Chapter 9 Flashcards
There are no clear-cut rules for setting the stage, except that the experimental setting must seem
plausible to the participants, nor are there any clear-cut rules for translating conceptual variables into specific operations. Exactly how the variable is manipulated depends on the variable and the cost, practicality, and ethics of the procedures being considered.
straightforward manipulations
manipulate variables with instructions and stimulus presentations. Stimuli may be presented verbally, in written form, via videotape, or with a computer.
staged manipulation or event manipulation
Sometimes it is necessary to stage events during the experiment in order to manipulate the independent variable successfully.
Staged manipulations are most frequently used for two reasons.
First, the researcher may be trying to create some psychological state in the participants, such as frustration, anger, or a temporary lowering of self-esteem. Second, a staged manipulation may be necessary to simulate some situation that occurs in the real world.
Staged manipulations frequently employ a
confederate (sometimes termed an “accomplice”).
confederate
A person posing as a participant in an experiment who is actually part of the experiment.
Staged manipulations are designed to involve participants in a situation that becomes a real experience.
True
A staged experiment may be difficult to replicate by other researchers.
True
Presenting participants with one of three versions of a written confession to a crime is an example of an event manipulation.
False
In some staged manipulations, a confederate appears to be another participant in an experiment but is actually part of the manipulation.
True
To study helping behavior, a confederate of the experimenter drops a stack of papers in front of one individual or a group of five people. The amount of time it takes for the confederate to receive help picking up the papers is the dependent variable. The manipulation employed in this experiment would be an example of a straightforward manipulation.
False
The simplest experimental design has two levels of the
independent variable. In planning the experiment, the
researcher has to choose these levels. A general principle to follow is to make the manipulation as strong as possible. A strong manipulation maximizes the differences between the two groups and increases the chances that the independent variable will have a statistically significant effect on the dependent variable.
A strong manipulation is particularly important in the early stages of research, when the researcher is most
interested in demonstrating that a relationship
does, in fact, exist
The principle of using the strongest manipulation possible should be tempered by at least two
considerations.
The first concerns the external validity of a study: The strongest possible manipulation may entail a situation that rarely, if ever, occurs in the real world. A second consideration is ethics: A manipulation should be as strong as possible within the bounds of ethics. A strong manipulation of fear or anxiety, for example, might not be possible because of the potential
physical and psychological harm to participants.
manipulation that uses straightforward presentation of written or verbal material is less costly than
a complex, staged experimental manipulation. Some government and private agencies offer grants for research; because much research is costly, continued public support of these agencies is very important.