Exam #1: Understanding Clinical Literature Flashcards
Outline the standard structure of a research paper.
- Abstract
- Introduction
- Methods
- Results
- Discussion
*IMRAD mnemonic– leaves out abstract
What are the preliminary questions that you should ask when reading a research paper?
1) Why was the study done?
2) What is the hypothesis?
3) What type of study was done?
4) Was the study design appropriate?
What are the two broad categories of studies?
Primary i.e.
- Experiments
- Observations
- Clinical trials
- Surveys
Secondary
- Reviews
- Economic analyses
- Decision analyses
What is the difference between a systematic review and a non-systematic review?
Non-systematic= something is guaranteed to be left out
What are the traditional study designs?
- RCT
- Cohort studies
- Case-control studies
- Cross-sectional surveys
- Case reports
What is the purpose of systematic reviews and meta-analyses?
To evaluate groups of studies
What is the best study design for a therapy/ intervention question?
RCT
What is the best study design for a harm/risk/etiology question?
RCT
What is the best study design to assess harmful outcomes?
Cohort-study OR
Case-control
*****Note that it is NOT ethical to assess harmful outcomes with RCTs
What is the best study design for a diagnosis question?
Diagnostic validation study
*****This is an independent, blinded comparison with the “gold” –also called reference– standard.
What is the best study design for a prognosis question?
Cohort study
Describe the methodology of a RCT.
- Participant randomly assigned to one intervention group or another
- Both analyzed for a specific defined outcome
- Randomization should produce demographically similar groups
What type of bias does randomization decrease? What is the caveat to this?
- Randomization reduces “selection bias”
*****Requires “concealed allocation” i.e. a third party assigns groups
What is the difference between concealed allocation and blinding?
Blinding= keeping participants unaware of their group assignment
What is the difference between single and double blinding?
Single= only subjects blinded
Double= patients and investigators blinded