Decision Making Flashcards
Are groups better at making decisions?
- Generally speaking yes, but better than individuals
- You learn more in groups, and remember things more
- Groups perceptions of others is more accurate
How does groups make decisions?-
- No one reach a decision the exact way as other groups but there is a general process
- O-D-D-I
- Usually happen in this order but some phases can happen simultaneously or in different order
- Following these steps makes it more likely to make better decisions
Orientation Phase
- A problem that needs a solution
- Planning the work
- Goal Clarification
Specify goals, what challenges might we face, who will we evaluate the work, whats the requirement to pass - Goal - Path Clarification
How will we do the work, tasks and subtasks, how will we make decisions, organizing roles and explicit norm, milestones and deadlines - Shared understanding on everything that needs to be done?
- Takes time but is more efficient long-term, better decisions etc
What are the problems with orientation phase?
- Planning fallacy
- Relying on previous experiences,
- Wanna get started right away
- Associate planning with something bad, or planning is boring
Discussion Phase
- Communication of information between two or more people in a group
- Expressing views, opinions, different perspectives
- Gathering information and processing it more thoroughly together with others, asking questions, alternative options
- Discussing improve the groups memory
- Increases the quality of the groups decisions with information related to the task
- Easier to identify errors and mistakes, time consuming
Information processing model
Assumes that people strive to make good decisions by getting the info needed and going through it thoroughly
Collective memory
A groups combined memories, alot of networks
- A group remember more things, and can specialize in different areas
Transactive memory system
Storing and retrieving information
- Team experience and trust
Cross- cuing
- The enhancement of recall that occurs during discussions
- Serving as cues to remember more things
What are the difficulties of discussions?
- Requires motivation, skill and practice
- Assume their skill is enough to discuss things
- Relies on previous experiences
- Groups are forgetful, especially without discussions
- Same biases apply to groups as individuals, but amplified in groups
(conformation bias, selective information gathering, social loafing) - Group members misunderstand each other
- Problems during meetings
Poor planning, lack of communication skills, egocentric behaviour etc
Decision Phase
- You reached a decision, go to implementation
- If not, go back a few stands
Social decision scheme
Combining individual input into one decisions and group members accept it
- Explicit or implicit processes
Averaging Scheme
- Statistics
- Computer draws the average of everyone´s input, accurate
- No discussion, no benefits from that
- Can be skewed
- Lack of responsibility
Reaching consensus
- Unanimous decision, happens different ways
- High levels of commitment and task satisfaction
- Takes time, can lead to misfire
- Sensitive questions
- Long term positive effects on effects
- Holding back information
Voting Scheme
- Majority wins, doesnt mean its always right
- Publicly or in secret
- Internal conflicts, not everyone can be satisfied
- Group pressure
Delegation Scheme
- Sharing decisions
- One takes the decision and delegate the work to others
- Outside expertise
- Avoid responsibilities and blame others