Lec 2 Flashcards
What are the key components of Darwin’s theory of natural selection?
More born than can survive; struggle for existence; variation via natural selection
What are three broad classes of evidence used to support evolution and natural selection?
Artificial selection
Island radiation
Fossil record
Behavioral data
Morphological data
Embryological data
Molecular data
What are two examples of features Darwin had trouble explaining by natural selection?
Evolution of complex traits
Traits with little importance (i.e. male nipples)
Elaborate traits with no fitness advantage
Source of variation
Natural Selection and Adaptation
Individuals with alleles best suited to their environment survive and reproduce
Components of Natural Selection: 4 main observations led to Darwin;s discovery of Natural Selection
10 Individuals within species are variable
2) Some of these variations are passed on to their offspring - they are HERITABLE
3) In every generation, more offspring are produced than can survive to reproduce
4) Survival and reproduction are non random - individuals carrying specific variations best suited to their environment survive and reproduce the most (have HIGHER FITNESS)
Case Study: California Drought
California declared a state of emergency every year from 2000-2004
Plants were particularly hard hit - drought SHORTENED THE GROWING SEASON of Brassica rapa, a species of mustard in Souther California
In particular, later in the summer became too hot and dry for mustard to grow
What pattern is shown in this figure?
Descendant (post-drought) plants flower earlier than ancestral plants
Based on your understanding of evolutionary theory, what might you hypothesize the response to intense drought to be in mustard populations?
Flower earlier
Is this the pattern you would hypothesize under natural selections?
Yes - a shorter growing season due to drought should select for plants that flower earlier
Drought selects for earlier flowering time
Plants derived from the seeds of the 2004 parents flowered earlier, on average, than plants derived from the seeds of the 1997 parents
What is variation?
Much of variation is caused by differences in DNA sequences; Darwin did NOT know what the cause of variation was
What does variation look like at the genetic level?
All of the alleles (or genetic variants) from all of the individuals in this population make up the GENE POOL
AAACTGTTT
AAACTTTTT
AAACTATAT
Key vocabulary: Phenotype
The outward appearance of an organism
Key vocabulary: Genotype
The genetic constitution of an individual organism
Genetic variation underlying the phenotype
Phenotype vs Genotype
Natural selection does not directly act on genotypes, but rather it acts on phenotypic differences among the individuals in a population
Phenotypes are sets of observable characteristics
They represent the interaction of genes and environment
To understand natural selection, we have to understand how the interaction between genotype and environment determines the phenotype
Key vocabulary: Heritability
The mount of variation in a phenotype due to genotype
How much is CAUSED by the genotype; some variation NOT heritable because it is due to the environment
Not all variation is heritable: Phenotypic Plasticity
The same genotype expresses different phenotypes in different environments
i.e. a house plant put in a dark corner with no water won’t grow very tall; take the same plant and put it outside in the sun with lots of water, it grows tall; plant has the SAME genotype but is provided different nutrients to express different phenotypes
Phenotypic plasticity: Reaction Norms
Norms of reaction - each line shows a different genotype. The x-axis is DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENTS, and the y-axis is EXPRESSION of phenotype. The same genotype looks different in different environments
How we show reactions in particular environments; basically a graph
Each line is a _______
Reaction norm
Do most genotypes show a similar relationship between leaf area and light intensity? (Based off graph)
Yes, most genotypes have the largest leaf area at intermediate light intensity
Resemblance among relative: Genes vs. environment
Second of Darwin’s observations that led to natural selection is that offspring resemble parents
Language APPEARS to be heritable: offspring resemble parents, and there are clear differences among populations
Language is NOT heritable - if you raise the child of English-speaking parents in a Spanish-speaking household, the children will speak Spanish. This trait is 100% environmentally determined
Only traits that have a genetic basis can evolve over time
Traits that are 100% environmentally determined CANNOT be acted on by natural selection
Is language heritable?
NO
100% environmentally determined
Why can’t 100% environmentally determined traits evolve by selection?
a) They are too variable and selection would be ineffective
b) Evolution by selection is change in allele frequencies over time and there are no alleles in these traits
c) Offspring don’t resemble parents in environmental traits
b) Evolution by selection is change in allele frequencies over time and there are no alleles in these traits
Only traits that are GENETICALLY determined can be selected
What is fitness?
