out -
ripley’s
-No oversight or ethical norms to obey
-Wrong motivation - primarily motivated by their own profit
-Kardashian herself - didn’t need original had a replica
-Knew it wouldn’t fit and couldn’t be used without permanent alterations and damage

Question 7

what was lizzo case

Answer 7

accountability : oversight and ethical guidelines controlling use
- was used as use value like it was intended