Investigative Interviewing Flashcards
Cognitive interview
- recommended for use with cooperative witnesses, victims or suspects
Geiselman (1986)
CIT enhanced memory recall and reduced the effect of leading questions
4 stages
- Witness reports everything
- Reinstate the context
- Witness recalls details of crime in different orders
- Witness recalls the event from various perspectives of others at the time
Enhanced cognitive interview
Cognitive interview combined with the technique from social psychology of communication
Skills?
- Interviewer helps relax witness and builds rapport
- Actively listens
- Encourages spontaneous recall
- Ask open ended questions
- Pause after response
- Avoid interrupting
- Request detailed descriptions
- Recreate original context
Irving (1980)
- police use of persuasive and manipulative tactics
- manipulating suspects self esteem
- pretending they had more evidence than they had
- Pointing out the futility of denial
- advising interviewees it was in their interest to confess
- minimising the seriousness of the offence
Baldwin (1993)
- officers were unprepared, nervous and lacked confidence
- used leading questions
- made assumptions of guilt
Police interview training
- aimed to enhance the effectiveness of investigative interviews
PEACE (1992)
Preparation and Planning Engage and Explain Account Closure Evaluation
Effectiveness - Gudjonsson (1992)
- some People are more likely than others to be coerced into giving false information during interrogation
Gudjonsson suggestibility scale
- measures how susceptible a person is to coercive interrogations
Two different aspects :
Yield
Shift
Yield?
Persons tendency to give in to leading questions
Shift
Persons tendency to change their response when put under interpersonal pressure
Clarke and Milne (2001)
Little evidence of rapport building
Time consuming
Expensive to train
Brief improvement
PACE requirements - suspect interviews
- audio recorded
- right to legal advice
- cautioned against self incrimination
- asked to recall crime but also explain intentions
- adult representation if under 18
Victim/w interviews
- recommended audio recording
- don’t have right to legal advice
- not cautioned against self incrimination
- if under 18 adult recommended but not entitled to be present
- asked to recall crime they’re involved in or observed