Biological Approach to Personality Flashcards
Biological Approach to Personality - Basic Assumptions?
Personality traits:
– Reflect physiological differences
– Are largely genetically determined
– Are rooted in our evolutionary history
Pre-Scientific Approach to biological personality?
Phrenology
Regions of the brain are associated with certain functions
Modern view of Phrenology?
- It’s in the brain, not the head
- It’s not that specific
Galen’s 4 humours?
Ancient Greek physician
Though personality was a reflections of the four humours (fluids) that (he thought) make up our bodies.
Yellow Bile - bad temper, irritability (Choleric)
Black Bile - gloomy, pessimistic (Melancholic)
Phlegm - sluggish, non-excitable (Phlegmatic)
Blood - cheerful, passionate (Sanguine)
In one of theses fluids was dominant, the personality associated with that fluid would be observed
The modern biological approach mainly looks at?
Genes
Genetic Approach to Personality?
Genes are the building blocks of personality
- Inherited through evolutionary processes
– Shape personality and behavior by shaping physiological responses
– Behavioral genetics = the study of how genes shape behavior
Assumptions of Behaviour Genetics? (really important to remember) Nature vs. Nurture
Nature vs. Nurture
- Behavior (i.e. personality) is shaped, in part, by genes we inherit
- Behavior is also shaped by
- NO traits are cased entirely by nature or nurture; it’s always both
Genotypes are genetic potentialities, e.g. genes for eye color, height
Phenotypes are manifest characteristics, e.g, actual eye color and height; influenced by mix of genes and environment
Genetic determination
- If gene, then phenotype, irrespective of environment
Gene-environment interaction
- If gene and a particular environment, then a particular phenotype
Genetic Heritability? (read the textbook section about this!)
Heritability is the extent to which individual differences in a trait, within a group of people, are due to differences in genes
- Heratability can only apply to groups -> based on individual differences
- Does NOT mean how much of a trait within a single person is due to genetics
Behavioural Genetics?
- Used to identify genetic differences between individuals within a group
- Allows researchers to determine the extent to which individual differences in a trait are due to genetics and to the environment
Misconceptions about Heritability
Group differences are (most typically) NOT explained by genetic differences.
– E.g., African-American vs. Caucasian IQ
scores
– Numerous studies have found that average
IQ for U.S. African-Americans is 10 to 15
points lower than for U.S. Caucasians
– This difference has been assumed, by some,
to be due to genetics
Group differences are caused by environmental differences between groups?
The difference in average racial IQs describes when environments are matched on socio-economic status
- Average IQ for U.S. African-Americans adopted into white middle-class households is 110
– 25 points higher than average African-Americans, 10 points higher than average Caucasians
Group Differences Are Due to Different Environments?
Race differences in IQ differ by age
– No difference in infancy
– 4 point difference at age 4
– From ages 4-24 years African Americans lose 6/10th of a point per year
What’s the environmental difference between African American children and Caucasian children?
- African American children more likely to be raised by single parent
- Single parent homes less cognitively complex
- Attend schools with lower average IQ, so high achievers don’t need to achieve as high
Research on behaviour; genetics - Twin Studies?
Twin studies help us understand the importance of genetic and environmental influences on social development
- Identical (MZ) vs. Fraternal (DZ) twins
- Reared together vs. reared apart
Shared traits in identical twins - Why do Identical twins share traits?
Twin Study Research Diagram
- Monozygotic Twins
Environment: Same
Genetics: Same - Dizygotic Twins
Environment: Same
Genetics: Different
Behavioural genetics methology?
- Twin Studies: Compare concordance (similarity) of trait in MZ vs. DZ twins
- Adoption Studies: compare concordance of trait between parents and biological vs. adopted kids
- MZ Twins raised apart: Best design, simply look at the concordance of the trait, aka its heritability
Behavioural; Genetics Methodological Issues?
Twin studies
- Equal environments Assumptions; Is amount of shared environment really the same for DZ vs. MZ twins?
Adoption Studies
- Representativeness? (Higher SOC’s, more engaged parents)
- Selective placement (“I am jewish and I want my kid to go to a jewish family”)
Behavioural; Genetics Methodological More General Limitation? + 3 types of genetic dispositions
- Assumption that genes and environment are independent
- In fact, certain genotypes and environments may be associated with each other (genotype-environment correlation)
Passive, Active, Reactive
Genetic dispositions 3 types
1. Selection of certain environments (P)
2. Manipulation of the environment (A)
3. Reactions from others (R)
Behavioural genetic research? (3 important influences on personality)
Twin studies have revealed 3 important influences on personality
- Genetic influences: Genes individuals inherit from their parents
- Shared Environment: Environmental effects
shared by family members (parenting style, family environment, schools, neighborhood, material resources) - Non-shared Environment: Environmental effects unique to the individual – NOT shared by family members (illnesses, friends, teachers, being treated differently by your parents)
Uncovering Genetics and Environmental Effects with Behavioural Genetics Research?
