Context of mental health in SA Flashcards
In public health, reliable data on prevalence and risk factors is needed to…
inform interventions and allocation of resources
A critique of the levels of MH data available in SA
Covid 19 saw insane levels of data readily available and updated daily. This is highly contrasted with the data available on MH in SA.
Why might this be? (priorities, difficulty assessing/diagnosing?)
7 sources of MH data
1.National Prevalence studies
2. NGOs
3. Schools
4. Provincial prev studies
5. Community prev studies
6. Clinic studies (look at clinic records, but this is therefore limited to help-seeking populations)
7. Other practitioners and studies
*each data source has benefits and limitations, best to put them together
The SASH study in SA assessed ….. using the ….. which is based on ….. diagnoses
-Common mental disorders
-CIDI (Composite International
Diagnostic Interview)
- DSM-IV
The most key stats discovered by the SASH study (learn some stats for essays etc)
-One lifetime mental illness = 30%
-Anxiety disorders = 16%
-Substance abuse disorders = 13%
-Major depressive disorders = 10%
Problems with the SASH study (3 marks)
- still don’t know prevalence rates of serious disorders
- presumed the western common MDs applicable to SA
- stigmatized natures of MDs in SA may have encouraged soc des bias in survey
The SASH study found that there was a …. treatment gap in SA. This treatment gap was irrespective of…
75%
severity of mental illness or socio-demographic factors
The SASH study found a ….% treatment gap in uninsured adults
92
List 4 of the 6 structural barriers reported by SASH
- lack of proximity to health clinics
- Lack of community-based services after hospital discharge
- Absence of referral pathways after MI is detected
- Inadequate training of primary HC staff of MI detection
- Long waiting lines at clinics
- Costs of accessing treatment
List 4 of the 6 non-structural/Attitudinal barriers
- Perceived ineffectiveness of treatment
- lack of integration between traditional and western approached
- distrust/discomfort with pyschs (linked to race, class, language, culture)
- Lack of knowledge about resources/services
- Stigma of mental illness
- Poor mental health literacy (or diff cultural understandings/interpretations of MIs)
Even if one overcomes the attitudinal/social structures to obtaining MH care, the…. are still there
structural
MI often seen as a…..
“white thing” (receiving help from a white psychologist could also been seen as having to be helped “by the oppressor”)
Name 3 things that defines MHC under the apartheid regime
- Emphasis on INSTITUTIONAL care and MEDICAL treatment for mentally ill
- Protection of society > individual human rights
- Segregation of services, inequitable distribution of resources (black people often used as forced labour and experiment subjects)
These inequalities still persist today
Describe the 2 big shifts in MHC policy that came post apartheid
- move from institutional care to community based care
- Integrate MHC to general health care (though community health care clinics rather than specialized psychiatric hospitals)
*clinics provide support networks closer to community rather than big central hospital
In what way was the 2002 Menth Health Care Act consistent with international human rights standards
- legal protection of mentally ill from abuse, discrimination etc, with review boards to monitor treatment of patients
Though the 2002 MHC act was good in theory, and inline with international standard, give an example of when these guidelines were clearly not followed
the 2016 Life Esidimeni Tragedy
The 2002 MHC Act was poorly implemented due to shortcomings in 4 key areas. What were those 4 key areas?
- Guidelines never distributed to provinces
- Lack of plan to implement the policy
- Lack of staff to monitor implementation
- Low priority to MHC at provincial level
In which policy framework was task-shifting introduced into the South African MHC landscape? And when was this plan to be implemented?
The National Mental Health Policy Framework and Strategic Plan (MHPF) which was to be to implemented between 2013 and 2022