Lecture 2: TMS Flashcards
What are brain perturbations?
They impair or influence cognitive functions
Wht can brain perturbations arise from?
e.g., perturbations from brain damage in stroke patients, disease or trauma but perturbations induced experimentally using pharmacological or electrical methods
Infromation from brain perturbations have
greatly advanced our understanding of the neural underpinnings of cognitive functions
What is lesion studies?
When a specific brain region is purposefully or incidentally damaged, and consequentially specific cognitive functions are affected, these functions are causally connected to processing in this region.
Lesions and TMS give advantage, over fMRI EEG being correlaiton, is that
causal
Example of lesion study - (3)
In 1948, Phineas Gage had a workplace accident in which an iron tamping rod entered and exited his skull.
He survived but it is said that his personality changed as a result, leading to a greater understanding of the brain regions involved in personality, namely the frontal lobe
famous patient with frontal cortex lesion - accidental lesion
There are two types of lesion studies - (2)
- Invasive methods
- Non-invasive methods
Invasive methods of lesion studies - (4)
- Destory processing in brain region of interest –> advantage can tightly control ROI
- Can for instance be done by remving brain tissue or cooling region
- Ethically very problematic
- Done in animals
What are non-invasive methods of lesion studies? - (2)
- Studying patients with incidental lesions(e.g., due to stroke/posioning) in specific parts of their brain e.g., phineas gage
- Using brain stimulation to temporarlly impair neural processing (TMS)
What does lesion mapping in patients require?
use of structural imaging (e.g., structural MRI)
What is involved in lesion mapping? - (2)
Carefully mapping the damaged cortical regions allows for establishing spatially specific and causal relationships between brain activations and cognitive functions
mapping where the lesions is happening
There is database in lesion mapping across the world which - (2)
have structural images and where the lesion is and catalogue of functions assessed
if interested what causes arithmetic difficulties and find list of patients with this in database and overlap their lesions in MRI and find common area impaired in all of them
Lesion Mapping in Patients
What does this diagram show? - (2)
MRI scans of patient D.F (on right) and healthy volunteer)
D.F had damage to visual cortex called lateral occipital and not acivated vs healthy volunteer L0 activated in task that activates it
Whats a single dissociation in lesion studies?
A lesion to a specific region leads to an impairment in a specific task (but not in other tasks)
What is the problem with single dissociations? - (2)
Single dissociations my be found when the two tasks are differently sensitive (e.g., different task demands or difficulty
e.g., has a patient who is deficit in factual arithemtic e.g., 2+2 = 4 but okay in comparing numbers then say task is quite difficult and different from each other
The problem of single dissociation that they are found when 2 tasks are differently sensitive (e.g., different task demands/difficulty) is aggravated/increased by
fact that participants may have unspecific impairments that impair their performance in various tasks with high sensitivity
Whats example of single dissociation? - D.F - (3)
Single dissociation between dorsal and ventral stream functions in the visual system
Traumatic lesion in human ventral stream (patient D.F.) leads to impaired object perception (matching card in the angle of slot), but leaves object-guided action intact (posting - card through angular slot)
healthy volunteers good at both
What is a double dissociation? - (2)
A lesion to one region leads to an impairment in a specific task (but not the second task), and a lesion to another region leads to an impairment in another specific task (but not the first task)
e.g., patient who can do arithmetic 2+2 = 4 but not number comparison and patient who can do number comparison and not arithmetic and have lesions in different areas
What does double dissociation reveal?
Reveals unequivocal links between lesion and putative (supposed) brain function, that are not explicable by the tasks’ sensitivity
What is an example of double dissociation?
: Double dissociation between dorsal and ventral stream functions in the primate visual system - (3)
- Trained macaque monkeys in two tasks: 1) object discrimination of always picking up Toblerone shape object wherever it is, 2) landmark discrimination of monkeys always pick up the piece closer to cylinder
- Artificial lesions in macaque animals’ ventral stream (temporal lobe) leads to an impairment in object discrimination but not in landmark discrimination
- Artifical lesions in macaque animal’s dorsal steam (parietal cortex) leads to impairment in landmark discrimination but not object discrimination
What does this graph show in terms of single vs double dissociation? - (2)
- single dissociation, region A is reduced in function X but not in function Y
- In double dissociation , region A is reduced in function X but not in function Y, region B is reduced in function Y and not X
What are the 2 advantages of lesion studies? - (2)
- Reveals causal links between brain regions and functions esp in double dissociation in patients
- High spatial precision (when done invasively - in animals artifical lesions)
What are the weaknesses of lesion studies? - (4)
- Low temporal precision
- Low spatial precision (when studying incidental lesions)
- Confounding impairments are not unlikely –> e.g., patients have number of processing deficits but may also have speech problems - lesions may not just impair one function so lesion mapping is useful
- Experimentation can be difficult, costly, and unethical (animals in lab)
What is brain stimulation?
Driving neural activation to understand brain function