Chapter 13: Juvenile Justice Flashcards
Stubborn Child Law
In Massachusetts in the 1600s the “Stubborn Child Law” was enacted which called for the death penalty to be applied to male children who did not obey their parents.
Progressive Era
Between 1880 and 1920, which was known as the progressive era in the U.S., there were significant increases in the number of immigrants coming into the country which was part of the cause of surging populations in urban areas. Due to this rapid growth, one result was a large number of impoverished children roaming the streets without supervision or guidance and many fell into criminal behavior.
During the progressive era, three different types of facilities for juveniles began to emerge in the U.S.
- Houses of Refuge
- Reformatories
- Facilities for female juvenile offenders
Parens patriae
Parens patriae is a common law belief that permits the government or the state to intervene on the behalf of children for several reasons:
- To protect children from abusive parents, caretakers or legal guardians
- To act as the parent for children lacking adequate and proper care
- To act in the best interest of the child
Kent vs United States (1966)
The thrust of this decision was that juveniles must receive due process prior to juvenile authorities waiving cases to the adult court system.
In Re Gault (1967)
In the Gault case, the decision was made by the U.S. Supreme Court that those charged in juvenile court with delinquency offenses are entitled to the due process guarantees that adults receive when they are accused of crimes including the right to legal counsel and the right to confront witnesses.
In Re Winship
Winship appealed his case and the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the reasonable doubt standard must be applied in all criminal cases for both juveniles and adults.
Types of Juvenile Cases
Delinquency Cases
These cases involve juveniles who have committed actions that would be considered criminal if they were adults. There are substantial differences between the punishment and procedure for juveniles and adults accused of criminal activity. In the case of juveniles, the focus is towards rehabilitation and to avoid long-lasting negative effects.
Types of Juvenile Cases
Dependency Cases
These types of cases focus on the safety and well-being of children regarding incidents of neglect, abuse or being abandoned by parents or guardians. Most of these types of cases, specific to juvenile victims, are handled in family court settings.
Types of Juvenile Cases
Status Offense Cases
Cases of this nature relate to juveniles, specifically, whose actions, if they were adults, would not be considered a criminal violation. Examples of status offenses include truancy, curfew violations, underage drinking, running away from home, etc.
Police Options with Juveniles
Verbal or Written Warning: In certain situations it is acceptable for police officers to briefly detain juveniles, issue either a verbal or written warning and then release them from custody. This method is sometimes referred to as being warned or advised and released.
Detain the juvenile: Police officers have the discretion, in certain circumstances, to detain a juvenile, issue a verbal or written warning, and subsequently release them to the custody of their parents or a guardian.
Make a Referral: In some cases police officers will keep a juvenile offender in custody and make a direct referral to the juvenile court.
Case considerations for juvenile prosecutors or intake officers include
Offense severity
Age of the juvenile
Criminal / delinquent history of the juvenile
Amount and strength of evidence
Gender of the juvenile
Social history of the juvenile
Parents ability to control the juvenile’s behavior.
Juvenile Case Breakdown
20% of referred cases are dismissed
25% of cases are dealt with informally
55% of cases are run through the formal procedure
Informal Hearing Conditions for Juveniles
Attend a presentation or lecture that is offense appropriate
Go through a counseling program
Take classes after school
Make restitution to the victim for any damages incurred
Pay any court ordered fines or fees
Complete a specified amount of community service
Be placed on probation.
Juvenile Court Options
A plea agreement can be entered by the juvenile
Judges can divert the case
Adjudicatory hearing