Knowledge of God's Existence Flashcards
natural theology
drawing conclusions about the nature and activity of God by using reason and observing the world
protestantism
- rejects authority of Catholic Church
- places greater emphasis on the Bible and personal faith
revelation
when God chooses to let himself be known
immediate revelation
when someone is given direct knowledge of God
mediate revelation
when someone gains knowledge of God in a secondary non direct way
how did the Greeks understand knowledge of God
- spoke of difficulty of gaining true/certain knowledge of world in constant motion/change
- Plato addressed with Theory of the Forms
- Aristotle said we can only learn anything meaningful through science, looking at physical world
how can we learn
- born with knowledge
- through sense experience
- reason and logic - take deductive steps to work out what is true
- from sources of authority like teachers where we have to have a degree of faith that what they are telling us is true
what do different people argue is the genuine knowledge worth pursuing
- that which comes from reason/sense experience
- religious believers however say its limited as only gives people knowledge of physical world
- don’t help gain knowledge about spiritual or ethical truths about how we ought to live
- but some people argue there are no such thing as supernatural or ethical truths
- physical world all that exists
god for empiricists
- unavailable to five sense as God is not physical
- for those who think only real knowledge is gained through sense God can’t be known and perhaps doesn’t exist at all
- same if people believe knowledge is gained through reason and logic as he is said to be beyond the realms of the rational and beyond capabilities of human mind
what did Bonaventura think
- a Franciscan monk
- human mind has three different ways of knowing
- used analogy of an eye to represent the different ways of seeing
- popular through Christian history
- influenced Polkinghorne
what is Bonaventura’s analogy of the eye
eye of the flesh:
- incorporates sense perception - empiricism of science
- eye by which we gain knowledge about the physical world
eye of reason:
- lets us work out maths and philosophical truths through logic
eye of contemplation:
- goes beyond sense experience and reason gaining knowledge of God through faith
Polkinghorne
- Binocular vision - looking through two dif eyes
- science through one eye - shows him physical world, laws and processes behind it
- spiritual truths through the other which show purposefulness and the world in the context of the creation of God
- both eyes need to work together to give a complete picture
- foolish of some religious people to ignore the discoveries of science and equally foolish of some scientists to close one eye and refuse to engage with possibilities of God
what do religious believers argue about the type of out knowledge of God
- can be known not only in the way we know facts but also the way we know people
- knowing the PM exists is different from knowing him personally
- god can be known not just in the sense of knowing his existence but also known personally in a relationship
distinction in Christian thought between natural and revealed theology
natural theology
- gaining knowledge of God through powers of human reason and observation
revelation theology
- God choosing to reveal himself directly through RE and scripture
- both can help understand religious truths
- but some argue only revelation is reliable
robert boyle
- science developed in 17th/18th century
- created metaphor of God’s two books
- the natural world and Bible created by the same author
- words of Bible and scientific discoveries are complementary enhancing knowledge
revelation flow chart
- revelation - general - natural world - scientific study
- revelation - special - scripture - theological study
- natural world and scripture in complete agreement
- scientific and theological study sometimes disagree
discuss the revelation flow chart
- everyone has access to general revelation as all have reason/can see natural world regardless of belief
- special revelation given specifically to Christians through scripture
- nothing incorrect in scripture - natural world and scripture both created by God thus in agreement - both him revealing himself
- scientific and theological study disagree because of human error - we make mistakes in our interpretations of things and how we see things
how has natural theology played an important part in forming and supporting belief
- looking at beauty of world leads to conclusion there must be a creator
- like Paley’s design argument
- Bible offers this view
- Psalms - night sky evidence of God’s relationship with humanity
- “when i consider your heaven you made them rulers over the works of your hand”
natural theology for Aquinas
- important in demonstrating that Christian belief was reasonable
- Aristotle and scientific common sense thinking raised some questions about Christianity
- Aquinas keen to assert that it was reasonable to support Christianity - reason and observation employed in support not opposition
- e.g. world in constant state of change so can work out there is a Prime Mover
Richard Swinburne
- modern supporter of natural theology
- our human reason and observation provide us with solid ground for probability of a God
- good reason to think the world shows signs of order that leads us to conclude there is an intelligent being, author of the universe
natural theology as rising from an innate human sense of the divine (Cicero)
- in all cultures and times in history people have had a sense of there been a infinite being in control of universe
- cultures which can’t have known about each other’s existence developed similar beliefs of a God
natural theology as rising from an innate human sense of the divine (Bible)
- Genesis - God makes people in his image - breathes life into Adam suggesting spark of divinity in each human life which could mean we are designed to seek and respond to God