EXSC 480 Exam 3 Flashcards
How does thermodynamics relate to weight maintenance?
reducing thermodynaic efficiency results in increased weight loss
a calorie isn’t always a calorie (2nd law)
you have to decrease consumption or increase expenditure (1st law)
What are some factors that influece weight loss?
satiety age behaviors body composition food supply diet economics medications genes gut microbiota hormones metabolic rate
Energy density
differences due to fat, water, and fiber content
macronutrients can also hvae differeing effects on satitaion/satiety
Which macronutrient has the greatest effect of satiety?
Protein
Very low calorie diets
Less than 800 kcal
hard to maintain for longer than 6 months
can negatively bone health, possible eating disorders
Results of VLCD
10-40% of weight loss
1.5-2.5 kg lost per week
Low-calorie diets
800-1500 kcals
or can be classified as decreasing 500-750 kcal in obese and 300-500 in overweight
LCD results
improve cholesterol, LDL, triglycerides, HDL
8% body weight loss
can be used after a VLCD
Low fat diet
less than 30% of total kcal comes from fat
weight loss of about 5.41 kg
Very low fat diet
15% from fat
Low fat diet results
4 months to a year 6% to 12% body weight loss
improvement in total cholesterol, LDL. Variable effects on HDL and triglycerides
Fat diets and weight loss
fat energy is dense but has weak satiating effect
low fat diet may induce greater weight loss
helps to reduce total energy intake
heart-healthy approach
Low-fat to low-carb diets
difference is not significant
Low-carb diets
there isn’t a set definition
can range from 10-20% of kcals from carbs
Very low carb diet
less than 10% total kcal from carbs
Why does a low carb diet work?
Increased thermogenic effects of protein intake
Greater protein turnover for gluconeogenesis
Loss of energy through excretion of ketones
Increased satiety, allowing lower energy intake w/out hunger
Specific metabolic advantage
Low carb drawbacks
greater change at 6 months than low fat
but same results at a year (33% vs 34%)
only 59% were able to do a whole year
Two year low carb
HDL cholesterol higher than low calorie diet
but more adverse symptoms than other low diets
Negatives of low carb diet
less fat loss even with more weight loss
lots of adverse side effects
Positives of low carb diet
8-12 kg at 6 months
5 kg at a year
increased energy expenditure
decreased triglycerides, increased HDL
Carb Insulin Model
increased insulin levels and high carb levels don’t lead to oxidation but to fat storage
this causes increased hunger and food cravings, lower energy expendture, weight gain.
Atkins, Zone, Weight Watchers
all achieve modest and similar long-term weight loss
all low carb
Intermittent Fasting
Insulin levels drop w/out snacking
because of low insulin levels, fat cells release energy and are burned
Fasting protocols
fasting every other day
7 AM to 3 PM or 7 Am to 7 PM eating pattern
Mediterranean Diet
eat rarely red meat
eat in moderation poultry, eggs, cheese, yogurt
Mediterranean vs low fat
more effective
at 6 years, MD had lost 3.1 kg vs .06 kg
Glycemic index diet
limit refined grains and sweets
3 meals a day and 1-2 snacks..
Eat slowly and stop when full
Who should do a glycemic index diet?
those with high insulin secretion
beneficial for HDL and not LDL
Problems w/gluten free
expensive
processed foods
fewer nutrients
doesn’t induce weight loss
Low sugar
decrease in .8 kg
doesn’t necessarily help you to lose weight because you intake other carbs
Dieting problems
preoccupation w/food food is the enemy slowed metabolism weight rebound dissatisfaction w/body
Intuitive eating attitudes
body acceptance
dieting is harmful
Intuitive eating behaviors
learn to not eat for emtional, environmental or social reasons
learn to interpret body singals and respond in a positive way
Intuitive eating principles
Reject diet mentality honor your hunger make peace with food challenge food police discover satisfaction feel your fullness cope w/emotions with kindess respect your body love exercise honor you health
Efficacy of intuitive eating
lower BMI more evident w/time less weight cycling improves mental health and mindfulness increases internal cues to eat
Drawbacks of intuitive eating
little evidence for weight reduction
not related to increased PA
influence on healthy diet is mixed
PA for maintaining or improving health
150 min/week
PA for prevention of weight gain
150-250 min/week
PA for clinically significant weight loss
225 to 420 min/week
PA for preventing weight gain after weight loss
200 to 300 min/week
Heterogeneity of weight loss/exercise in research studies
PA is defined and recorded differently
weight loss or benefits of PA can differ from study to study
Clinical trials w/no or modest weight loss still have benefits
glucose control endothelial function lipoportein particle size HDL quality of life CVD risk