Ethnicity Flashcards
what aspects of pupils does the Government record
- ethnicity, gender, location they live in
what does the Millennium Cohort Study say about south Asians and black Caribbeans and biological children
- 86% of South Asian children live with both biological parents compared to 30% of Black Caribbean children
what is the critical race theory
- the idea that racism in society is inherent and ingrained - esp in the legal and social institutions
what 2 groups are the most expensive for schools to take on
- the working class and special educational - thus they’re less likely for schools to market and cater towards
what is the funding formula
- the funding given to schools per student. is why schools want as many pupils as possible
what does Roithmayer say about the critical race theory
- roithmayer: institutional racism is a locked in inequality so large and historical that its no longer a conscious thought
what does Gillborn say about the critical race theory
- Gillborn: sees racism as so ingrained in education that its now inevitable
what does Gillborn say about marketisation
- Gillborn: marketisation allows for more covert selection to occur, which can lead to segregation + discrimination of different social groups
what did the Commission for Racial Equality 1993 say
- covert selection procedures led to ethnic minority students more likely to be in unpopular / worse schools
define ethnocentric curriculum
- ethnocentric curriculum = a curriculum in which it reflects the culture of one ethnic group - usually the dominant culture
what does Gillborn say about the education system
- Gillborn: the education system is biased to validate the dominant (European) culture
what does Sanders + Horn say about assessment
- Sanders + Horn: the change from written tests to teacher assessments led to black pupil underachievement - could be due to teacher bias
outline 2 key facts about access to opportunities
- in Gifted and Talented programmes, White people are 2x more likely to be identified as G&Ts than EMs
- Ethnic Minorities are less likely to be entered for higher tiered exams due to teacher labelling and SFP
outline ‘new IQism’ + Gillborn’s view
- teachers + policy makers make false assumptions about pupils ability or potential
- potential is seen as fixed and is measured through old style IQ tests - in which Gillborn argues that these tests only examine current ability - not what could be
outline the idea of labels and what Gillborn + Youdell, Bourne say
- Gillborn + Youdell: teachers are quicker to negatively label Black pupils due to teachers’ ‘racialised expectation’
- Gillborn + Youdell: black pupils are more likely to be in bottom sets and treated like ‘hopeless cases’ due to the A-C economy
- Bourne: neg labels often impact black students in terms of higher levels of exclusions. 1 in 5 students who are excluded achieve 5 GCSEs
what does Gillborn and Youdell say about black students upon entry
- on entry (age 4), African Carribean students were the highest achievers, however at GCSE level, they were one of the lowest achieveing groups
- this shows that their underachievement is due to internal factors (SFP, institutional racism, streaming, pupil subcultures etc)
what does lack of ethnic representation lead to
- lack of positive role models for BAME students, and so they may seek representation in worse places, E.g. MTV image for young black boys without a father
- bias from white teachers can happen - labelling, racism, discrimination etc
outline an ideal pupil identity by Archer
- white, middle class, passive, masculine identity (dominant, confident - doesnt have to be boy), normal sexuality, achieving through natrual talent + ability (those that quickly ‘get’ concepts)
outline an pathologized pupil identity by Archer
- deserving poor, feminised identity, asexual / repressed sexuality, plodding conformist, succeeding through hard work rather than natural ability
outline an demonised pupil identity by Archer + its affects
- black or white, working class, hypersexualised, unintelligent, peer led, culturally deprived, underachiever
- more likely to be excluded, be in an anti-school subculture, in lower streams
what does Fuller say about pupil responses and subcultures
- she studied a group of black girls in year 11 in a London comprehensive school. they were untypical as they achieved highly in a school where black girls underachieved / were put in low streams
- shows that pupils can still succeed if they refuse to conform to their labels. negative labels dont always lead to failure
- these black girls channelled their anger of being labelled into educational success instead of accepting their stereotypical label
- they didnt seek teacher approval, or limit their friends if they didnt achieve highly
what does Mac an Ghaill say about pupil responses and subcultures
- he studied Black and Asian a level students who rejected their negative labels depending on their gender, ethnicity and nature of former schools
- E.g. some girls who formerly went to an all girls school found that it gave them greater academic commitment, allowing them to overcome neg labels at college
- a label doesnt inevitably produce a SFP
what does Mirza say about pupil responses and subcultures
- she studied ambitious Black girls who faced teacher racism. found that the racist teachers discouraged their ambition
- there are 3 types of teachers; colour blind, liberal chauvinists, overt racists
- racist teachers could discourage BAME students from persuing professional careers, subject options, encourage them to do more vocational
define Mirzas 3 teacher labels
- colour blind = teachers who believe all pupils are equal - but in doing so, ignores the discrimination that could require BAME students to need extra help - allowing racism to occur
- liberal chauvinists = teacher who believe black students culturally deprived and have low expectations for them
- overt racists = teachers who think black pupils are inferior and actively discriminate
what does Sewell say about black boys
- he focuses on street culture + absence of fathers + influence of peers to explain underachievement in black boys
- labels black boys as falling into either rebel, conformists, retreatists, and innovators of black culture and education