Corporate Insolvency Procedures Flashcards
What were the aims of the corporate insolvency reforms in the Enterprise Act 2002?
- promote the rescue culture
- to remove the stigma associated with insolvency and therefore encourage an entrepreneurial culture
- give prominence to collective insolvency procedures (which are conducted for the benefit of creditors as a whole) over enforcement procedures (which generally only benefit a creditor holding security over the company’s assets)
When will a company be insolvent?
- it is unable to pay its debts as they fall due (the cash flow test)
- has liabilities that are greater than its assets (the balance sheet test)
- does not comply with a statutory demand for a debt over £750 - this provides evidence that the company is cash flow insolvent
- fails to pay a creditor to satisfy enforcement of a judgment debt
What must directors do when a company is in financial difficulty?
They must continually review the financial performance of a company and recognise when it is facing financial difficulties
They must decide what course of action to take
What options do directors have when a company is in financial difficulties?
- do nothing - (risks personal liability and breaching directors’ duties)
- do a deal - reach an informal or formal arrangement with some or all of the company’s creditors with a view to rescheduling its debts so that the company has less to pay and/or more time to pay
- appoint an administrator - this is a collective formal insolvency procedure which considers the interests of all creditors
- request the appointment of a receiver
- put the company into liquidation
What is the difficulty with entering an informal agreement with creditors?
Not all creditors may want to be bound or agree to such an agreement
What may the company have to do to gain creditor approval of an informal agreement?
- grant new or additional security
- replace directors or senior employees
- sell failing businesses/subsidiaries or profitable ones to raise cash
- reduce costs eg through a redundancy programme or the closure of unprofitable businesses and/or
- issue new shares to the creditors
What is a Standstill Agreement?
Creditors agree not to enforce their rights or remedies for a specified time period to give the company and the creditors some time in which to negotiate a contractual arrangement to resolve the company’s financial problems
What is the effect of pre-insolvency moratorium?
The company enters a period whereby creditors are unable to take action to exercise their usual rights and remedies, thereby creating breathing space for the company to resolve the situation
- no creditor can enforce its security against the company’s assets
- there is a stay of legal proceedings against the company and a bar on bringing new proceedings against it
- no winding up procedures can be commenced in respect of the company (unless commenced by the directors) and no shareholder resolution can be passed to wind up the company unless approved by the directors
- no administration procedure can be commenced in respect of the company (other than by directors)
What is the procedure for obtaining a pre-insolvency moratorium?
Company files at court:
- a statement that the company is or is likely to become unable to pay its debts as they fall due
- statement from a licensed insolvency practitioner, known as a Monitor for these purposes, stating that in their view, it is likely that a moratorium will result in the rescue of the company as a going concern. The monitor has a supervisory function during the pre-insolvency moratorium
Can a company enter a pre-insolvency moratorium if they are in a formal insolvency?
No - can only enter one if they are not in a formal insolvency
How long does a pre-insolvency moratorium last for?
20 business days but can be extended by the directors for a further 20 business days
Further extensions are possible with the consent of a requisite majority of creditors and/or court order up to maximum period of one year.
Court order is required to extend period beyond a year
What will happen to the moratorium if a company enters liquidation or administration or at the point that a CVA is approved or court sanctions a restructuring plan or a scheme of arrangement?
The moratorium will automatically end
What pre-moratorium debts do a company have to still pay during the moratorium period?
- the monitor’s remuneration or expenses
- goods and services supplied during the moratorium
- rent in respect of a period during the moratorium
- wages or salary or redundancy payments
- loans under a contract involving financial services ie company remains liable for all sums due to a bank which made a loan to it before it obtained the moratorium
What pre-moratorium debts does a company not have to pay during a moratorium period?
Debts which have fallen due before or during the moratorium by reason of an obligation incurred before the moratorium aside from exempt debts
Must a company pay debts that fall due during or after the moratorium by reason of an obligation incurred during the moratorium?
Yes - company must be capable of paying its way through the moratorium period
Effect of this being that a company must be ‘cash flow’ solvent ie able to pay its debts as and when they fall due
What are the two types of formal arrangements a company can enter into with its creditors?
- a company voluntary arrangement (CVA)
- a restructuring plan
What is the main advantage of a formal arrangement?
Provided the requisite majorities of creditors vote in favour of it, it is legally binding on all creditors even if some of those creditors voted in against it or did not vote or did not receive notice of the relevant procedure
What is a company voluntary arrangement (CVA)?
Compromise between the company and its creditors
Creditors agree to part payment of debts owed to them and/or to a new extended timetable for repayment
What must happen once a CVA has been approved?
It must be reported to the court - no requirement for the court to approve the CVA though
CVA will be supervised and implemented by a Supervisor who is an insolvency practitioner
What happens to the directors during a CVA?
