DCT - Knowledge of God's Existence Flashcards
Define sensus divinitatis
a sense of God, a phrase used by Calvin to talk about an innate sense in each of us of the existence of God
How might christians say they know God exists?
.Creation .Bible scripture .Miracles .The person of Jesus the incarnation .Numinous .Sense of the divine .Conversion .The world cannot be an accident
What is numinous?
a sense of a presence of something greater
What does Romans 1:18-21 show/mean?
.Creation of the world proves God exists
.The knowledge we have about God is God given
Romans 1:20
For since the creation of the world Gods invisible qualities - his eternal power and divine nture - have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that people are without excuse
What do Christians believe is possible about the sense of the divine?
.Christians believe it is possible to know God through what is around us – this is what is known as natural theology
What does natural theology tell us?
.Natural theology tells us about God throughout his creation, and in using our reason and experience we can understand God’s nature and God’s experience
What does natural theology give us access to?
a point of contact between God and humanity in the natural world – although we may not fully know the nature of God we can have access
What did Calvin teach about this topic?
.As well as the sensus divinitatis, he also taught there was the semen religionis (seed of religion) within all
What does semen religionis mean for humanity?
.If people are unware of these things, it was because they are confused by sin and so cannot recognise God
Calvin quote for semen religionis
‘God himself has implanted in all men a certain understanding of his divine majesty’
Explain calvins quote for semen religionis
God has given us knowledge of God, innate and from the beginning
CCC 27
‘The desire for God is written on the human heart … only in God will he find the truth and happiness he never stops searching for’
Define conscience
the inner feeling of right and wrong
What does the catholic church teach about conscience?
The Catholic Church teaches that this is made up of two parts:
- The ability to know right and wrong
- The ability to act on what is right and wrong
How does beauty help us understand God more clearly?
.The appreciation of aesthetics and beauty helps people understand God’s existence more clearly
.When we see beautiful things or hear beautiful sounds we can use our reason to understand that this is God working in the world
.Our ability to do this is something that is God-given and innate
Aquinas quote on natural law
.’It is evident that all things partake somewhat of the eternal law’
What are Aquinas’s primary precepts of natural law
Natural Law: .Education .Reproduction .Preserving Life .Living in an Ordered Society .Worshipping God
Strengths of using sense of the divine to show natural knowledge of God
Fibonacci Sequence/Golden Ratio present within the natural world – evidence of design? Aids the teleological argument, this beauty suggests intelligent design
Natural theology is accessible to all, supports Gods Omni benevolence
All humans have a conscience – it is what sets us apart from animals
Natural law suggests absolute rules that should be abided by, it is clear what is right and wrong
Focuses on human virtues and excellence
Protects the absolute nature of human rights
Natural law provides a set of rules mainly seen through the western society
Weaknesses of using sense of the divine to show natural knowledge of God
Religious experiences often contradict each other
Not everyone upholds the natural law, atheists or people who don’t want kids
The idea of conscience is subjective, a lot comes down to cultural upbringing
Crime suggests not everyone wants to live in an orderly society
Too subjective – beauty is based on perspective and culture
Natural law enforces traditional values that are out of date in today’s society
There are no fixed ideals on what society should be like
Conscience can be wrong, often serial killers will claim they have been told to do it
Dawkins would argue that creation is a mere coincidence. The reason we see beauty in nature is a result of evolution
Define teleological
The argument for the existence of God from the evidence of order and hence design in nature
What psalm can be used to argue for the existence of God through the order of creation?
Psalm 139: 13-18
What is john calvins ‘principle of accommodation’?
that despite God being unknowable, he has communicated in ways that humans can understand through use of their reason
What is william paleys watchmaker analogy essentially?
.If something is complex, like a watch, it must have a designer
.There are much more complex natural things in the world than a watch
.If a watch must be designed so must the complex things in the world
.People call this designer God as only God could have the power to design and create the world
Dawkins quote for intelligent design
‘I have no explanation for complex biological design. All I know is that God isn’t a good explanation, so we must wait and hope that somebody comes up with a better one.’
Criticism of the teleological argument, Darwin
.Design is the result of a long process of natural selection
.The world is as it is due to pure chance, nothing else
.Some might argue that God started evolution, or micromanages it
.Darwin refuted this, as he argued that if God micromanaged then he would be responsible for all the bad parts of nature – like digger wasps
Criticism of the teleological argument, Hume
.Don’t know for a fact that all order comes about because of design
.Self-sustaining order could have come about by chance, this is close to Darwinism
.We have nothing to compare our world to – it might have very little order
.Any world might look designed, because if it were not then it would not be able to survive
.We cannot prove God is the cause of this design, so we do not know
Criticism of the teleological argument, Dawkins
.Backed up Darwin
.Has no time for religious faith at all
.As science gets better there’s less and less need to resort to God
.Dawkins argues that the discovery of DNA provides an explanation for the existence of humanity, there is no need to assume the existence of God to account for human life
Christian response to criticism of the teleological argument, J.H. Newman
.Evolution is ‘suggesting a larger idea of divine providence or skill’
.There is no fault in logic to say that an intelligent designer created evolution
Christian response to criticism of the teleological argument, Charles Kingsley
.Shared Newman’s ideas
.’Of old God was so wise that he could make all things; behold he is so much wiser … he can make all things make themselves’.
