CHAPTER 1: POWER, SOVEREIGNITY AND INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS Flashcards
Power
- power is the ability to influence other groups in politics and achieve outcomes
- States may be powerful in different ways: economically but not militarily and vice versa
- There is no universal definition of power
Hard Power
- Hard power: achieving aims through force (military force, sanctions)
- the largest armies, the
most advanced weapons (including nuclear weapons) and the technology - Proposed by Joseph Nye
Soft Power
- achieving aims through persuasion or influence (outreach, cultural ties)
- may take years to create
- Reliant on states’ credibility and international reputation
- Proposed by Joseph Nye
Smart Power
- Proposed by Joseph Nye
- achieving aims through force, persuasion and influence (payment, trade/aid)
Military Power Less Useful and Significant
- Unsuccessful in major conflicts since 2001
- Does not work against contemporary non-state actors or armed opposition groups
- Inter-state war is decreasing
Military Power Still Useful and Significant
- check the advance of non-state groups who threaten state sovereignty
- Intra-state war is increasing (civil wars)
- Inter-state Conflict is not nonexistent. Conflict between Russia and Ukraine, Israel and Hamas demonstrates a continuing threat
- still useful to protect civilians
Military Power and Soft Power(with examples)
- Military power is not just used to force other groups into action and is frequently used for humanitarian objectives to prevent human suffering
- 2014 – US, France and UK sent troops to Liberia to tackle the Ebola crisis
- 2009 – troops were sent to Haiti to deal with the earthquake
- 2005 – sent troops to South Asia to help deal with the tsunami
Economic Power
- Several ways e.g. Gross domestic product, GDP per person, Economic growth percentage
- Unlikely that a state will be a significant military power if not also an economic power
- States can use economic power as a form of hard power (imposing sanctions)
Structural Power(with examples)
- When states influence the political ideas, structure and framework of global politics itself
- States may wish to push others towards a more democratic, capitalist, free market model
- Ideological struggle between capitalist and communist demonstrates this
- Dominance of capitalist was largely achieved through hard power and economic success
- Examples: the Arab Uprisings, removal of authoritarian regimes
Relational Power
- When a state has a relationship with another state and uses this relationship to influence the
other state to change its behaviour - May use military, economic, hard, soft smart power to achieve its aims
- Must know the other state’s strength and weaknesses
- The three types of relational power: Threats and rewards. Controlling the agenda, Establishing preferences
Social and Cultural Power
- Globalization has made it possible for countries to export cultural resources
- Global brands are universally known but it’s Difficult to know whether brand popularity has any soft power benefit on countries
- Cultural power connects diverse populations around the world at a human level
Cyber Power
- Internet has empowered new groups both at a state and individual level
- Nation states invest in cyber security and accuse each other of launching cyber-attacks on others
- Private individuals have also launched cyber-attacks against governments and MNCs whereas Others have launched legitimate campaigns challenging state power
Gross Domestic Product
- measures the size of domestic output
GDP per person
- measures the size of the economy as a proportion of the total population
Economic Growth Percentage
- measures the annual or quarterly percentage by which a state’s economy has grown (or decreased)
Relational Power - Controlling the Agenda
- limiting the choices of the other state to reach the goal
Relational Power - Threats and Rewards
- likely to encourage the state to reach the desired goal
Relational Power - Establishing preferences
- getting the other state to want the same goals as your state
Cyber Power Examples
- Powerful blogs can be seeing during the Arab Uprisings in 2011
- WikiLeaks: leaked large volumes of secret United States government diplomatic information
Measuring Power as Resources
- by calculating the size of armies, economies, populations, etc.
- Does not consider what states do with these resources
- May be reluctant or unable to use their power resources
- States may misuse their power resources and make strategic mistakes
Measuring power as Behavioral outcomes
- piratical effect that states have when they use their power resources
- Judgement about whether sanctions (or others) have achieved desired effects
Global Distribution of Power
- Unipolar, multipolar, bipolar
- Distribution of power is an indicator of global stability
- Imbalance of power can often mean that war or conflict is more likely
Unipolar World Order
1.when one state is more powerful than all the others
- Some argue that we live in a unipolar system, with the US on top.
Multipolar World Order
- when many states are powerful and compete with each other
- some argue that our world is multipolar, with countries all over the world having significant power.
Bipolar World Order
- when two states are equally powerful, main competition is between them.
- Some argue the world is bipolar with the US and China as the two major actors.
Realism
- global politics as being dominated by states and in which states are the most important actors in global politics, usually defending and prioritizing their own national interest and security above others
- largely in terms of states’ hard power capabilities
- See states as locked in competition with each other
- Offensive and defensive realism
Offensive realism
- when states attempt to expand their power
- proposed by Waltz
Defensive realism
- when states attempt to defend themselves against external threats
- main advocate is Mearsheimer
Liberalism
- those who view global politics as benefiting from states and other actors working together, following international law, respecting human rights and having a boarder range of core interests than their own core interest
- See states as more powerful when they work together
- States should use power by conforming to a world order and institutions governed by international law and respecting human rights
Power Transition
- Power is not a fixed concept; states can become more powerful or less powerful
Rising powers
- economic rise of the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India and China)
- Achieved remarkable economic growth between 2001 and 2011
Declining Power(US?)
- Financial crisis of 2008 exposed weakness in the US economy
- Military failure in Iraq and Afghanistan made the Obama administration reluctant to use its military power in future conflicts (Syrian Assad regime in 2013)
Power Diffusion(terrorist groups)
- Islamic State and al-Qaeda have gained considerable power through online international recruitment, control over land, and ability to launch deadly terrorist attacks
- Shown no interest in negotiating with other actors
Sovereignty
- states are sovereign when they exercise supremecontrol over what happens inside their borders
- External and internal sovereignty
Internal Sovereignty
- the ability of a state to exert legitimate control over its population and manage its affairs independently
- They can decide and enforce their own laws(e.g. taxes) and decide their own trade policies(e.g. tarrifs)
External sovereignty
- when states are recognized as independent and sovereign by other states, and are not interfered with; also, their external border is respected
- often established by intergovernmental bodies, such as the United Nations
Sovereignty and Legitimacy
- A state’s sovereignty is dependent on other states recognizing the state as a state
- The Treaty of Westphalia in 1648: ideas of statehood were formally established
Montevideo Sovereignty
- Sovereign states should have (1933 Montevideo Convention):
- A permanent population
- A defined territory and borders
- Effective government
- The capacity and legitimacy to enter into relations with other states