Lecture 8 Flashcards

1
Q

Paper money

A

 Gold didn’t actually flow (would require huge transaction cost and lots of gold at bottom of ocean)
 Central banks intervene by adjusting money supply
 Gold standard -> strong discipline
* Discipline – willingness to cause hardship at home

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Gold standard in theory

A

 If B has more gold than A, there is less money in A and more in B, leading to B importing from A, which leads to A having more gold than B

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Discipline

A

Central Bank has to cause deflation in times of deficit to lower prices
What do “lower prices in Country A” mean?
* Supply of money down
* If you expect prices to fall in the future, you don’t buy anything today
* More expensive to borrow
BAD economic crisis!

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Gold standard and deflation

A

 World supply of gold is fixed
 Economic growth -> more goods chase less money -> prices fall, growth constrained
 Gold standard was able to persist because of new gold discoveries

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Bretton Woods

A

A hotel in New Hampshire…
* Agreement on the Post WWII monetary system
* A monetary system is a public good…
* Coordinating on a common system allowed for:
* increased international trade and finance
* a way to manage crises so they didn’t spread
* Attempted to solve a global problem:
* How to keep monetary policy autonomy and a fixed XR?

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

To fix or float

A

Trade & International capital flows lead to imbalances
* How do governments deal with imbalances, assuming free capital
flows?
* Fixed XR  sacrifice monetary policy
* OR
* Floating XR  exchange rate uncertainty
* Trade off between:
* Exchange rate stability vs.
* domestic price stability with monetary policy autonomy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Keynesianism

A
  • Based on observation of high
    unemployment in Britain
    1920s&30s
  • Alternative neoclassical
    economics (“the market will fix
    it”)
  • Governments can (should) use
    monetary and fiscal policy to
    help the economy out of crises
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Why did bretton woods fail?

A

The institutions didn’t work:
* IMF lacked true authority over XR policy.
Governments didn’t comply, they did what they
wanted
* Governments didn’t like conditionality (still don’t)
* The stabilization fund wasn’t large enough to deal
with the new imbalances caused by globalization
US unwilling/unable to maintain system:
* Bretton Woods depended on the US to exchange $ for gold.
* US was spending more money than was entering the country
* Expansionary Macroeconomic Policy: More spending Vietnam
War + social spending, without higher taxes
* US dollars left the country (high imports + US investors invest
more abroad)
* Increased claims on US gold by foreigners who received dollars.
* Eventually… dollars > actual gold.
* If confidence in peg was in question, investors would rush to
sell dollars (speculation), heightened by newly dynamic capital
markets.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

US privileged, currency used as reserve

A

“exorbitant privilege”:
* Federal Reserve could run BoP deficits and conduct
monetary policy to influence aggregate demand,
output and employment
* But US monetary policy influenced economies of
other countries, especially as capital mobility rose
25
US Privileged
* Suppose USA increased its money supply:
* lower US interest rates, putting downward pressure
on the value of the US dollar
* If other central banks maintain their fixed exchange
rates, need to buy dollar-denominated (foreign)
assets, increasing their money supplies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Options to fix bretton woods

A

To “fix” the problem:
* The US would have to constrain US economy,
run trade-surpluses, change foreign policy
* Adjust the peg to gold (requires coordination,
can’t be done unilaterally)
* Expand economic activity in the rest of the
world (many states unwilling to experience
inflation).
* None of these options was politically popular

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

End of bretton woods

A

First, speculation about devaluation of the dollar caused large purchase of
gold by investors
 Federal Reserve sold huge quantities of gold in March 1968
 US President Nixon “closes the gold window” on August 15 1971 = no more gold-US
dollar exchange
* Second, speculation about devaluation of dollar caused investors to purchase
large quantities of foreign currency assets
 Coordinated devaluation of the dollar against foreign currencies of about 8% occurred
in December 1971
 Speculation about another devaluation occurred: European central banks sold huge
quantities of European currencies in February 1973
 Japan and Europe stopped selling their currencies and purchasing of dollars in March
1973, allowing the value of the dollar to fall
End of BW monetary system

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Core take aways bretton woods

A

Fixed exchange rate hard to maintain with increasing capital mobility +
democratic demands for domestic monetary policy
* Gold standard had been backed by the British, BW had been backed by
the US (remember hegemonic stability theory from trade lectures…)
* While it would’ve been nice to have XR stability, The US was no longer
in a position/willing to enforce cooperation.
 US acted in self-interested way
 As did other countries

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Post bretton woods

A

Post BW most major economies floated their currency
* Europe tried to organize a regional monetary cooperation around German
policy
* Eventually, adopt a monetary union (the EURO)
* Other countries floated or pegged to the $US/European currencies
* Dollar remains world’s reserve currency
* Despite floating XR, global imbalances still pose a threat to the global
economy…
* Uncoordinated macroeconomic policy still has the potential for large
problems…

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Electoral models; assumption

A
  • Help explain choice between fixed and floating exchange rate
  • Politicians have two major ways to influence the state of the
    economy
  • Fiscal policy (taxes & spending)
  • Monetary policy (adjust interest rates, if available)
  • Monetary policy is determined by a leader’s desire to control
    their own fate.
  • Assumption: Policymakers want monetary policy autonomy,
    only maintain fixed XR if compatible with MP they want to
    implement
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Electoral models; regime type and institutional heterogeneity