.When modern teleological arguments for design qua regularity are taken into account, it can be seen that the sheer complexity and detailed process of evolution hints strongly at something designed rather than accidental
Christian response to criticism of the teleological argument, Alister McGrath
.Paley’s view is not typical of the modern day Christian
.Dawkins is criticising a 200 year old approach, if we criticised 200 year old science we would be able to find fault too
Difference between natural and revealed theology
.Revealed theology looks at things the other way round to natural theology
.Natural theology starts with human responses to what can be seen around them (beauty in nature etc)
.Revealed theology looks at what God has deliberately shown people
What two ways can revealed theology be understood?
both directly (when God reveal himself directly to people such as a religious experience) or indirectly (when God reveals himself through a source such as the bible)
What are some obstacles to knowing God
.Upbringing (having parents who are too religious and put you off or having parents who are completely atheist and you follow suite) .Education .Geography .Culture .Science .Life choices .Problem of Evil .Pride .Ignorance .Disability .Mental illness .Addiction
Catholic perspective on why natural theology is not sufficient
.As a result of the fall, humanity cannot rely on their reason/intellect completely because it has been corrupted
.Catholics see faith as being something that works alongside reason. True faith is something that comes through a process of formation, which allows a person to let go of reason alone
.Aquinas reflected on the idea of faith and concluded that it was the conscious choice to accept something that is not certain
.Faith and reason must work together in order for someone to discover knowledge of God
John Calvin’s perspective on why natural theology is not sufficient
.For Calvin, Christian faith comes from accepting Christ as the redeemer of the world, which is something that is done on a spiritual level, not a rational one
.Christians believe that grace is something that is received from God and is the ‘undeserved favour’
.Christians believe that because of God’s grace they are given faith, and as a result of this they can develop a personal relationship with God
.Calvin said that the holy spirit helps humans in their lives by giving them faith
In the catholic church, what do they teach opens up a person to faith and Gods grace
the Holy Spirit gives ‘gifts’ such as wisdom and understanding in order to love out ones vocation, and open a person up to faith and God’s grace
Name the gifts of the holy spirit
Wisdom, knowledge, understanding, fear of the lord, counsel, piety and fotitude
What is wisdom?
To love spiritual things more than material
What is knowledge?
To be able to learn more and more about God
What is understanding?
To comprehend how we need to live as followers of christ
What is fear of the lord?
Otherly known as fear of the lord, to be aware of the glory and majesty of God
WHat is counsel?
Otherly known as right judegment, to know the difference between right and wrong and to choose what is right
What is piety?
Otherly known as reverence, to have a deep sense of respect for God and the church
What is fortitude?
Otherly known as courage, to overcome fear and to be willing to take risks as a follower of Jesus
Calvin quote on grace?
‘The grace of God has no charms for men till the Holy Spirit gives them a taste for it’
Pope St John Paul II quote on Faith and Reason
‘Faith and reason are like two wings on which human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth; and God has placed in the human heart a desire to know the truth - in a word, to know himself - so that, by knowing and loving God, men and women may also come to the fullness of truth about themselves’
According to the catholic church, how are faith and reason linked?
faith and reason work together. They are complementary, not hostile or against each other. They can work hand in hand to work out religious truths.
St Anselm of Canterbury says that we can argue rationally for the existence of God and that a person of moderate intelligence, can be shown that it is rational to believe in God’s existence, what is the quote that goes with this?
‘If anyone does not know that there is a creator who is omnipotent and omniscient I think he could at least convince himself of these things by reason alone, if he is even moderately intelligent’
What does Anselm think of our religious journeys with quote in latin and english
.Anselm thinks of our religious journey as beginning with reason and then continuing to use reason combined with revelation to find further truth.
.He says ‘fides quaerens intellectum’ (‘faith seeking understanding’)
Why do Catholics believe we should not leave our rational faculties behind?
They are Gods gifts after all.
What is Fideism?
.The view that it is wholly faith that allows a person to be a true believer
Why do some Christians believe we can only rely on faith to be a true believer, linking to eden
.Some Christians believe that through the fall in the Garden of Eden, we have somehow become separated from its divine source, which means natural knowledge of God has become impossible, our minds are so ruined that we can no longer see that God exists by the light of natural reason, instead we have to rely wholly on faith to be a true believer
Who is Karl Barth
.A modern theologian who argues that God is so wholly different that it is impossible to know him naturally
What does Barth believe regarding fideism with quote
.He says we have to wholly rely on God to have any knowledge of him at all, stating:
‘the gospel proclaims a God utterly distinct from men’ (Church Dogmatics)
Why does Barth reject natural theology but accept revealed theology?
.One of the reasons Barth rejected natural theology was that he believed it would lead to human reasoning being the centre and not God
.Barth did not see the power of human reasoning, especially during the build up to the first world war in which many of Barth’s teachers signed a document backing up the German war plan
.If God is so utterly different from mankind, then it is impossible for us to know God through our own unaided powers of reason
.Gods revelation through Jesus Christ as mediated in the Bible must be our focus
What did Calvin suggest?
He suggested the doctrine of total depravity
Calvin says that everything which comes from the natural, fallen human mind is …
‘foolish, frivolous, perverse, and insane’
Accoridng to Calvin how can we have a mind which is made whole again?
Through total renewal
What does Calvin believe about God’s grace?
No part of us escapes the need for it
Reason is not stable, what is it
culturally relative