They remain in office and continue to run the company’s affair subject to the terms of the CVA
What is the process for setting up a CVA?
1) directors draft a CVA proposal and appoint a nominee who must be an insolvency practitioner. If the company is in liquidation or administration, the administrator or liquidator drafts the CVA proposal and acts as Nominee
2) the directors must submit the CVA proposal and a statement of the company’s affairs to the Nominee
3) the nominee considers the CVA proposal and within 28 days must report to the court on whether in their opinion, the company’s creditors and shareholders should be asked to vote on the CVA proposal
4) the nominee must allow at least 14 days for creditors to vote on the CVA proposal. A meeting of the shareholders must take place within 5 days of the creditors’ decision
5) the CVA must be approved by creditors and shareholders
6) the nominee reports to court the the CVA has been approved
7) the nominee usually becomes the Supervisor and the Supervisor will implement the CVA proposal
What voting requirements are there for approving a CVA proposal?
- at least 75% in value (ie value of debts owed) of those voting on the CVA proposal (excluding secured creditors)
- if above majority is obtained, the decision of those creditors will be invalid if those voting against the CVA proposal include more than half of the total value of creditors unconnected to the company (eg not related company, shareholder or director of the company proposing the CVA)
- simple majority of shareholders/members vote in favour
What happens if the creditors vote in favour of a CVA but the shareholders vote against?
Then the creditor’s vote prevails
Is a secured or preferential creditor bound by a CVA?
No - unless they specifically consent to be bound
Can creditors challenge a CVA?
Yes within 28 days of the CVA’s approval by creditors being reported to the court
On what grounds can a creditor challenge a CVA?
On grounds of unfair prejudice ie the CVA treats one creditor unfairly compared to another
OR
On grounds of material irregularity relating to the procedure which the company has followed in seeking approval of the CVA eg dispute over the way in which the creditor’s votes were calculated
What is the role of the supervisor of a CVA?
- agree to creditor’s claims
- collect in the unsecured funds to pay dividends to creditors
- ensure the company complies with its obligations under a CVA
- send a report on completion of CVA to all shareholders and creditors
What is the advantages of a CVA from the company’s perspective?
The directors remain in control of the company
The company can continue to trade during the CVA
The company has the prospect of surviving as a going concern
What is a Restructuring Plan?
Compromise a company’s creditors and shareholders and restructure its liabilities so that a company can return to solvency
When can the plan be used?
A company must have or are likely to encounter financial difficulty
Who needs to approve a Restructuring Plan?
- Court approval called a sanction
- Creditors
- shareholders
How is shareholder/creditor approval gained?
- Shareholders and creditors must be divided into classes and each class which votes on the Plan must be asked to approve it
- plan must be approved by at least 75% in value of those voting in each class
Who will be bound by a Restructuring Plan on it being approved by the court?
All creditors including secured creditors
On what grounds can the court exclude creditors and shareholders from voting even if they are affected by the Plan?
If they have no genuine economic interest in the Company
When can the court sanction a Restructuring Plan which brings about a ‘cross-class cram down’?
When it is just and equitable to do so even if one or more classes do not vote to approve the plan
What is a cross cram down in relation to restructuring plans on creditors?
It means that one rank of creditor can force the Plan on another class of creditor who has voted against the Plan
What is a cross cram down in relation to restructuring plans on shareholders?
Shareholders are forced to accept a debt for equity swap in which creditors are able to hold new shares in the company in place of their debt claims
Who does an administrator owe duties to during administration?
They owe duties to creditors as a whole rather than interests of particular creditor
The owe duties to the court as an officer of the court
Who can be appointed an administrator?
A licensed insolvency practitioner
What are the statutory objectives of administration?
Administrators must perform the objectives in the following order:
1) Rescue to the company as a going concern, or if that is not reasonably achievable
2) achieve a better result for the company’s creditors as a whole than would be likely is the company were wound up
3) realise the company’s property in order to make a distribution to one or more secured or preferential creditors
What are the two different ways an administrator can be appointed?
- court procedure
- out of court procedure
Who can apply to the court for appointing an administrator?
- company
- directors
- creditors
- supervisor of a CVA
- liquidator
When may the court appoint an administrator?
Where the company is likely to become unable to pay its debts
What will the court consider in deciding whether to appoint an administrator or not?
The court must consider whether the appointment is reasonably likely to achieve the purpose of the administration
What will happen on application to the court for appointment of administrator whilst the court considers the application?
There will be an interim moratorium, freezing any creditor action during the period
What effect will the court ordering an administration order have on any pending winding up proceedings?
They will be automatically dismissed
What are the two different methods for appointing an administrator out of court?
- directors of the company may appoint an administrator
- holder of a qualifying floating charge may appoint an administrator out of court