Memory Errors Flashcards
Memory capabilities
- Memory does not operate like a DVD/ video recorder
- Memory is reconstructive
- We fill in the gaps
Eyewitness Errors
- are the single greatest cause of wrongful convictions worldwide
- 75% of convictions that have been overturned through DNA testing, even cases with multiple eyewitnesses
7 sins of Memory
- Transience
- Absent-mindedness
- Blocking
- Misattribution**
- Suggestibility**
- Bias**
- Persistence
DRM Paradigm
- Used to study false memories in humans
- Activation- Monitoring Theory (why the paradigm works?)
- Ex: Heard a list of words associated with sleep & then listed the word sleep during recall (false memory)
1. Spreading activation (come up with word)
2. Source Monitoring (where you got the information from)
DRM Paradigm - False memories affected by ..
- Stereotypes
- cognitive biases or Individual Differences
Gender Stereotypes, Lenton, Blair, & Hastie (2001)
- If primed are the participants going to falsely remember more traits or jobs.
- Given traits (feminine or masculine trait)
- Masculine or femenine jobs list
- If primed more likely to remember false related jobs of traits exposed to
- People made stereotype consistent errors
Hostile Attribution Bias
- Why are some people so quick to anger? Are people that are put into an angry state have more false memories?
- Prime to put group in state of anger or non anger
- List of words
- Primed subjects with list with ambiguous list (can be categorized to kitchen or violent words)
- aggressive & primed = more likely to develop violent false memories
- Not violent & not primed = did not at all remember lured words
PTSD, Brennen & Colleges
- war vs. non-war list
- how many words did participants come up with that were not on the list
- PTSD Group more likely to develop “war related” false memories
What can influence memory errors?
- peoples pre-existing stereotypes & cognitive biases (due to personality characteristics or clinical diagnosis)
Post event information
- any information received after an event that effects how we remember an event
- Fill a gap
- Supplement
- Transform
Post event info - Fill a gap
add a correct detail
Post event info - Supplement
- reenforce correct detail
- increase confidence
Post event info - Transform
- change your memory
Eyewitness memory, Loftus & Palmer (1974)
- participants watched serious of slides depicting a car crash
- asked questions about it
- Changing nature of the word changed estimate speed (mph)
- asked a leading question - did you see the broken glass at the scene?
- Smashed + higher MPH = said they saw glass
Misinformation effect
• misleading information presented after a person witnesses an event can change how the person describes the event later.
1. Event occurs
2. Post-Event Information (to change/alter memory), or misleading post info
3. Test: Force choice (Forced to choose what you saw in the movie or read about)
• PERFORMANCE IS WORST WHEN PEOPLE GET MISLEADING INFORMATION
• CONTROL BAR ALWAYS HIGHER THAN THE MISLEAD BAR TO SHOW MISINFORMATION EFFECT
• IF ARROWS OVERLAP = NO MISINFORMATION EFFECT
How is the misinformation effect amplified?
Susceptibility increases with
- Authority
- Stress, fear
Discrepancy detection
The ability to notice difference btwn. what was seen & what was told that was seen
What can increase the likelihood of discrepancy detection?
- Discrepancy detection increases (up) , the less likely the misinformation effect will occur (down)
- Warning to pay attention to detail
- When attention is drawn to an interesting stimuli
Who is susceptible to the misinformation effect?
• Coginitive abilities (lower/worse) 1. Lower intelligence 2. Lesser perceptual abilities 3. Lower working memory 4. Worse performance on face regcognition • Personality characteristics 1. High in cooperativeness 2. Reward dependence 3. Self-directiveness
Who is less susceptible to the misinformation effect?
People with..
Lower fear of negative evaluation & harm avoidance
Social influences (alcohol study); Assefi & Garry (2002)
- 1/2 told placebo
- 1/2 told alcohol
- created ambiance
- subjects that were told alcohol said it affected cognitive abilities more than the tonic water group (the told placebo group)
- subjects that believed that they were given alcohol more susceptible to the misinformation effect
- PERFORMANCE IS WORST WHEN GETTING MISLEADING INFORMATION
What are the pro’s of co-witness discussion?
- prompt witness to recall forgotten details
- Reinforce memory (rehearsal)
- Aid recovery from trauma
- more complete overall picture of event
What are the cons of co-witness discussion?
- Can contaminate independent recollection
- weaken the prosecution case
- Become unsure of their testimony
- May lead to reports of “common things”
- Collusion (conspiracy)
Co-wtiness discussion- Gabbert, Memmon, Allan & Wright (2004)
- if discussed what was seen more errors that lead to the misinformation effect
- People incorporated elements of each other memories into their own reports even if those details contradicted with what they saw.
The type of memory errors that we make are caused by what
- individual differences
- Social influences
- Cognitive processes (such as attention & biases)
Flashbulb Memories – Brown & Kulil (1977)
- Suggested that there is a special mechanisms about how a person heard about a surprising & traumatic event
- vivid recall
- detailed
- clear
Flashbulb Memories – Nessier & Harsch (1992)
- Questionnaire w/in 24 hours about all details of event
- Repeated the event 3 years later
- 25% completely wrong
- 50% more than half wrong
- Shown original reports
- CONFIDENCE NOT RELATED TO ACCURACY
Flashbulb Memories - Schmidt (2004) - 9/11 Attacks
- High confidence in memory
* less than 50% information consistent
What did Talarico & Rubin’s Study Show (flashbulb v. everyday memories) ?
- the number of details reduced for everyday
- the number of details falling off overtime
- expected to be more accurate for flashbulb memories
What can be concluded about Flashbulb memories?
- No evidence for flashbulb memories
- There does not seem to be a special mechanism for “flashbulb memories”
- Even highly traumatic or surprising memories are subject to forgetting and distortion
What is the 3 step process in Freud’s definition of repression?
- Event banished from conscious recollection until one can deal with it.
- Emotion seeps in everyday relationships – emotion is affecting you now.
- Recall memory in pristine detail (w/ help of therapy)
What is repression?
Not conscious that there is a blocking of event.