Lecture 1 Flashcards
Mercantilism
Close to realism
Focuses on state as main unit of analysis, rather than subnational interests
Assumption -> states use economic policy to increase power
National power comes from economic power
* Back in the day meant = who has the biggest pile of gold
Liberalism
Countries and individuals gain from trade by exploiting comparative advantage
* Focuses mainly on individual welfare
No harm in engaging in trade
* A rising tide lifts all boats
* All trade is good, not just a positive balance
Implication is that role of state should be limited
Marxism central factors
Not the policy prescriptions but the theory underlying them
2 central factors (players)
* Capital (means of production, owned by bourgeoisie) and wage labour (proletariat)
Subsistence wage for laborers, capitalists keep surplus
Capital becomes more concentrated and less profitable
Increasing inequality and eventual workers revolution that abolishes private property
Modern approach
o Interest ideas and institutions
The interaction between societal interest, how people interpret them and the political institutions that aggregate them into policy
Interests
Do you win or lose from a certain policy or proposed policy?
Material interests can be shaped by endowments
* Factor of production (Land, labour (skilled and unskilled) capital)
* Industry (what kind of industries employs you (sector))
“Tell me where you work and I’ll tell you your political preferences”
context depending
Ideas
IPE scholars often start with assumption of objective economic interests, often quite accurate/useful simplification of messy reality
Ideas and ideology can also matter
Interpreting the facts
* Even among macro economists, there is no agreed upon economic theory
* What economic theory decision makers believe in informs policy choices
* individuals often use simplified mental models to understand the economy (private vs government household)
What is an institution?
A set of rules that governs behaviour
Both enforced and unenforced
* QWERTY, driving on the right
Domestic institutions
* Democracy, dictatorship, in between
* Presidential, parliamentary
* # of parties, electoral rules
International institutions
* WTO
* UN
* EU
* IMF and world bank
What drives political behaviour
Material, ideational and political incentives
Cooperation in IPE
interaction in which 2 or more actors adopt politics that make at least one actor better off relative to the status quo without making others worse off
Bargaining in IPE
an interaction in which actors must choose outcomes that make one actor better off at the expense of another, bargaining is redistributive, it involves allocating a fixed sum of value between different actors.
When actors bargain, they move along the pareto frontier
Coordination as type of cooperation
actors benefit from all making the same choices and subsequently having no incentive not to comply
Collaboration as a subtype of cooperation
actors gain from working together but nonetheless have incentives to not comply with any agreement
Prisoner’s dilemma
shows that individual incentives often make cooperation difficult. Individual incentive to defect undermines the collective interest to cooperate. Simple model with strong implications
Stag hunt
2 hunters can work together to kill a stag and feed their families well or individually hunt a rabbit. Outcome is indeterminate (depends on trust)
Public goods
nonrival in consumption and nonexcludable. Achieving public goods is hindered by collective action problems
Factors that facilitate cooperation
Institutions
number and relative size of actors
iteration, linkage and strategies of reciprocal punishment
Information
Hegemonic stability theory
- Liberalization occurs when a hegemon exists to monitor and
enforce the rules of the international trade regime (also applies
to monetary policy) - May help explain the global trading system
Before WWI: British Hegemony
After WWII: US Hegemony
Mercantilists and export
mercantilists are in favour of export because the money you get in return is more for your pile of gold and import is therefore bad
o Was once partly true when state was the economy
* Exports vary in importance
o Manufactured goods are superior
* Implication – economy should be controlled in order to gain power
* The countries that export (increasing power) win, import loses(decreasing power)
Hegemonic stability theory implications and evident in….
- Implications:
As the hegemon’s power declines, so should international trade - Evident against:
We still see growing liberalization despite the US decline in share of
trade
Cooperation might be possible without a single power
Iteration, institutions, information
marxism contradiction and implication
Inherent contradiction, people that are supposed to buy the goods, get such little wages so crises will follow
Very pessimistic about politicians and state
The state exists to protect capital, not labour
Internationally, imperial exploitation of the global south by the global north
Implication – revolution of the masses to abolish this system
Modern approach, what drives political behaviour?
o What drives political behaviour
Material (societal)
* Qui bono – whose welfare increases/decreases with different policy options?
Ideational
* How do people/decision makers interpret their material interests/the state of the economy
Political (institutional)
* What will keep leaders in office? What checks and balances are they subjected to?