Criminal Courts And Lay People Flashcards
Summary offence
Minor crimes such as careless driving
Can only be tried at the magistrates court
Indictable offence
Serious crimes such as murder
Can only be tried at the crown court
Either way offence
Middle range offences which can vary in the degree of harm caused such as theft
May be tried at either court
Role of lay magistrates: magistrates try all summary offences and decide…
If D is guilty or not guilty, after hearing the evidence and applying the relevant law
Role of lay magistrates: they decide what the…
Sentence should be where D pleads guilty or is found guilty
What is the maximum sentence for a single criminal offence committed by an adult
6 months imprisonment (12 months for two) and/or an unlimited fine
Role of lay magistrates: they deal with…
The first hearing of all indictable offences then transfer those cases to the crown court
Role of lay magistrates: they can issue…
An arrest warrant and/or issue a search warrant to the police
Role of lay magistrates: they can extend the…
Period of detention of a suspect at a police station
Role of lay magistrates: they decide whether D should be granted…
Bail or remanded in custody between court appearances
Role of lay magistrates: specially trained magistrates sit in…
The youth court to hear criminal charges against those aged 10-17 years old
Role of lay magistrates: sit in crown court with a judge where…
A case is on appeal from the magistrates court against conviction and/or sentence
Role of lay magistrates: deal with the procedure of either way offences…
Either way offences can be tried either before magistrates in magistrates court or before judge and jury in crown courts. Under the plea before venue and allocation procedure D is asked whether s/he pleads guilty or not guilty to the offence
What happens if D pleads guilty under plea before venue and allocation?
The magistrates must decide whether their sentencing powers are sufficient to sentence D or if the case should be committed to the crown court for sentence1`
what happens if D pleads not guilty under the plea before venue and allocation
magistrates must work out the most appropriate court to allocate the case for trial- hear arguments from prosecution and defence with any relevant previous convictions
should be tried in MC unless its likely that sentencing powers will be insufficient
if case isn’t suitable for trial by MC they’ll commit it to CC
if magistrates are prepared to hear case- d given a choice of trial court- likely sentence indication given to help decide
if the trial for an either way offence is in MC what will happen
adjournment and a decision on bail will be made
on day of trial 3 magistrates will hear evidence and decide on guilt or innocence- must be unanimous/by majority
sentence up to max sentencing powers or commit case to CC for sentence
what age must candidates be to become a magistrate
16-65 on appointment
how many times must magistrates commit to sitting in court per year
26 minimum
6 key qualities that magistrates should have
- good character
- understanding and communication
- social awareness
- maturity and sound temperament
- sound judgement
- commitment and reliability
which types of people are excluded from becoming magistrates
- anyone whos work is considered incompatible with duties of magistrate eg police
- serious criminal convictions
- undischarged bankrupts
first stage in the selection of magistrates
local advisory commitees advertise for individuals in local community to put themselves forward
aim to create bench that’s representative of all aspects of society
second stage in selection of magistrates
two interviews by local advisory committees
first: assess attitudes and key qualities of candidate
second: pratcial with sentencing exercises
third stage in selection of magistrates
following interview process, local advisory committee will recommend suitable people to lord chief justice or their delegate
fourth stage in appointment of magistrates
lord chief justice or delegate will appoint from lost of recommended candidates sent by local advisory committees
aim to have balance of gender, ethnicity and occupations
fifth stage in appointment of magistrates
background checks are carried out prior to formal appointment
sixth stage in appointment of magistrates
oath of allegiance must be sworn at swearing in ceremony
problems with make up of magistrates bench today
still a feeling that magistrates are ‘middle class, middle aged and middle minded’ despite efforts
vast majority of them come from professional/managerial backgrounds
few young magistrates- most middle aged or older
‘middle minded’- mostly conservative supporters
less representative of society ITO ethnicity- 8.7% compared to 14% population
gender balanced- 52% female- much higher than in professional judiciary
who is much of magistrates training delivered by
magistrates clerks
which initiative is used to train magistrates
magistrates new training initiative MNTI 2
initial training
before sitting in court a new magistrate will undergo introductory training on the basics of the role. after this she/he will sit in court with 2 other experienced magistrates