Peer review Flashcards
What is a peer review?
Peer review is a crucial process in the field of academic research including psychology. Evaluation of scholarly work by experts in the same field.
What is the first process of peer review?
submission
-The process begins when a researcher completes a study and writes a summary of their research, methods, results, and conclusions
-the researcher then submits the paper to an academic journal
What is the second step of peer review?
blind review
-peer review is often conducted anonymously- identities are kept confidential
what is the third step of peer review?
peer review evaluation
-provide constructive feedback on strengths and weaknesses
-thoroughly examine the
paper
Strength of peer review
Anonymous process, provides more honest feedback
Weakness of peer review
-publication bias
-burying ground breaking research
-established psychologists are more likely to get published
What is step 4 of peer review?
Editors decision
-based on feedback from peer review, the editor decided about whether to accept the paper , request revisions or reject it
What is the final stage of peer review?
submission
-once paper meets journal standards and the editor is satisfied the paper is accepted for publication
-it becomes part of scientific literature and made available to academic community
What is the purpose of a peer review?
-ensures quality and credibility of published research, providing constructive feedback for authors and helping to advance knowledge in the field