Individual Differences Flashcards
What was the aim of Freud’s study
To document the case of little Hans a boy who was going through the phallic stages of development and to confirm whether Freud’s theories about the unconscious and Oedipus complex were true
What was the procedure in Freud’s study?
Hans’ father recorded detail of Hans behaviour and conversations- made own interpretations and sent to Freud in letter
Freud would reply with his interpretation and gave guidance on what his father should look for and be talking with hans
What was the sample in Freud’s study?
One normal boy
3 years old to 5 years old
What is the Oedipus complex.
Children develope a desire to have a sexual relationship with their opposite gender parent and are fearful of same gender parent
What is the psychosexual development theory
Oral stage - thumb sucking like nipple sucking
Anal stage - holding back stool for pleasure
Phallic stage - contains Oedipus complex
Latency stage - interests go from sexual desire to hobbies
Genital stage - desire directed at others like them not parents
Discuss ethics of Freud
“Little hans” protect the identity of child
Consent came from parents
Discuss validity of Freud
Is freuds interpretations correct? More obvious explanations
Eg giraffe dream cause he has been to the zoo
Use of leading questions “when horse fell down did you think of daddy”
Discuss reliability of Freud
Sample of one is too small to establish consistent effect , in order to say all children progress through these 5 psychosexual stages of development larger sample needed
Is Freud ethnocentric
Yes, in terms of middle class child in Vienna different to experiences of child in poorer places No as phobias are common in children across the world
Some case history of Freud - phobias and fantasies
- Letter said Hans aged 3.5 yrs old had lively interest in his widdler, mother told him “if you do that I shall send for Dr to cut off your widdler”
- age 4.5 Hans being powered Hans asked his mother “why don’t you put your finger there” “it’s great fun”
- fear of horses biting Hans
- dream about giraffes and went and told parents next morning
- scared of what horses blinkers and muzzles
- liked lumf
- plumber fantasy widdler cut off and given new one
Freud’s interpretations
- fear of castration, anxiety begins
- tries to seduce mum by asking her to touch widdler
- fear of horses biting is to do with fear of having widdler cut off, effect of mother’s threat
- long neck giraffe is dad as big penis, crumpled giraffe is mum, during night seized with longing for mother hence coming into bedroom
- blinkers look like fathers glasses and muzzle looks like his moustache
- lumf -fear of defecation and carts falling over linked to heavily loaded stomach
- fantasy of plumber shows Hans over coming fear of castration
Why does Freud link to psychology as science
- case study is unique and impossible to replicate
- freuds interpretations were subjective as his own opinions (qualitative)
- unclear how to prove freuds theory wrong as can’t know what the unconscious is
Why does freud support nature nurture
Stated that “both disposition and experience can be expected to play part in anxiety disorders”
Nature- child’s constitution
Nurture - child’s experiences as they grow up
Why does Freud link to reductionism and holism
Reductionist- only explained phobias and fantasies in relation to his own theory of psychosexual development
Holistic- in-depth case study over two years meant Hans was not restricted to what experiences he could reveal
Why does Freud fall into individual differences
Investigates how people differ by phobias
Comes from psychodynamic perspective due to how Hans behaviour was explained
Why does Freud link to key theme of understanding disorders
Freud suggests that understanding disorders sjousl be done by understand the unconscious conflicts
Aim of baron-Cohen
Develop advanced test of theory of mind of adults
Sample of baron-Cohen
Group 1-16 high functioning autistic or Asperger adults, normal intelligence 13 males and 3females
Group 2-50 normal adults, 25 male, 25 female, no history of psychiatric conditions selected randomly
Group 3-10 adults with Tourette’s, 8 male, 2 female
What were the three groups matched on in baron Cohen
Age 18-49
Normal IQ
What did baron Cohen hypothesise
- participants with autism or Asperger would show sig impairment on eyes task
- normal female perform better in eye task than normal males
What was procedure in baron Cohen
Tested individually either at home or in researcher clinic
Given 4 tasks to do, tasks presented in random order
-eyes task
-strange stores task
-gender recognition task
-basic emotion recognition task
What did the tasks in baron Cohen consist of
—Eyes task- shown 25 photos for 3 seconds, all black and white, only showed eyes, had to choose one of two contrasting words which showed emotion of eyes
- Strange stories-24 stories including irony, white lie, lie, truth, joke, figure of speech, participant asked to explain why they character said or did what they did
- gender recognition-looked at same setsof eyes and say if female or male
- basic emotion-photo of whole face, 6 photos had to say which emotion was shown either (happy sad disgust angry afraid surprise)
How were the words in eye task chosen
Panel of 8 (4 male and 4 female) blind to hypothesis agreed on words
What was the point in the tasks other than eye task
Strange stories should present same results as eye task
Others were controls to check for deficits on eye task due to other factors
Results of baron Cohen eye task
Autistic 16.3, SD of 2.9, range of 13-23
Normal 20.3, SD of 2.63, range of 16-25
Tourette’s 20.4, SD of 2.63, range of 16-25
Results of second hypothesis baron Cohen
Males 18.8, SD 2.53, range 26-22
Females 21.8, SD 1.78, range 20-25
Discuss ethics of baron Cohen
- assumed consent given but unclear if it was informed fully about eyetask
- options reduced harm by enabling them to see an answer, however anxiety over giving wrong one
- withdrawal could have stopped answering questions