Fieldwork Human AS

Question 1

Re-development Fieldwork enquiry question

Answer 1

Hypothesis: The titanic Quarter’s redevelopment has created homogenous Belfast.
P: positive attitudes
E: same potential for redevelopment/ affluence
S: lived experiences

Question 2

Re-development enquiry methods

Answer 2

RICEPOTS tally
Potential for redevelopment ranking
Building decay tally

Question 3

RICEPOTS tally info (Belfast)

Answer 3

RICEPOTS: Used to tally up and estimate land uses and how they vary

Pros:
- Data was quantitative
- Some were easy to tally
- Could compare it to other quarters to see development

Cons:
- Some fit into multiple categories
- Hard to estimate % where tallies were not possible

Question 4

Potential for redevelopment ranking Building

Answer 4

Potential for re-development ranking Building: Ranked areas from 1-7 using criteria on the quality/quantity of RICEPOTS

Pros:
- Broad range of criteria
- Allowed us to see **potential for change
- Quantitative

Cons:
- Subjective
- Hard to correlate number to rank

Question 5

Building decay tally (Belfast/ Derry)

Answer 5

Building decay: tallied up the visible signs up of different measures of physical deprivation

Pros:
- Quantitative
- Objective
- Comparisons

Cons:
- Some deprivation could not be seen
- Some are too much to count
- Time
- Safety

Question 6

How did we survey development in Belfast

Answer 6

Split Belfast into four equal transects ((NESW) and spent time surveying each with multiple groups covering each area

Question 7

What does RICEPOTS mean?

Answer 7

R - residential
I - industrial
C - commercial
E - entertainment
P - public spaces
O - open spaces
T - transport
S - services

Question 8

Deprivation & inequality enquiry (Derry)

Answer 8

Methods
- Safety rank ((RAG)
- Accessibility rank
- building decay tally
- Questionnaire of perceptions

Question 9

Safety rank (Derry)

Answer 9

Safety rank: RAG-rated Derry areas to see safety and level of deprivation

Pros:
- Easy to do
- Comparable

Cons:
- Subjective
- May vary over time

Question 10

Accesibility rank

Answer 10

Potential for re-development ranking Building: Ranked areas from 1-7 using criteria on the quality/quantity of accessibility through public services etc

Pros:
- Broad range of criteria
- Allowed us to see **potential for change
- Quantitative

Cons:
- Subjective
- Hard to correlate num

Question 11

Questionnaire of perceptions (Place check in Derry)

Answer 11

Questionnaire: surveyed locals of different ages randomly in our transects to gain their opinions on Dery

Pros:
- Gained a wide range of opinions from different demographics
- Understood perceptions of a place and desirability
- easy to represent in a word cloud

Cons:
- May over/ under represent certain demographics’ views
- subjective
- Misses out some demographics