Chapter 3 Ethical Consideration - Sheet1 Flashcards
Ethics
is understood as referring to conduct that is considered “morally right” or “morally wrong” as specified by codified and culturally ingrained principles, constraints, rules, and guidelines.
Active Deception
manipulating the truth
Passive Deception
spying on people or omitting pertinent information
The Belmont Report (1970)
Established 3 principles as an ethical foundation of human subjects research (Respect for persons, Non-maleficence, Justice)
The Belmont Report (1970)
Established the use of informed-consent procedures
The Belmont Report (1970)
Established institutional review boards
Five ethical principles
Respect for persons and their autonomy), An obligation not to psychological or physical harm and to strive to do research that is meaningful or potentially beneficial, pursuit and promotion of justice, The establishment of a relationship of trust between researchers and research participants, A fidelity to professional responsibilities, scientific integrity, and accountability
Respect for persons and their autonomy
Maintained using informed consent
Obligation not to psychological or physical harm
All proposed studies carefully evaluated by panel of evaluators
Non-Maleficence
no physical harm
Beneficial
strive to do research that is meaningful or potentially beneficial in advancing knowledge or well-being
Injustice
Occurs when an individual is unreasonably denied a benefit or gain to which he or she is entitled, or when some burden is imposed excessively or undeservedly on individuals, The burden and benefits of the study are intended to be distributed fairly
Trust between researchers and research participants
A traditional way to establish trust is to use confidentiality
Four components of an informed consent agreement
Describes nature of study, any potentional risk to participants, procedure for ensuring confidentiality of the data, & describes voluntary nature of the participants’ cooperation and their freedom to withdraw at any time without prejudice or penalty
Situations in which informed consent is unnecessary or impossible
Archival studies using public records, Risk-free experiements
Informed consent
must be obtained from parents or guardians in the case of children and adolescents
Informed consent
Signing an _____ agreement does not mean the person has relinquished legal rights, such as the right to sue for negligence
Risk-benefit analysis
Do Research, benefit high/risk low, Don’t do research, benefit high/risk low
Diagonal of indecision
Benefit and risk are intermediate; requires more elaboration and possible modification
Risk-benefit analysis
A limitation of this decision-plane model is that it focuses on the risks and benefits of doing research and ignores the societal and scientific risks of not doing research
Debriefing
The process of disclosing to participants more about the full nature of the research in which they participated and, if an active or passive deception was used, why it was believed to be necessary
Four guidelines for debriefing, especially when deception is used
Give whatever explanation necessary to reveal truth about the research and the researcher’s carefully considered decision to employ a deception, Explain that being deceived does not reflect on the participants’ intelligence or character; instead, it shows the effectiveness of the study’s design, Proceed gradually and patiently, with the chief aim of gently unfolding details of any deception that was used, Never use a double deception, that is, a second deception in what the participant thinks is the official debriefing
Ethics in animal research, Three R’s Principle
Reduce the number of animals used, Refine the experiement so there is less suffering, and Replace animals with other procedures whenever possible
Ethical guidelines during the reporting stage of research
Make available the data on which the conclusions are based (while protecting the confidentiality of the participants), Do not imply that a study published in more than one journal represents different studies, and always give credit where due