Chapter 2 - Contract formation Flashcards
Three essential elements of contract
agreement, intention to create legal relations, consideration
Void / Voidable - lack of capacity
Individual must be of sound mind and aged 18 or over
If not followed - voidable at option of person without capacity
Void/Voidable = absence of free will
a party should not be made to enter into a contract other than by their own free will (not duress, undue influence)
Voidable
void/voidable = illegality
contract should not be illegal or offend public policy
Void
Void/Voidable
Mistake
If one or both parties allies they were mistaken, may affect validity, but complex
Void/Voidable
Misrepresentation
If A makes pre-contractual statement of fact that is intended to and does cause B to enter into a contract that terns out to be untrue,e the other party may choose to avoid the contract
Voidable
Void contract definition
A void contract is not a contract at all. Parties not bound by it and if they transfer property under it can generally recover goods even from third party
Voidable contract definition
Contract which one party may set aside property transferred before avoidance is usually irrecoverable from a third party
When will a contract be unenforceable
where it is not in the correct form
When is oral contract not sufficient
Agreement for transfer of land and consumer credit agreements - must be in writing
Guarantee - does this need to be in writing
No - but terms must be evidenced in writing before any action is bought
Golden Ocean Group Ltd v Salgaocar Mining Industries PVT 2011
Decision - Court of Appeal recognised contracts often negotiated informally by email and held single document was not necessary, not material that no documents were traditionally signed, and typed name in email clearly signified agreement and constituted validsignature
Offer
defined promise to be bound on specific terms and is made by offeror
Is a vague statement an offer
No - unless can be rendered certain by reference to previous dealings or cusom
Is a statement which sets out possible terms of a contract an offer
No - unless offer is clearly indicated
In the course of negotiations when a vendor states price they will sell at is this an offer
Yes
Is advertising an auction will take place an offer?
No - statement of intention
What is an invitation to treat
where party is initiating negotiations, it cannot be accepted to form binding contract
An advertisement is
an invitation to treat
Goods displayed for sale in shop window/self service shelves is
an invitation to treat (if accepted by removing, couldn’t put back and would be breach)
Circulation of a price list is
an invitation to treat
Who does an offer have to be made to
class of persons or to the world at large
arils v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co 1893
Advertisement for 100 reward to anyone contracting influenzaa
valid offer capable of acceptance as not vague, and offer can be made to the workd at large
Termination of offer
Rejection
rejection by offeree terminates the offer
Termination of offer
counter offer
offeree proposes new/amended terms, terminating the original offer. this is then open to be accepted or rejected
Hyde v Wrench 1840
Counter offer - accept original offer - original offer terminated by counter offer
Stevenson v McLean 1880
Offer to sell iron Stevenson enquired whether agree to delivery spread over 2m, no reply, Stevenson accepted original, McLean had sold to third party
Held there was a contract Stevenson had enquired variation of terms, not rejected/counter offer
Termination of offer
Lapse of time
Offer may be expressed to last for a specified time, if there is no express time limit set, expires after reasonable time
Ransgate Victoria Hotel Co v Montefiore 1866
Montefiore applied for shares and paid deposit in June, in November acceptance and requested payment, Montefiore contended offer expired
Offer was for reasonable time only, five months more than that offer had therefore lapsed
Termination of offer
Revocation of offer
Offeror may revoke anytime before acceptance either expressly or implication
When does revocation initially take effect
When it is communicated to or received by the offeree (postal rule only acceptance, not revocation of offer)
Termination of offer
Failure of pre-condition
Offer may be conditional (dependent on some event occurring or change in circumstance) if that event doesn’t occur, offer can’t be accepted
Acceptance must be
unqualified agreement to all the terms of the offer. Acceptance may be made by express words to that effect by the offeree or their authorised agent or can be inferred from conduct
Brogden v Met Railway 1877
C supplied coal to D for years, D’s agent sent draft agreement for consideration and applied terms of draft to dealings, didn’t sign, C denied agreement
Held the conduct was only explicable on assumption they both agreed to terms
Felthouse v Bindley 1862
C wrote to nephew offering to buy horse, adding if I hear no more, I consider the horse mine, nephew intended to accept, did not reply
held C had no title to horse as silence is not acceptance
Acceptance made by post, communication is effective
the moment the acceptance is posted, even if delayed or lost all together
Postal rule - subject to:
Delay not attributable to offerees negligence (address incorrect);
Use of post must have been within contemplation of parties
Does postal rule apply when offeror requires acceptance ‘by notice in writing’
No - means notice actually received by offeror
Does the offeree have to be aware of the offer for acceptance to be effective
Yes
Clarke v Dunraven 1897
Both entered regatta, and undertook to obey club rules including obligation to pay for all damages caused by fouling. Dunraven’s yacht fouled Clarkes which sank and they sued for damages. Dun argued liability under merchant shipping act
Held contract created when entered yachts and accepted rules
Is intention to create legal relation required for contract
Yes
What is presumption for social, domestic and family relations
Presumed not intended to be legally binding unless clear evidence to the contrary