education and ETHNICITY Flashcards
what are the external factors of varying school success for different ethnicities? (external/internal)
(+ PRYCE)
- cultural deprivation - schools British habitus
- linguistic skills
- attitudes and values
- family structure - black Caribbean high percentage of single parents - a less cohesive culture due to the devastating effects of colonialism (PRYCE)
- Asian families - strong family networks - strong culture
- most sociologists argue failure is down to racism in schools and ethnocentric curriculum
what is the stereotypical family structure/parental support like for Black Caribbean families? (external)
(MOYNIHAN & SEWELL)
- MOYHIHAN - cultural deprivation/inadequate socialisation of children - similar to WC children in general
- lone mothers - financial problems
- lack of male role models for boys (SEWELL)
what are the stereotypical Asian family attitudes? (external)
(PRYCE)
- PRYCE - Asian families have strong family networks/strong culture/close-knit extended families
- high aspirations for their children
- promote positive attitudes towards education/adult authority/respectful behaviour
SEWELL: fathers, gangs and culture (external)
- argues the absence of ‘tough love’ Black boys find it hard to overcome emotional and behavioural difficulties
- in this absence the boys join gangs who offer ‘perverse loyalty and love’ - media inspired role model of anti-school black masculinity (ultra tough, rap, MTV)
- anti-educational peer group pressure: speaking in standard english and doing well in school seen as ‘selling out to the white establishment’
- do different to asian children due to culture differences
what is a criticism of SEWELL: fathers, gangs & culture? (internal)
he downplays the impact of racism such as institutional/educational racism
material deprivation (external)
PALMER (housing)
- ethnic minorities more likely to live in poverty / overcrowded places
- more likely to be unemployed / in low paid employment / home working
- more likely to be homeless
- live in deprived areas
- foreign qualifications not recognised in the uk
- asylum seekers may not be allowed to work
- racial discrimination found in jobs and housing
what do many sociologists blame for educational differences? (external)
racism in wider society and external factors
FSM and ethnicity (internal)
- chinese girls who receive FSM achieve better GCSE results than white girls who don’t get FSM
- so, material deprivation/social class factors don’t completely override the influence of ethnicity
internal factors of ethnic differences (internal)
(black caribbean boys)
- labelling / pupil responses
- many black caribbean boys start their education off as high achievers but don’t achieve their potential
- many fall behind before they leave primary school
black caribbean boys (internal)
GILLBORN & YOUDELL
- GILLBORN & YOUDELL
- teachers use racialised expectations based on negative stereotypes
- teachers expected problems from black boys
- negative labels from teachers
- educational triage - more likely to be placed in lower sets
- received harsh discipline from teachers
- have a high percentage in pupil referral units
asian pupils in primary school (internal)
CECILE WRIGHT
- teachers left asian children out of class discussions as they assumed they had a poor grasp of english
- failed to pronounce their names correctly
- teachers failed to respect their customs and traditions
- saw them as a problem they could ignore
- these pupils were marginalised
institutional racism (internal)
- discrimination built into the way schools operate
- national curriculum focuses to much on british culture
- few opportunities to learn asian languages
- low priority given to racial issues
- school governors tend to be white, middle class and middle aged
- schools not respecting cultural needs
what are the three pupil identities described by ARCHER ? (internal)
- teachers often define pupils using stereotypical ethnic identities
- ideal pupil identity
- pathologized pupil identity
- demonised pupil identity
what is the ideal pupil identity (internal)
ARCHER
white, middle class, masculinised identity, normal sexuality, achieve the right way through natural ability/initiative
masculine - confident, self assured
feminine - quiet, polite
what is the pathologized pupil identity? (internal)
ARHCER
asian, feminised identity, asexual, oppressed sexuality, conformist culture bound over-achiever, plodder, succeed through hard work not natural ability