documents Flashcards
studies
Ofsted reports
Anne Frank - The Diary
the black report 1980
public documents
documents produced by public organisations (government, school)
The Black report 1980 - comprehensive examination of class and the health in the uk
personal documents
documents created by private individuals (letters, diaries)
historical
documents (both public and private) created in the past
practical advantage of documents
cost - normally free and widely available
personal characteristics - you don’t normally need to have specific skills or personal traits
time - often can be done quite quickly if documents easily available
historical analysis - often the only way to study historical events
theoretical strength of documents
validity - often provides very in-depth data. Letters and diaries reveal how people feel about and interpret their lives
practical limitations of documents
time - can take a long time to analyse and collect - particularly historical documents
access - some official documents are kept hidden through the official secrets act
ethical limitation of documents
consent/privacy - if using private documents you need to ensure informed consent and maintain privacy and confidentiality where required
theoretical limitation of documents
subjective - not everyone may interpret documents the same way
representativeness - private documents may not be representative of the wider population
validity - not all private documents may be accurate and may be deliberately false
what is content analysis
a process of which qualitative data is turned into quantitative data
thematic content analysis is used to uncover themes within qualitative data - it follows a similar process but the categories are more subjective and it is harder to replicate
practical strengths of content analysis
cost - it is normally a very cheap process
source material - normally very easy to get relevant source material
theoretical strengths of content analysis
positivism - a good way to do quantitative data, objective analysis of qualitative source material
practical limitations of content analysis
time - may take a while to generate a large amount of data
theoretical limitations of content analysis
validity - interpretivists argue that counting how many times something appears doesn’t help understand the meanings behind it - therefore it has a low validity
reliability - different sociologists may categorise the same data in different ways - this is particularly an issue with thematic content analysis
positivist views on documents
do not generally use documents as they are prone to subjectivity when being analysed
if positivists do study documents, they are more likely to employ content analysis to quantify the data