Forensic Psychology Flashcards
Top down approach
US
Start with pre established typologies and assign into a group
When was the td approach used
FBI
Gathered 36 interviews of sexually motivated killers and could categories into organised or disorganised
What is organised
Evidence of planning, above average intelligence
What is disorganised
No planning, impulsive, lonely
4 stages of FBI profile
- Data assimilation - evidence review
- Crime scene classification - organised or disorganised
- Crime reconstruction - hypothesis of events
- Profile generation - Hypothesis of likely offender
EVAL: Top down approach
- Obvious of distinct categories. Canter et al viewed 100 murders and found concurrence of 39
- Organised and disorganised not exclusive. Godwin suggests could be random
- TD can be adapted to other crimes, 85% of solved cases in 3 states in US (Meketa)
- FBI top down doesn’t have a scientific basis
Bottom up approach
UK
Generate a picture of the criminal through their actions and by systematic analysis at the crime scene no fixed typologies. Data driven
Investigative psychology
Matches details from a crime scene to statistical analysis of typical offender
Interpersonal coherence
The way in which offender behaves / interacts with the victim.
-E.g rapists more apologetic Dwyer
Significance of time and place
In geographic profiling
Forensic awareness
May be ‘mindful’ of their tracks
Geographical profiling 2 types
Marauder and commuter
What is geographical profiling
Uses info from crime scene to make inferences about their likely base.
Centre of gravity
Base of the criminal
Canter circle theory
That there is a circle around the offending home
What can geographical profiling show
Was the crime planned or opportunistic
EVAL: Bottom up approach
- Evidence, Canter and Heritage observed 66 sexual assault cases using smallest space analysis and there were common behaviours
- Lundrigan and Canter found centre of gravity with geographical profiling especially with marauder
- However geographical alone does not help, 75% of crimes are not even reported by people. Other factors important.
Atavistic form
Biological, that they look a certain way
Who created the atavistic form
Lombroso
What do criminals look like (atavistic form)
Murders- blood shot eyes, curly hair, long ears
Sexual deviant- Swollen, fleshy lips, thin and reedy
Also normally extra toes, nipples, dark skin, tattoos, unemployment, use of slang
Lombrosos research for atavistic form
Italian convicts
383 dead
3839 alive
40% of criminals had this atavistic form
IGNORE
IGNORE
Genetic twin studies of offending
Christiansen studied 3500 twin pairs in Denmark
Concordance rates for
35% MZ
13% DZ
Crowe said that adopted children with biological mother criminal record had
50% crime chance
5% without
What is the candidate gene
MAOA - aggression
CDH13 - substance abuse and ADHD
by Tihonen et al (500 Finnish offenders). 5-10% of severe crime