A

Regime Type:
* Democracies are more sensitive to the state of the domestic
economy…
* Therefore, monetary policy autonomy is more important (but not
irrelevant in non-democracies).
Institutional heterogeneity:
* Electoral rules in different democracies (or non-democracies) might
alter these incentives.
* Veto players
* The more fiscal constraints, the more monetary policy autonomy is
valued
* Ex. Obama and the Republican Congress

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Electoral models institutions and credibility

A

Institutions and Credibility:
 Fixed XR requires a commitment to uphold the peg…
 Democracies might not be the best at upholding commitments…
 Why? Elections…
 Politicians often have incentives to focus on the next election, not
long-term commitments

17
Q

Partisan models

A

XR policy is determined by the ruling party’s ideology/interests
* Remember the Phillips Curve: There is a trade-off between inflation and
employment
* Left-wing parties are “pro-employment”
* Tend to represent labor organizations, poor folks
* Right-wing parties are “anti-inflation”
* Tend to represent business interests, rich folks
* The partisan model reflects the FACTOR model of trade politics

18
Q

Partisan models, prediction

A
  • Prediction of partisan model:
  • Right-wing governments are more likely than left-wing governments
    to establish & maintain a fixed XR
  • Right-wing governments are more likely than left-wing governments
    to promote a “strong currency” (because it requires taming inflation)
  • Connection with Electoral Model:
  • Voters choose left-wing parties during recessions & right wing
    parties under inflation
19
Q

Sector models

A

Interest groups have different preferences towards the trade-off:
* Some prefer XR stability
* Others like monetary policy autonomy
* The “sector” of employment determines preferences.

20
Q

Export oriented producers and XR

A

Export-oriented producers
 Fixed XR: stability for int’l transactions
 Weak XR: lowers price of products abroad

21
Q

Allies and adversaries

A

XR stability:
* Non-tradeable and import competing want flexibility
* Export oriented wants stability
* XR strength:
* Export oriented and import-competing want a weak currency
* Non-tradeables want strong currency

22
Q

Criticisms electoral model

A

Electoral Model:
* Limited in explanation. Tells us only why a government might abandon a fixed XR.
* Some governments don’t abandon fixed XRs according to its predictions

23
Q

Time inconsistency problem

A
  • In the long-run, governments want price stability, but in the short-run,
    boosting employment is tempting
  • How can we avoid this problem?
  • Adopt a fixed exchange rate? Ties your hands to stop using expansionary
    monetary policy
  • This is the choice many developing countries make (remember Argentina’s
    election…)
  • Democracies don’t do well with fixed XR and free capital flows
  • Domestic price instability…
  • Inability to deal with real crises
24
Q

Solution time inconsistency problem

A

Governments might adopt an INDEPENDENT CENTRAL BANK
* Appointed for long terms
* Don’t face electoral pressures
* Or are distanced from them

25
Q

Central banks as commitment mechanisms

A

Political independence provides the mechanism to maintain monetary
policy autonomy but not tempt politicians (too much) to abuse it.
* Central banks differ in their independence
* Freedom to choose economic objectives to pursue
* Inflation and/or employment
* Freedom to set monetary policy to pursue that objective
* Whether the policy can be reversed by politicians in government

26
Q

European central bank

A

European Central Bank
* Mandate for price stability primarily
* Each country appoints a governing member
* An executive council sets decisions
* Appointed to non-renewable 8-year terms
* Appointed by “common accord” of member governments
* Can’t be removed by politicians

27
Q

US federal reserve

A
  • President appoints a Fed Chair every four years (in non-presidential election
    years)
  • Confirmed by the Senate
  • Can’t be removed
  • Must “report” to Congress bi-yearly
  • Now has a dual mandate to pursue low unemployment and stable prices and
    interest rates
  • This set -up allows it to act in times of crisis but avoid political time
    inconsistency problems.
28
Q

Four innovations bretton woods

A
  • FOUR INNOVATIONS:
    1. Fixed but adjustable XR
    2. Capital Controls
    3. Stabilization Funds
    4. The IMF
29
Q

Criticisms sector model

A
  • Sector Model
  • Overestimates importance of fixed XR to export interests
  • They have ability to purchase insurance
  • Weak currency also increases production costs, eliminating some gains to tradedgoods sector (remember supply chains…)
  • They also use imported imports, which rise in cost as a currency weakens
  • Can’t tell us much about which sectors will prevail in political competition.
30
Q

Criticisms partisan models

A
  • Partisan Model
  • Monetary policy preferences aren’t always neatly distributed across parties. Other
    issues matter.
  • Leftists sometimes pursue contradictory measures, rightists are sometimes
    expansionary.
  • Can’t explain situations where monetary policy is separated from politics
    (Independent Central Banks)
31
Q

Financial services industry and XR rate

A

Financial services industry.
 XR stability for int’l transactions
 But XR volatility can be profitable
 Currency trade
 Monetary policy autonomy maintains stable domestic banking system
 WEAK preferences for floating XR
 No preference for strength of currency
 Buy foreign assets when XR is strong, repatriate investments when XR is weak.
 Win/win

32
Q

Nontraded goods producers and XR

A

Nontraded-goods producers
 Floating XR: prefers monetary policy to address
recession/inflation
 Strong XR: consumes more traded goods, travel more, pay for
tuition….

33
Q

Import competing producers and XR

A

Import-competing producers
 Floating XR: prefer monetary policy to address recessions/inflation
 Weak XR: keeps imports high, they are more competitive.