Core Gender Flashcards
Biological sex
rmbr this?
Based on biological facts like genitals and chromosomes. Typically viewed as male or female.
Gender
The cultural meanings and roles associated with masculinity and femininity. Viewed as socially constructed rather than purely biological
Darwinist view of gender
IMPORTANT
Gender roles and traits like competitiveness or nurturing have an evolutionary, biological basis
Typical gender roles are “natural” and rooted in biological differences between sexes
Used to justify gender inequalities like men having more power/opportunities
Feminist view (de Beauvoir)
Gender is a “historical and cultural artifact”, not biologically determined
Critiques focusing only on biology while ignoring the meanings and narratives around gender
“One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman”
How are gender narratives constructed?
Through language and the connotations/associations of words
Through the way we live and societal norms/expectations
Gender narratives can be reclaimed and changed over time
Key disagreement between Darwinists and Feminists
Pre much ur argument x
Darwinists argue biology is deterministic of gender roles/traits
Feminists argue biology is descriptive, not prescriptive - it doesn’t dictate how we should behave
Feminists see gender as socially constructed meanings to be critiqued and changed
Feminist critique of Darwinist view
Focuses too heavily on biological determinism, ignoring social/cultural influences on gender
Assumes gender traits/roles are “natural” based on shaky evolutionary psychology arguments
Risks justifying existing gender inequalities as biologically inevitable
Darwinist critique of feminist view
Dismisses biological factors too quickly by framing gender as purely a social construct
Ignores potential evolutionary roots of psychological differences between sexes
Risks denying any inborn tendencies and treating gender as a blank slate
Feminist response to critique
Acknowledges biology and evolution shape human behavior to some degree
But rejects using biology alone to define or restrict gender roles/expression
Emphasizes societal narratives can evolve beyond perceived biological constraints
some stuff to note
How much weight to give biological factors vs. social/cultural influences in shaping gender
Whether biological tendencies necessarily dictate restrictive gender roles and inequalities