Genetic effects
– What parents pass on to their children
– 100% shared in MZ twins, 50% in DZ twins
Environmental effects
– Shared: Family and environmental influences
that affect MZ/DZ twins similarly
– Non-shared: Family and environmental
influences that affect MZ/DZ twins differently
Heritability of personality traits?
All traits have a large genetic component
- Genetics and non-shared environment important
- Shared environment has little influence on personality
Conclusion from heritability of personality traits?
- Most personality traits have some genetic component
- Non-shared environmental experiences have a very strong impact on personality
- Shared environmental experiences have little impact on personality
-> Do parents matter??
Where do non-shared environment effects come from? New Zealand Twin Study
Measured self-esteem: two teachers reported (age 5 & 7)
Measured parent-child relationship
– Mother’s expressed emotion (child at age 5)
– Mothers spoke about each twin for 5 minutes
– Negative emotion expressed towards child coded from tapes
Does the unique parenting (non-shared environmental effect) influence self-esteem?
Parent-Child Relationship = 0.15 effect on Childs self-esteem (age 5 & &)
Variance due to genetics = 0.65 effect on Childs self-esteem (age 5 & &)
Conclusion, genetics appear to have a more significant impact on the child’s self-esteem than the parent-child relationship
Do parents matter?
- Yes
- The unique relationship between the mother and each child predicts the unique self-esteem of each child -> Non-shared environmental effect
- Kids’ personality is strongly influenced by their individual relationships and life experiences
Conclusions from behaviour genetic research?
- All personality traits are at least partially heritable
- The effect of being raised in the same family is smaller than the effect of genes
- Much of the variance in personality is not due to genes or shared family experiences
- Personality differences are strongly influenced
by unshared or idiosyncratic (individual) experiences, or unique parent-child relationship
Shared family environment does influence other aspects of a person?
Attitudes
Religious beliefs
Political orientations
Health behaviours
Strong correlation between adopted siblings on smirking and drinking tendencies
Which traits are most heritable?
Twins Separated at Birth
Very Heritable
- Neuroticism
- Imagination
- Aggression
Moderately Heritable
- Traditionalism
- Sense of Alienation
- Social Potency
Somewhat Heritable
- Achievement Orientation
- Social closeness
How can we explain heritability of personality?
Genes -> Neurotransmitters, homemoes, physiological arousal -> Thoughts and Feelings -> Personality -> Divorce
Current genetic research on personality?
– Molecular genetics (genetic markers of traits)
– Neurotransmitters (dopamine) and hormones (testosterone)
– Neuro-anatomy
Broader Issue: Genetic Determinism vs. Free Will
- Do we have any conscious control over our actions, thoughts, and personality?
- Or are we all predetermined by our genetic make-up?
Example, the concordance rates of felony convictions for identical twins (42%) is much higher than fraternal twins (13%)
Physiological Approach - How do we get from genes to personality? (Infant temperament)
Biologically based traits present at birth, example:
Excitability
Sociability
Activity level
- Infant temperament and adult personality
Some adult traits are strongly related to temperament and others are not, aka some are mostly biological and others are mostly environmental
Which personality traits have the strongest biological basis?
Extraversion and neuroticism
Adult traits related to temperament –>
Sociability + activity level (extraversion) and
Excitability (neuroticism)
Eysenck’s Theory of Personality?
Extraversion and introversion represent different levels of physiological arousal
Extraverts: Below optimal level (underaroused)
– Seek out social interactions for stimulation
Introverts: Above optimal level (overaroused)
– Avoid excessive stimulation (e.g., social
interaction)
– But, this does not mean that introverts are shy
What is the difference?
Eysenck’s Theory: Evidence
Preference for quiet environment (e.g., library)
– Introverts prefer and perform better in quiet environments
Loud music
– Extraverts set volume higher than introverts
Bedtime
– Introverts may be morning people and
extraverts night people
Recreational drug use
– Extraverts tend to use stimulants (e.g., cocaine, caffeine)
– Introverts tend to use sedatives (e.g., heroin, cannabis)
Alternate Theory: Jeffrey Gray? (Reinforcement Sensitivity)
Reinforcement Sensitivity
– How sensitive are you to rewards and punishments?
Two systems
– Behavioral Activation System (BAS) -> Sensitivity to reward
– Behavioral Inhibition System (BIS) -> Sensitivity to punishment