ch 19 Breach of Contract and Remedies Flashcards
Jacob and Youngs v Kent
He contracted the firm to build something with a specified pipe, they deviated with a pipe of similar quality and price, but when he discovered this, he demanded they replace the pipes. Ruled in favor of firm
conditions + the 3 types
qualification in a contract based on a possible future event
conditions precedent, subsequent, and concurrent
condition precedent
condition that must be fulfilled before a partys performance can be required, condition preceeds absolute duty to perform
conditions subsequent
condition operates to terminate a partys absolute promise to perform, rare
concurrent conditions
when each partys perf is conditioned on the other partys perf or offer to perf; exist only when contract expressly or impliedly calls for the parties perform their respective duties simultaneously
discharge by performance
contract come to an end when both partues fulfill duties
tender
unconditional offer to perform by a person who is ready, willing, and able to do so
two type so fperformance + def
compelte - when party performs exactly as agreed
substantial performance - * in good faith performs substantially all term of a contract can enforce contract against the party
to qualify as substantial performance (4)
party must have perf in good faith
perf must not vary greatly from perf promised in contract, minor if remedied by compensation
perf must create substantially the same benefits as those promise in the contract
measure of damages of substantial performance
cost to bring obj of the contrat into compliance with its terms OR difference between perf rendered and perf that would have been rendered
performance to the satisfaction of another
often means perf need satisfy a reasonable person, unless subject matter of the contract is personal
material breach of contract v minor obligations
non performance of a contractual duty; when performance is not at least substantial
nonbreaching party duty to perf X entirely excused but sometimes suspended until breach remedied
anticipatory repudiation
is what type of breach?
before either party to a contract has a duty to perform, one of the parties refuses to carry out their contractual obligations, but repudiating party can retract the anticipatory repudiation by proper notice and restore the parties to their original obligations
Material
time for performance in relation to breach
vital -> delay destroys parties right to payment
of the essence -> time is a condition, but if no complaint, then waived
4 types of discharge by agreement
discharge by mutual recission, discharge by novation
discharge by settlement agreement, discharge by accord and satisfaction
discharge by mutual recission -
parties must make another agreement that also satisfies the legal rq for a contract
discharge by novation (4 rq, 2 types)
both parties agree to sub a 3rd party for 1 of the original parties
previous valid obligation, agreement by all parties to new contract, extinguishing old obligation, new contract - valid
express v implied (new contract terms are X consistent with old terms)
discharge by settlement agreement
will be subbed as new contract and revoke and discharge obligations udner prior contract
discharge by accord and satisfaction
parties accept perf that - diff from perf originally promised
original obligation suspended until accord fully performed, else can file suit based on either original obligation or accord
discharge by opeation of law (7)
material alteration of the contract, statue of limitation, bankruptcy, impossibility of performance, commercial impractibility, frustration of purpose, force majeure event clause
statutes of limitations (discharge)
oral contract, 2/3 yrs, wrriten, 4/5 yrs, 10-20 file recovery, sale of goods 4 yrs of breach
(dischrage) bankruptcy ->
prevents creditors from enforcing most of debtors contracts, and partial repayment does not revive debt
(discharge) impossibility of perf, 2 types
when supervening events make perrf impossible in objective sense, could not have reasonably foreseen
objective and subjective (impossible fore me, but not evryone -> doesnt discharge)
When is perf impossible? (3)
when party died/becomes incapacitated prior to perf, specific subject matter o contract - destroyed, change in law render perf illegal
(discharge) temp impossibility
perf delayed, can be discharged if substantially more burdensome for parties to perform promised acts
commercial impractibility
anticipated perf must be sig more difficult or costly and added burden of perf must not have been foreseeable by parties when contract - made
frustration of purpose
contract discharged if unforeseen supervening circumstanc emake it impossible to attiain purpose both parties had in mind when contract made
force majeure event clause
contractual provisio which excuses 1 or both parties perf obligations hwne circumstance arises which is beoyond the parties control and make perf o the contract impractival or impossible