Class, Power And Crime Flashcards
Official statistics from around the world consistently show that which social class is more likely to commit offences?
the working class
Why do Marxists believe that official crime statistics shouldn’t be taken at face value?
because the law is disproportionately enforced on the working class
NAME the 3 main elements of of the traditional Marxist view of crime
1) Criminogenic capitalism
2) The state & law making
3) Ideological functions of crime & law
Which Marxist sociologist discusses Criminogenic capitalism
GORDON 1976
define criminogenic
by its very nature it causes crime
explain the traditional Marxist view of criminogenic capitalism
-crime is inevitable because capitalism is criminogenic. capitalism is based on the exploitation of the working class, which gives rise to crime.
-White collar + corporate crime also occurs
-crime is a rational response to the capitalist system
give 1 reason the exploitation of the working class (capitalism) gives rise to crime
-poverty may mean crime is the only way of survival
-alienation + lack of control over their lives causes frustration / aggression –> violence / vandalism
-theft may be only way to obtain consumer goods
Which Marxist sociologists discusses the state & law making
CHAMBLISS 1976
SNIDER 1993
explain the traditional Marxist view of the state & law making
-law making + enforcement only serve the interests of the ruling class - laws that protect private property are the cornerstone of the capitalist economy.
-ruling class have power to prevent laws that would threaten their interests
Which Marxist sociologists discusses ideological functions of crime & law
PEARCE 1976
JENABI 2014
explain the traditional Marxist view of ideological functions of crime & law
-the law, crime + criminals perform ideological functions for capitalism. Laws are occasionally passed that appear to benefit the working class like health&safety laws, but are really for the ruling class - keeps workers fit for work.
give 2 strengths of the traditional Marxist view of crime
-provides a useful explanation for the relationship between crime + capitalism
-puts labelling theory into a wider structural context
-draws attention to corporate crime and the fact that it is under policed and rarely prosecuted
give 2 weaknesses of the traditional Marxist view of crime
-too deterministic
-ignores relationship between crime and other inequalities
-not all capitalist societies have high levels or crime
-not all prosecutions act in favour of the capitalist state
what do Neo-Marxists call their new theory of crime?
Critical Criminology
name the 3 sociologists that were involved in creating the neo-marxist ‘fully social theory of deviance’
TAYLOR, WALTON AND YOUNG (1973)
identify 2 differences between critical criminology and the traditional Marxist view of crime
-neo Marxists believe crime is more voluntaristic and individuals have free will when committing crimes
-neo Marxists believe crime has a political motive: individuals trying to redistribute wealth to the poor
-neo Marxists see criminals as ‘robin hood’ figures
NAME the 6 factors / considerations that Taylor, Walton and Young identify in their fully social theory of deviance
1) wider origins of the deviant act
2) immediate origins of the deviant act
3) the actual act of deviance
4) immediate origins of social reaction
5) wider origins of social reaction
6) impact of social reaction on future behaviour
How can Taylor, Walton and Young’s Fully social theory of deviance be criticised?
-its idealistic: suggests that crime is motivated by desire to get revenge against inequalities in society
-doesn’t explain why crime is mostly committed against other working class individuals
-overly complicated: 6 factors