Fitness: RELATIVE genetic contribution of individuals to future generations
2 components of fitness:
1) Survival
2) Reproduction
For your genes to make it to the next generation, you need to SURVIVE and PRODUCE OFFSPRING
Relative Fitness
Fitness is the RELATIVE genetic contribution of individuals to future generations
If individual fitness > mean population fitness, relative fitness HIGH; if individual fitness < mean population fitness, relative fitness LOW
Relative Fitness = Individual Fitness/Mean Population Fitness
Mean Population Fitness = Sum of each population/number of populations
This means that how fit you are doesn’t just depend on who many offspring YOU have, it depends on the ratio you have to everyone else
In this course, we consider how selection affects relative fitness
Who has the higher relative fitness within its population, the WHITE MOUSE in population 1 or population 2?
Pop 1: W = 10,000 offspring
B = 1000 offspring
Pop 2: W = 100 offsrping
B = 10 offspring
Rel. fitness for pop. 1:
Mean = (10,000+1,000)/2 = 5,500
Rel. fitness = 10,000/5,500 = 1.82
Rel. fitness for pop. 2:
Mean = (100+10)/2 = 55
Rel. fitness = 100/55 = 1.82
They have the SAME FITNESS
Fitness means the “strong” survive T or F
FALSE
Darwinian Fitness
The ability of an individual to survive and reproduce in its environment
NOT the same as reproductive fitness
Fitness measures:
The variable success in reproduction of the individuals in a population, comparing them to each other
It is NOT how many offspring YOU have, it is how many you have COMPARED to everyone else
Darwinian fitness is ___________ - your fitness only matters in relation to other individuals in your population
Relative, not absolute
Fitness (is, is not) fixed
is NOT
If your environment changes, your fitness may also change
Why do we care about fitness?
Fitness is the currency of natural selection/evolution
Examples of natural selection: Peromyscus polionotus
Shows all 4 of Darwin’s observations:
-Variation in the phenotype (gradient of light and dark colors)
- Variation is heritable
- -Phenotype variation can arise through genetic variation along, variation in environment alone, or through a combination of both
- -ONLY heritable variation can be acted on by natural selection
- Genetic variation and phenotype
- -Beach mice typically carry a recently evolved form of the Agouti allele and a mutation at the Mc1R gene that contributes to their lighter coat color
- -Underlying genetic basis of coat color is the Mc1R gene (receptor pathway)
- -Mutation is genes to results in this lighter color
Are there fitness consequences to color variation (is there differential survival in different environments)?
YES, population will evolve to have coat to suit environment
Put mice down on varying colors of soil: shown percentage of mice captures by predators
Light mice captured more in dark environments; vice versa is true as well
Fitness consequences: Experimental test using mouse models
Natural selection leads to populations of pale mice in light habitats and dark mice in dark habitats
Dark mice attacked in light habitats, same for light in dark habitats
Consequence of natural selection:
-Light mice in light environments will survive and be more fit; proportions of light mice will go up in light habitats
What does relative fitness mean?
Who has the higher relative fitness within its population, the WHITE MOUSE in population 1 or population 2?
Pop. 1: W = 10,000 offspring
B = 15,000 offspring
Pop. 2: W = 10 offspring
B = 5 offspring
Rel. fitness 1:
Mean = (10,000+15,000)/2 = 12,500
Rel. fit = 10,000/12,500 = 0.8
Rel. fitness 2:
Mean = (10+5)/2 = 7.5
Rel. fit = 10/7.5 = 1.33
Population 2 has the higher relative fitness
Adaptation
Adaptive means “reproductively advantageous for individuals” or “beneficial for the genes underlying development of the trait”
An adaptation is a trait associated with the highest relative fitness in a given environment
-You will have more offspring survive if they have the particular ADAPTATION that helps with survival
Natural selection is the only mechanism that consistently causes adaptive evolution
-Evolution can occur via processes other than natural selection; however, natural selection is the ONLY type of evolution that leads to adaptive evolution since it isolates the ones that work and those that don’t