Gender and Theology Flashcards
What type of feminist was Ruether?
•She was a reform feminist theologian
What did Ruether argue about Christianity?
•She argues that Christianity has become distorted by patriarchal traditions, and needs to be reformed as a result
What does Ruether argue the patriarchy has also distorted?
•She argues it has also distorted the way Christians think about God
- This is because she believes we need to move away from our traditional understanding of God as male as this will allow Christianity to move away from the sin of sexism
What quote by Ruether supports that we should move away from our traditional understanding of God as male?
•She argues that “male language for the divine must lose its privileged place”
What 2 main challenges does Ruether make to male language being used about God?
- She challenges the idea that Jesus fulfilled the expectation of a Messiah who would be a male warrior embodying male characteristics
- She argues that Christians need to go back to an understanding of the characteristics of God being both male and female
What is the definition of messiah?
•It means “God’s anointed”
- It was applied to Davidic Kings who ruled Israel as they were the Son of God and the Son of Man (due to being chosen by God and also ruling over people)
What does Ruether argue about real Kings?
•She argues that they do not live up to the high standards of the title Messiah
- This caused the definition of Messiah to change to a future king, who would be a warrior that would free Israel from its foreign rule, and lead them to victory
What does Ruether argue about the hebraic framework?
• She argues “in the hebraic framework the Messiah can only be imagined as male”
- This is because in that society, only a man could be that kind of warrior King
Why does Ruether argue that Messiah no longer applies to Jesus?
•She argues that Messiah can no longer be applied to Jesus due to the Messiah being expected to win and “not to suffer and die” like Jesus did
- She also argues the title of Messiah does not apply to Jesus due to Jesus himself, not seeing himself as a warrior king (this is shown when Jesus rejects his disciples equating him to a King and also due to the fact he does not try to overthrow authorities)
What else does Ruether argue that Jesus cannot be seen as a warrior King?
•She argues he cannot be seen as a warrior King due to his teachings on a kingdom being not one that he would rule over, but one that was about establishing equality where “basic human needs are met and all dwell in harmony”
What did Jesus believe we should all be?
• Jesus believed that we should all be servants to God and that we should not seek to rule or dominate
Why does Ruether believe women are opressed?
•She believes women are oppressed due to men seeking to dominate them
What does Ruether argue is the true role of a Messiah?
• She argues that the true role of a messiah is to liberate
- This means Jesus can be compatible with feminism as he is speaking out for “the oppressed of the oppressed” (women)
What does Ruether not deny?
•She does not deny that Jesus was male but that the “maleness of Jesus has no ultimate significance”
What does Ruether argue Jesus should not be seen as?
•She argues that Jesus should not be seen as the “once-for-all”redeemer as he continues to liberate humanity through his followers (who can be “in the form of our sisters”)
Why does Ruether argue that Jesus cannot save women if he continues to be seen at the traditional male-warrior Messiah and if his maleness continues to be seen as important?
•She argues this because it excludes women from leadership in the church and makes them second-class citizens
- She argues this means Christians should understand Jesus as someone who liberates people and whose identity continues through the Christian community (this means he can save women)
How does the Old Testament reference Wisdom?
•It references to Wisdom as a personified woman
- It also refers to Wisdom as the part of God that creates and sustains the world while also guiding and revealing God to the world
What does Ruether believe the imagery of wisdom is based on?
•The Goddess of Wisdom
- This is supported by the name of Wisdom in Greek translating to “Sofia”
- However, attributes of this Goddess were transferred to the male God and can be seen in Jesus
What does Ruther argue “Sofia” begins to be replaced by?
•She argues that “Sophia” begins to be replaced by “Logos”
- This is a more masculine word which causes God’s characteristics to no longer be male and female
What does Ruether not want Christians to see wisdom as?
•She does not want Christians to see wisdom as the female side of God
- This is because it will cause the female to become subordinate to the male again
How does Ruether argue we should see language about God?
•She argues we should see language about God as analogies and understand them in apophatic tradition
- This means we see God both is and is not like the comparison being made (“God both is male and female and neither male nor female”)
* This supports Ruether’s beliefs that we should not assign only one gender to God
What does Ruether argue the Christian church has become towards women?
•She argues that the Christian church has become patriarchal and oppressive towards women
- This is supported by Ruether stating “the more one becomes a feminist the more difficult it becomes to go to Church”
Why does Ruether not see the ordination of women as the solution?
•She does not see this as the solution as all it does is encourage women to “think feel and act like ‘one of the boys’”
- This is not a solution as it is not change the patriarchal assumptions behind the hierarchical structure of the Church
How does Ruether create a solution?
•She turns to a feminist version of liberation theology to provide a model for a Christian community based on equality
- She believes this radical shift could happen in existing churches but that it would be difficult due to the clergy having to share their power with the community
What does Ruether argue is the only alternative for most Christians?
•She argues that the only alternative is “autonomous base communities”
- This is because they would be dedicated to excluding sexism and the patriarchy from their community
* She argues they do not need to replace traditional churches but that they can be used to challenge and change the traditional churches
Short summary of Ruether:
3 strengths of Ruether:
1 weakness of Ruether:
How does Chan critique Ruether?
•He argues that you cannot rewrite the Christian story to give more prominence to women, because the maleness of God is central to Christianity
- This is supported by God being described as the Father but never the Mother
Who argues that many ancient religions had both male and female gods, but were just as patriarchal is Christianity?
•Chan
- This mean changing the way Christians view God will not remove the patriarchy from Christianity
What type of feminist is Daly?
•A radical feminist theologian
What does Daley believe the problem facing woman is?
•She believes the problem facing women is a worldwide sexual caste system (this is when women are treated as a lower class of person and segregated from men)
- She believes this is brought about through sex role segregation